3 ms·
I think there's a valuable role for such an institution in the world, but I'm not sure why it should be the university. The vast majority of people who attend
by geofft 11y ago
I think there's a valuable role for such an institution in the world, but I'm not sure why it should be the university.
The vast majority of people who attend university don't really care about optimizing for that goal. The vast majority of people who require university attendance as a prerequisite for something else don't really, either. And the vast majority of people who provide outside funding to universities don't: they fund research, not teaching. And as a result, the vast majority of successful employees in this system are those who at best want the university to be a place where faculty and graduate students learn things, and only secondarily where undergraduates learn things.
The change to make universities, as a system, be about people who specifically care about being a better thinker would be greatly disruptive to society, and for what benefit? Those who are interested in becoming better thinkers can go to a different sort of institution.
Arguably there is such an institution already, namely graduate school. That you have to go through undergrad first is not particularly more onerous than that you have to go through grade school first. Grade school sucks a lot for people who care about learning.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIt should be university because it originally was. It evolved towards being a very elaborate vocational school. The actual vocational schools are uncool now, so you get basically the same thing from Ivy League, only less efficiently and for more money. I think both approaches are fine; what messes things up is the dissociative identity disorder the university suffers from. On one hand, it is expected to carry great traditions of scholarship. On the other, economic incentives create strong pressure to do vocational training instead. If we could split it (back) into two separate institutions, things would be much better.