8 ms·
How T-Mobile wanted to change itself but ended up changing the wireless industry
- allendoerfer 11y agoI find it amusing how a company that was owned by a state and had a monopoly in one of the biggest consumer markets only 20 years ago, is now treated like an underdog in the US. In Germany it is the other way around: T-Mobile recently lost the leading position to Telefonica from Spain, which is called O2 in Germany, after several mergers.
- ck2 11y agoIt's an underdog in the US because it doesn't have the infatructure that at&t and verizon do. t-mobile is usually the better value but doesn't have the towers and signal strength mvnos are changing the value part though, you can get verizon's towers and signal strength without paying verizon prices, it's just the average consumer has no clue
- maxerickson 11y agoI think the MVNOs, combined with smart phone market penetration, are the real driving force removing 2 year contracts. People aren't so bad at math that they won't eventually figure out that $200 (or less) + 24 * $40 is less than 24 * $60. I guess the price point on good enough smart phones is also at least headed below $300 (for me it's less than $200, but people like shiny things).
- allendoerfer 11y ago> It's an underdog in the US because it doesn't have the infatructure that at&t and verizon do. I get that. Still it has nearly as much employees as Verizon and AT&T combined. Telekom is one of the least start-up-like organization you can think of. Some of these employees still have the status of German Beamte and are unfireable. I do not know if you are familiar with German bureaucracy, but Kafka wrote some books about it … Nevertheless articles like this treat T-Mobile like it's a small fast-moving start-up battling against evil corporations.
- maxerickson 11y agoThe US company appears to operate largely independently from the international owner.
- selectodude 11y agoAnd they keep trying to sell it.
- MrRadar 11y agoYep. In the past five years they've had four different suitors. In 2011 it was AT&T (blocked by FCC/FTC), in 2013 is was Softbank/Sprint (could not get enough assurance from FCC/FTC the deal would not also be blocked) and Iliad (French telecom, couldn't raise enough cash to meet DT's asking price), and in 2015 it was Dish (similar situation to Softbank/Sprint). My guess for the next suitor will be a cable company like Comcast or Time Warner Cable shortly after the 600 MHz auction.
- scurvy 11y agoAs long as tmo doesn't adopt DT's peering policy, I'll be happy.
- w33ble 11y agoPre-paid plans seemed to have started their lives as a huge ripoff, and I think they still have that stigma. But MVNOs have made them an amazing value now, and T-Mobile has helped a ton too. Even buying directly from the other big three providers, the cost has come way down. I wasn't aware of any Verizon MVNOs though, it seemed like they all went away or got bought up. Mind sharing which are available?
- nqzero 11y agoi did a survey of low-cost MVNOs over the xmas break, focused on data-centric plans that cost approximately $10 per month (i use google voice). there's also a link to the full list on wikipedia, which you can sort by carrier http://blog.nqzero.com/2015/12/at-mvno-pay-as-you-go-data-plans.html http://blog.nqzero.com/2015/12/at-mvno-pay-as-you-go-data-pl...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nommm-nommm 11y agoWhen were prepaid phone plans ever a ripoff? I used prepaid going as far back as 2001 and they were a good option for light users such as myself.
- sliverstorm 11y agoT-Mobile was actually pretty rockin', the best of the bunch, in my town in Colorado. The cheapest, too! However service in rural areas and along the interstate system was awful. I was either roaming on 1X or without service entirely for very nearly the entire stretch of Cheyenne to Tahoe. I had to switch, but I think it's the right strategy for the capital-limited underdog. You only need a few towers to cover a city compared to the Great Plains or the interstates, and many people spend nearly all their time in town.
- SwellJoe 11y agoThis will change, somewhat, as the new bands come online (particularly band 12, which is at 700MHz, and so it can travel farther and through obstacles more easily than higher bands at the same power). I noticed in a tiny Texas town that my T-Mobile hotspot (which has bands 2 and 12) had very strong 4G service, while my phone and tablet (which don't) had literally no service. The drive from that town to Austin or Round Rock was also devoid of service for miles at a time on the phone and tablet, but the hotspot had it pretty much all the way. As I understand it, Verizon has historically had the strongest presence in the low frequency range, which is part of their reputation for the strongest network. Fewer towers can cover more ground more effectively at lower frequencies.
- someguydave 11y ago>As I understand it, Verizon has historically had the strongest presence in the low frequency range, Yes this is correct, and the reason they have this 'monopoly' on the low frequency range is because Verizon has been the most shrewd at getting the government to grant them licenses for this spectrum.
- MrRadar 11y agoThat's because T-Mobile US is an underdog in the US and is barely related to the international T-Mobile brand. T-Mobile US was an independent company named VoiceStream Wireless until it was purchased by Deutsche Telekom in 2001. It continued (and continues) to run as an independent subsidiary with its own CEO and board of directors. After purchasing TMUS DT neglected to invest in them for capital improvements (spectrum purchases and equipment upgrades) and they fell further and further behind the competition (at its worst they were 4th out of 4 with 33 million customers[1] to #3 Sprint's 55 million[2] and #1 Verizon's 92 million[3]) until DT tried to dump TMUS in 2011 by selling it off to AT&T. The only reason T-Mobile US is competitive today is because the FCC blocked the merger and AT&T had to pay a substantial "break-up fee" in the form of $3 billion in cash and $1 billion in wireless spectrum (which is worth substantially more today). [1]http://www.tmonews.com/2012/02/t-mobile-announces-fourth-quarter-2011-financial-results-lte-network-coming-in-2013/ http://www.tmonews.com/2012/02/t-mobile-announces-fourth-qua... [2]http://newsroom.sprint.com/news-releases/sprint-nextel-reports-fourth-quarter-and-full-year-2011-results.htm http://newsroom.sprint.com/news-releases/sprint-nextel-repor... [3] https://www.verizon.com/about/news/press-releases/verizon-reports-record-revenue-growth-4q-fueled-strong-demand-wireless-fios-and https://www.verizon.com/about/news/press-releases/verizon-re...
- keithpeter 11y agoAha, that explains it. Could we borrow John Legere for a bit here in the UK? I'd love to get rid of the landline, but I need it for a couple of gigs worth of data a month. Believe it or not, it is cheaper to pay line rental to BT and £10 a month to EE than to get that from a mobile supplier using a mifi.
- sliverstorm 11y agoIt's easy to believe. IMO wireless bandwidth will always be more expensive than wired, assuming the copper is already in the ground.
- keithpeter 11y agoI can see your point, but then, that copper wire (actually solid aluminium wire in parts of the UK) has been down there since the 1950s/60s!
- shortformblog 11y agoThe real trump card, out of T-Mobile's many offerings, is the free international roaming for texting and data usage. No other U.S. carrier offers anything nearly as good on that front. To compare: T-Mobile: http://www.t-mobile.com/optional-services/roaming.html http://www.t-mobile.com/optional-services/roaming.html (Free texting, free 2G data in 140 countries, calls 20 cents per minute, 3G data available for a fee; covers every continent except Antartica.) Sprint: http://www.sprint.com/landings/international-value-roaming/ http://www.sprint.com/landings/international-value-roaming/ (Gets closest; free roaming in 64 countries and similar price plan, but there are significant gaps: it does not cover most of Europe or Asia, and Africa and the Middle East are notable dead zones) Verizon: http://www.verizonwireless.com/landingpages/international-travel/ http://www.verizonwireless.com/landingpages/international-tr... ($10 day passes, $25 monthly plan that does not include free texting, calls $1.79 a minute, only 100 megs of data) AT&T: https://www.att.com/shop/wireless/international/roaming.html https://www.att.com/shop/wireless/international/roaming.html (Cheapest plan $30, only includes 120 megs of data, calls still $1 per minute) The company took its biggest advantage over every other U.S. carrier—its affiliation with a large international mobile conglomerate—and leveraged that into something no other carrier could pull off to the same level of coverage. A brilliant move on their part. I now make a point of recommending people switch to T-Mobile before making a big international trip.
- cs702 11y agoThe other big thing is the lack of "gotcha" fees. Since T-Mobile rolled out its new plans, there are no horror stories of customers getting stuck with ridiculous wireless bills, which is a common occurrence with other wireless carriers: http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304331204577351824213467562 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527023043312045773518...
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoAlthough interestingly, I did end up paying 3x the normal rate for the past 7 months, until I reviewed my bills again. This is how it went. They had one of those 'not really a discount' price structures going on. i.e., say the normal market price of a service is $100 a month, they'll price it at $400 per month and then say you get a 75% discount. You still pay normal market price. The contract was for 2 years. After 2 years you can call 'm up and cancel, or renew at a new price. If you don't do anything, they won't cut your service (which makes sense, that'd leave a lot of customers surprised 2 years in), but they'll 'silently renew' the contract every month indefinitely, until you cancel. So you're not actually tied into anything after those 2 years. But the shitty thing is this... after 2 years, the 'discount' price ends, and you end up paying the $400 rate. Not just that, but the original $100 'discount' rate (the normal market rate at the time, btw), was for connectivity + a phone, because I got a free iPhone included. Obviously it's not free, it was just priced into the $100 contract. Plus, after 2 years the market rate of the connectivity + phone dropped from $100 to $50, the connectivity itself cost only something like $30. So instead of paying $30, I was paying $400. I was never called up or something to discuss my options, they simply executed a silent agreement we made in 2013 in tiny letters. I made up the numbers btw, they're not as shocking but in the past 7 months I ended up paying $250 more than I should have. Legally what they did was fine, but it was really shitty and felt like a 'gotcha'. I appreciate I should keep track of when my contracts end and check my fees, but when a company exploits this, they're no longer in the business of profiting off offering me a service I want, but they're in the process of unduly extracting surplus cash for non-service above their own market rates. That's 'gotcha' fees if you ask me. Other than that, I'm really happy with T-Mobile, solid company that I've always been quite happy with. I've contacted them about the above to see if they want to meet me halfway and credit me a substantial fraction of these bs extra gotcha fees. If not I'll likely switch to a competitor, hope I won't have to.
- joneholland 11y agoI worked for TMo in the pre-Legere era. About 8 years ago. The climate was toxic. IT was just a cost center. We had multi year waterfall death march projects. I eventually resigned after most of the work was pushed to offshore contractors, the onshore teams gutted, and those that remain responsible for rewriting the crap the offshore teams produced. I ran into a old friend who is still there recently, and I was surprised to find out that despite the huge public changes under Legere, IT was still a huge mess with the same leaders pushing most of the work offshore.
- shortformblog 11y agoI can definitely see some of that, admittedly. If there was a weak point in the T-Mobile offering from the perspective of the end user, it would be the various billing interfaces. They struggle to load sometimes and the company's app offerings (particularly on iOS) are surprisingly bad considering the fact that, y'know, T-Mobile is a company that specializes in mobile communications. I think that the company's comeback has largely been driven by innovative marketing and smart business offerings, rather than the technology itself.
- akgerber 11y agoI have repeatedly been unable to pay my T-Mobile prepaid bill in the past couple months after my CC number changed, because changes via the interface seem to have just failed to persist.
- jessaustin 11y agoYou have my sympathies, but having worked at several, I'd be surprised to find an American phone company where IT didn't display those pathologies. The environment is so dominated by regulation and has been for so long that executives can't imagine IT being other than a cost center, and honestly I don't think they're wrong. Telecom profits are pursued through investment, marketing, and lobbying. Look at all the work Google has done to route around this industry -- if there were a functioning market in which numerous providers had to appeal to customers, little of that would have been necessary. There is good engineering in telecom, inside the switches, which are purchased from outside vendors.
- stcredzero 11y agoCustomers traditionally purchased phones with big subsidiaries from wireless carriers Egregious editing for a news organization.
- jessriedel 11y agoHow should it have been phrased?
- techsupporter 11y agoSubsidies, not "subsidiaries." The latter is a business term for an entity owned by another entity (Skype, A.G. is a subsidiary of Microsoft, for example).
- mixmastamyk 11y agoIndeed, it almost seems like loathing of the customer is no longer considered a good business plan. I'm surprised it took this long.
- someguydave 11y agoI was a loyal T-Mobile customer for 12 years, until I went to the apple store and paid full price for a pair of unlocked iphones. After a few weeks I got a letter from T-Mobile saying that they had taken out a loan in my name to pay for the phone I had just paid for in full. I never got the whole story about how this was even possible, but there are clearly very scammy people somewhere in the management chain at T-Mobile. I went to Verizon and got more data for less money, and since I had an Iphone 6 it was fully portable to Verizon.
- therein 11y agoI think you were too hasty at assuming malicious intentions. Sounds like it was an honest mistake that the person checking you out made or some sort of glitch. It could even be related to the data breach they've had through Experian lately.
- someguydave 11y agoThat's what I thought too, but how could a loan be taken out without an explicit contract with my signature on it? To my knowledge, I signed no such document (granted, it all took place on an apple store ipad, so who knows). Also, apple doesn't even let you purchase phones on a 'tmobile loan', they want their money up front.
- someguydave 11y agoAnd in a related point, they refused to take the loan off of my account until I went to the apple store and had the manager swear to them that I had paid in full (even though it's not possible to buy an iphone on 'loan' though apple/tmobile). When the apple rep who was helping asked the tmobile rep how it was even possible for this to happen, the tmobile guy told him 'we won't tell you how this happened' - didn't sound like an 'honest mistake' to me.