6 ms·
> The article somehow contrives to be 18 megabytes long, including (in the page view I measured) a 3 megabyte video for K-Y jelly, an "intimate lubricant". (Wa
by mschuster91 11y ago
> The article somehow contrives to be 18 megabytes long, including (in the page view I measured) a 3 megabyte video for K-Y jelly, an "intimate lubricant".
(Warning. Swear words incoming, because the situation has grown far out of control)
Fuck websites with autoplay (or autoplay-on-hover) videos. Fuck them. Whoever has invented or implemented this crap, please resign from your post immediately.
Even in 1st world countries, people use 3G/4G with data caps to work or are in otherwise bandwidth-constrained environments (public hotspots, train/bus wifi) etc. You are screwing over your users and don't realize it.
Also, something especially Spiegel Online comes to mind: 30 secs video clip with a 25s advertising clip. Fuck you.
> Why not just serve regular HTML without stuffing it full of useless crap? The question is left unanswered.
Easy actually: because a well-defined restricted subset of HTML can be machine-audited and there is no way to abuse it. Also, Google can save resources at indexing.
- tillinghast 11y ago> Fuck websites with autoplay (or autoplay-on-hover) videos. It's not just marketing. My personal favorite is how Twitter and (shudder) Facebook are doing this on their timelines now. At least they have the decency to mute the volume, but that doesn't help with data caps.
- mschuster91 11y agoBoth services offer to disable the auto-play, but unfortunately global and not only on a certain device or depending on network environment. Hell, that 'd be a nice thing to have in HTML5 and OSes: allow the user to classify networks as "unrestricted" (fat DSL line, fibre,...) or "restricted" (mobile hotspots, tethering, metered hotspots), and expose this to websites so they can dynamically scale. Android already supports this, but no other platform. A shame.
- el_benhameen 11y agoThe Facebook app for iOS lets you choose whether to auto play on wifi+mobile data, just wifi, or not at all. One app, but it's a start.
- shiven 11y agoCould you explain some more? I'm looking for these settings on my iPhone 6S, but can't seem to locate them. Thanks.
- el_benhameen 11y agoSorry, should've included that. More > settings > account settings > videos and photos > autoplay. Nice feature, but that placement leaves a lot to be desired.
- protomyth 11y ago> Both services offer to disable the auto-play Twitter specifically won't disable autoplay for everything: The option text reads: Videos will automatically play in timelines across the Twitter website. Regardless of your video autoplay setting, video, GIFs and Vines will always autoplay in Moments.
- bazzargh 11y agoI removed Moments from the ui with Stylish the same day they launched it, and image/video previews entirely in the main timeline. The selectors you want to hide are ".expanding-stream-item:not(.open) .js-media-container", ".expanding-stream-item:not(.open) .js-adaptive-media-container", and ".moments"
- lucaspiller 11y agoWindows 8.1+ does at the OS level, I don't think it's exposed in the browser though. http://windows.microsoft.com/en-my/windows-8/metered-internet-connections-frequently-asked-questions http://windows.microsoft.com/en-my/windows-8/metered-interne...
- justaaron 11y agoPAYPAL frikkin has full-screen video autoplaying on page load... of course one can go directly to .com/login but it's mind-boggling that a financial services provider for the masses thinks that this is acceptable.
- brianwawok 11y agoI bet they did a study of 100 random users, and got more engagement with the videos. Just because we hate them doesn't mean our mom's and grandpas hate them.
- grubles 11y agoBut, I thought noscript breaks the web? What it seems like is web-devs are breaking the web. Somehow, they have turned browsing the web into a worse situation than watching cable television.
- Amezarak 11y ago> Easy actually: because a well-defined restricted subset of HTML can be machine-audited and there is no way to abuse it This is why I personally use NoScript. People often ask me "how can you stand to use NoScript on the modern web? Isn't it a huge pain to whitelist scripts? Isn't everything broken?" Nope. Most of the web works perfectly fine without loading Javascript from 35 different domains (as my local news site does). You whitelist a few webapps and you're pretty much good to go. The difference is incredible. Your browser uses a fraction of the memory. Pages load faster than you can blink. The browser never catches up or lags. Pages scroll as you expect. Audio and video never autoplay and distract you. When I briefly used NoScript on mobile, it was a miraculous life-saver that made my battery live forever. In the past couple years, however, I have noticed a new phenomenon. Remarkably - madly, in my view - there are webpages, webpages that should be simple, webpages by all appearances that consist of nothing more than a photo (maybe more than one), a byline, and a few hundred words of text, that require Javascript to load. As in, you will get a a blank page or an error message if you don't have their scripts enabled. I don't understand it. I don't want to understand it. I just want it to stop. I understand that you need Javascript and so forth to run a webapp. I'm not even asking for your webapp to be less than 5MB. Hell, make it 50MB (I just won't ever use it on mobile.) Making applications can be a lot of work, maybe yours is super complicated and requires tons of libraries or some crazy media loading in the background and autoplaying videos and god knows what else. But please, please, don't require Javascript to simply load an article and don't make a simple article 5MB. Why on Earth would you do that? How many things have to go wrong for that to happen? Who is writing these frameworks and the pages that use them?
- mschuster91 11y ago> But please, please, don't require Javascript to simply load an article and don't make a simple article 5MB. Why on Earth would you do that? No Javascript => no tracking/ads => force users to enable JS and (sometimes) disable their adblocker. It's all about money, never about technology.
- toast0 11y agoYou can track without JavaScript, but you can't just include a 3rd party service, you actually have to do the work. Same thing for ads, JavaScript isn't required (especially for text ads, although few networks will let you do server side ad requests)
- rpgmaker 11y agoFuck CNN. Fuck them. /rant
- runn1ng 11y agoThis is a pretty good extension, that will keep javascript going, while turning off autoplay (mostly). Of course doesn't work with Flash videos, but you should disable those anyway. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/disable-html5-autoplay/efdhoaajjjgckpbkoglidkeendpkolai https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/disable-html5-auto...
- tim333 11y agoI find Flashcontrol good https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/flashcontrol/mfidmkgnfgnkihnjeklbekckimkipmoe?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/flashcontrol/mfidm... Kills almost all the annoying video stuff and one click when you do want to see something. Works on CNN etc. (also if fixed horizontal junk on top of the page annoys you check out my own (5 LOC or so) thing to toggle them https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/zapfixed/jgiflpbkoefoepgmeifoglafkomgjbge?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/zapfixed/jgiflpbko...)
- dredmorbius 11y agoA surprising number of videos are served through a small number of video service provider sites (there's a different acronym for this, I can never remember it). A half-dozen or dozen entries in your /etc/hosts file will block them quite effectively. I've posted this to HN in past. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10133969 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10133969 (Including CNN. Fuck'em indeed.)
- onion2k 11y agoEven in 1st world countries, people use 3G/4G with data caps to work... _No_ mobile browser supports autoplay on videos in webpages. There used to be a hack on Android but it was closed in 5.1 (maybe earlier). Another reason to avoid native apps.
- kiiski 11y agoThat sentence wasn't limited to mobile. People (I for example) use 3G/4G with laptops too. I don't have a data cap, but in other countries those are more common.
- m_eiman 11y agoEasy actually: because a well-defined restricted subset of HTML can be machine-audited and there is no way to abuse it. Also, Google can save resources at indexing. But AMP isn't a subset of HTML, is it? They've replaced a bunch of HTML tags with their own amp-prefixed variants… IMHO it reeks of vendor lock-in, and could just as well have been made a proper HTML-subset.