3 ms·
So, we'll move everyone into the cities, where infrastructure is also going to hell because of vast unfunded pension obligations then? Unconvinced this is a sp
by jerf 11y ago
So, we'll move everyone into the cities, where infrastructure is also going to hell because of vast unfunded pension obligations then?
Unconvinced this is a special "suburb problem". Urbanists would be ill-advised to get to triumphalist about how they don't have an unfunded obligation problem until they're sure they don't.
- matthewmcg 11y agoWhat's special about the suburbs is the lower density. A dense city, at least, has more people (and more potential tax revenue) per unit of infrastructure to offset the cost of maintenance and replacement. As you point out, there might be other governance-related problems that offset the advantages density confers.
- mcbrown 11y agoDense cities also have higher cost per unit of infrastructure. Just think about the cost of digging up a gas line in Manhattan vs. in the suburbs. Which effect dominates - revenue vs. cost? I don't know. But that article certainly doesn't do anything to illuminate the issue.
- andys627 11y agoI have no problem with people living in suburbs as long as they pay for it. Everyone else is subsidizing (too low gas tax, wars for oil, obesity epidemic weighing on health care system, free parking) and accommodating (huge roads through downtown, small sidewalks, insane parking requirements) their car oriented life styles.
- grobbles 11y agoBoy, that sure is gracious of you. Have you actually run the numbers? Or do you just feel, in your heart of hearts, that you must be subsidizing those fat cats? I mean, dropping obesity in there is a real delight.
- grobbles 11y agoUnconvinced this is a special "suburb problem". These sorts of "suburban malaise" arguments are common, and they seem incredibly light on facts. I remain convinced that people are huddled in their 500 ft2 urban apartments and rationalizing why alternatives are somehow destined for perilous failure...someday. Anecdotes abound, but my "suburb" (really an exurb, which is what people really mean when they talk about suburbs now) has absolutely no problem replacing infrastructure -- what would be a mammoth, colossally expensive undertaking in the city is no big deal. Sewers are replaced. Fiber is laid. Telecom is replaced. The city recently moved virtually all above ground wiring underground. I mean...this doesn't seem to be a problem. And my city is surrounded by a green belt, and has tax revenue that is so easily bountiful that it is forcefully shared with nearby urban areas (to help them with social services).