2 ms·
I agree with most of this article, but there are some basic problems. 1) Page size alone is not the same as user experience. This is easily explained by youtub
by manigandham 11y ago
I agree with most of this article, but there are some basic problems.
1) Page size alone is not the same as user experience. This is easily explained by youtube or netflix. Videos are tens or hundreds of MBs but start instantly and you get the experience you need. Well made websites follow the same important content, navigation first approach and stream in the rest as necessary.
2) The comparison of page size and how you can fit entire Russian novels in the same size is just weird. The text of the site doesn't add up to megabytes, if it did then it would be an equivalent amount of text as those novels. The fact is that the modern web has lots of visual design and media. Even if you use CSS, people still want images, not just text. That's not a bad thing, it's just an evolution. Even this article has 1MB of images (even as just thumbnails and many not necessary). Whining about images is not helpful.
3) The thing about ad network model is just random and seems like the author has no experience in advertising itself. Either way, talk of bubbles and tracking without actually looking at all the angles and nuances is also not helpful and just derails the topic.
EDIT: author definitely loses some respect for this, I'd expect a legitimate reply: https://twitter.com/baconmeteor/status/683040882757505024 https://twitter.com/baconmeteor/status/683040882757505024
- chrisdone 11y agoPage size is part of user experience, however. If you've ever visited another part of the world where Internet is awful or tried to use 3/4G on a mobile with bad signal, you immediately start to hate web sites that take forever to load what amounts to a page of text, which, if it were merely a HTML file containing the text, would still load immediately even on dial-up quality connection or less. Most people don't know this. Programmers do, and people who remember 90's Internet. Taking this into account, comparing against books is not too weird.
- manigandham 11y agoThe point was that text is obviously much leaner and highly compressible - if you just discount the images like that then the web is already very fast. You have to take into account the entire experience and realize that images are a big part of the modern web. I definitely agree there's a major cruft problem but I believe most browsers already have the ability to disable loading images which gives the client the power to adjust for their network connection.
- pitay 11y agoAnother huge annoyance with mobile devices is webpages that load some of it then crash the browser with all the JavaScript that it loads. So on an iPad 2 using Safari, load page, crash, reload, crash, reload ...