2 ms·
I've never heard any of these 'stop studying the brain' statements you are referring to - do you have any citations? As to the question of the soul - sure ther
by zepto 11y ago
I've never heard any of these 'stop studying the brain' statements you are referring to - do you have any citations?
As to the question of the soul - sure there exist religious people who fear that science might demystify something they think should stay mysterious.
But the fact that such people exist doesn't strengthen the argument that consciousness is just a product of a certain kind of machine.
That may yet turn out to be true, but it is simply an unproven assertion at this time. It is attractive to pursue it because we have been successful at using machines to simulate other physical phenomena.
There is zero evidence that we are close to producing consciousness in machines. We have plenty of examples of simulating independent information processing functions that are adaptive to their inputs in ways that are analogous to the brain.
To assert that this indicates that we are getting close to reproducing consciousness is to affirm the consequent - that consciousness is just a paricular kind of algorithm. That's not scientific either.
The radio analogy can't be dismissed so easily by resorting to straw men. It doesn't imply a mystical source. It simply implies that consciousness is not located in the brain. One simple non-mystical explanation for this is that consciousness is a social phenomenon.
If this turns out to be true, then it would change the nature of strong AI from a standalone 'consciousness' to something that can only exist as an extension of our collective consciousness. It also opens the door for AI to do harm to our collective consciousness even without a singularity-like self-improving AGI take off.
Machines are a metaphor. Biological processes approximate machines to the extent that we can develop machines that capture their behavior, but to date these are strictly limited.