2 ms·
Why does that bother you? The wording doesn't seem misleading (as long as they are just using historical data, not incentivizing current production) and avoidin
by icebraining 11y ago
Why does that bother you? The wording doesn't seem misleading (as long as they are just using historical data, not incentivizing current production) and avoiding that knowledge would in fact bring more, not less harm to animals (if we include humans).
To me that sounds a very Augustinian view, in which we can never claim to be innocent of anything, because our life is shaped by past sins which we inherit. Personally, I reject that completely; we should acknowledge that actions by others in the past shape the present, but not feel ashamed of them.
- venning 11y agoThat's a good question, one that would take me a while to explain, so I'll keep it short. I did not mean to imply anything about innocence or lack of it. I guess I'm deeply bothered by proud statements of accomplishment that ignore profound and costly inheritance. PETA would never acknowledge that "cruelty-free" owes a debt to what they would term "cruelty". It's that lack of acknowledgement that bothers me.