3 ms·
What I don't get: why does the private sector have to be involved in insurance? In my opinion, as the right to health care is a basic human right, the state sh
by mschuster91 11y ago
What I don't get: why does the private sector have to be involved in insurance?
In my opinion, as the right to health care is a basic human right, the state should be responsible for providing its citizens with health care - and as all citizens are equal, so should the health care be.
Unfortunately, Germany isn't perfect either - privately insured patients get faster access to specialized MDs, they enjoy better quality of service (esp. dentals and glasses/eyewear) and the basic insurance (Gesetzliche Krankenkasse) is in fact a staggering number of distinct insurances, each of course carrying its own administrative bloat and its own deals with pharma companies. This may result in a doctor giving two identical receipts for medication - and because the two patients are insured at different companies, they get different generics with all the problems this causes (e.g. different colors of the pills, leading to lower stick-through rate because patients mistrust changes, or different composition leading to different absorption rate even though the medical compound is identical).
There's a shitload of money wasted in healthcare, not only in the US, and the poorest people (as always) have to suffer.
- _ak 11y agoWell, privately insured patients pay for their privilege when they're getting old, when the insurances hike up their fees to no end. Everyone knows that, but people that earn enough to qualify are in denial because it provides them with a bit more disposable income in the short run. The situation of having that many insurances is certainly bloat, but interestingly enough, it led to the situation where some of them operate with a deficit, while others operate quite efficiently. With the current legal situation, and literally hundreds of companies still being around, I'm not sure this is something that can be streamlined in the next few decades. People would lose jobs, after all.
- lintiness 11y agoif public healthcare was wonderful, there'd be no private insurance business in germany. it baffles me that people think the same government that pisses away billions on big digs, pointless fighter jets, and whatever else would magically save us billions on health care.
- grecy 11y ago>if public healthcare was wonderful, there'd be no private insurance business in Germany Private insurance companies exist in Germany, Australia, Canada, etc. because it's about choice. If everyone was given a perfectly functional Toyota Camry, people would still buy Porsches and Ferraris simply because they want the ultimate. Healthcare is no different. >it baffles me that people think the same government that pisses away billions on big digs, pointless fighter jets, and whatever else would magically save us billions on health care And yet Healthcare costs more in America than any other developed country. So the evidence is clear that when the government does it, it is cheaper.
- vonmoltke 11y ago> And yet Healthcare costs more in America than any other developed country. So the evidence is clear that when the government does it, it is cheaper. When the American government does damn near anything it costs more than when any other government in the world does something. Showing that other governments can do something cheaper does not demonstrate that the American government can as well. I have much more faith in the ability of a European government to set up a social program than I do my own.
- cpursley 11y ago> the right to health care is a basic human right Calling healthcare a human right is implying that we have the right to take from others what we need, even if indirectly via the police-power of the state (i.e., threat of violence or actual violence if necessary). To take this further, it means we have the right to a portion of another citizens labor. Now, don't get me wrong. Talking about what governments should provide their citizens as part of their benefits package is important, but calling healthcare a right is a stretch. None of the rights on the UN or US Bill of Rights involve coercion towards other citizens to provide said rights.
- ja30278 11y agoWhenever someone says that some rivalrous resource is a 'basic human right', I have a hard time taking them seriously. As I get older, I have mellowed a great deal, and I understand how smart people can reasonably disagree about a large number of things...but I honestly can't fathom how intelligent people can fail to grasp that you can't possibly have a 'right' to a finite, tangible resource which you yourself don't produce.
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoHealthcare is not a finite or tangible resource, it is a service provided by medical professionals. It isn't possible to run out of healthcare. It is possible to have a healthcare shortage, but as long as there is money to pay for running hospitals and training doctors, that won't happen. You might think that the amount of money it would take is impossibly large, but other nations provide free healthcare to 100% of their population for less money per person than we spend in the US already. If you disagree with the fundamental idea of taking money (taxes) from some people to pay for services used by others, than you may actually disagree with the entire concept of government.
- jdminhbg 11y ago> Healthcare is not a finite or tangible resource, it is a service provided by medical professionals. Medical professionals and equipment are finite, tangible resources. No matter how capitalist or socialist your health care system, you are subject to limits on how much time, energy, and money you devote to health care.