8 ms·
How to fix America's financial relationship to healthcare
- anigbrowl 11y agoDirect primary care is a good thing, and I greatly appreciate you contributing your experience to this discussion. On the other hand, having grown up with a public health system (in Ireland, whose model is almost identical with the UK's NHS), I'm strongly of the opinion that the necessarily higher rates of income tax are well worth it. Why? Because when you get sick you just go the doctor, and if the doctor's clinical opinion is that you need additional care, you go to the hospital. There is no financial decision-making involved, there's no additional paperwork to be filled out (not by you anyway), and you don't have to have conversations about who's in or out of your provider network in the normal course of events. The only focus is on your clinical care and recovery needs. Is it perfect, of course not - but when you develop a medical problem, you get to focus on that rather than having to split your attention between medical, financial, and administrative worries. My experience of the American healthcare system is that while there are many sincere and selfless people working in it, the system itself is badly corrupted and wildly inefficient. One objection I've heard from opponents of single payer healthcare is that if going to the doctor is free or almost so, doctor's offices will be filled with hypochondriacs and genuinely needy patients will be crowded out. I have never seen any evidence for this claim, and it doesn't match my experience. Most people don't like going to the doctor because it makes them nervous, it's icky, and they dislike being around other sick people in the waiting room - same as everywhere. Of course there are some hypochondriacs out there, and doctors quickly become skilled at spotting them and running them off. It may be a bit harder in these days of WebMd, but I am disinclined to believe that a tiny number of hypochondriacs are the major obstacle to restructuring and industry comprising 10-15% of our economy.
- egoodz 11y agoI'd gladly pay the increased tax rate if I didn't have to deal with all the BS that surrounds using health insurance; in/out of network, deductibles, companies trying to get out of paying, etc.
- pbreit 11y agoI think the main opposition to single payer in the USA is that it's counter to some of the bedrock principles the country was founded on, such as freedom, independence, limited government and personal responsibility.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAmerica (disclaimer: I'm a US citizen, born and raised) has this delusion of rugged individualism, that everyone should pull them up by their bootstraps. In reality, everyone who is successful is simply taking advantage of those who came before them, and shared infrastructure (both the physical an economic types). I don't see Americans adverse to Medicare, which is essentially single-payer for anyone over 65. Why does being under 65 mean you should die in the street without healthcare? Single payer is cheaper/more efficient than our current system. We just need to find the political will to implement it, and cut the legs out from anyone attempting to stymie that change who is currently profiting from the status quo.
- pbreit 11y agoBecause your earnings ability declines. And dying in the street is a 100% myth.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoOn the other hand, medical bankruptcy is reality.
- pbreit 11y agoThat's what real insurance is for, currently known as "catastrophic insurance", and unfortunately being outlawed.
- kgilpin 11y agoMedical bills are the leading cause of bankruptcy in the U.S. http://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/health/medical-bills/nerdwallet-health-study-estimates-56-million-americans-65-struggle-medical-bills-2013/ http://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/health/medical-bills/nerdwall...
- its2complicated 11y agoIt's good to hear from someone that's experienced another system. I would rather have that system than one that caters to the big corporations and corrupt officials. ObamaCare just shifted the burden of the uninsured directly onto the tax payers, through subsidies, from the insurance companies and hospitals that billed higher for it. It's a BS system that allows the Obama administration to look at statistics and say, "Wow, look at how many people are insured now!" I've been unemployed for 9 months and now have to pay the individual mandate for 6 of those months. I think the Supreme Court was bought or blackmailed on that one. We need a system, but not this one and it can't be opt-in or get fined! Maybe a sales tax would work.
- Mz 11y agoAuthor here: My father and ex husband were both career military. I was married long enough to still be entitled to medical coverage through the military system. We briefly dealt with insurance and copays and all that when he was a recruiter stationed someplace without a military base. Other than that, I have had an experience of medical care closer to what many Europeans experience. I would be all for the US finding some means to institute government paid universal coverage. But I think that health insurance is too entrenched in the system for such hopes to be realistic any time soon. I think that is why the ACA chose the unfortunate path it chose: the transition directly from what we had before Obamacare to a European style solution is too harsh to be politically viable. Maybe someday the US will get on board with providing a better solution. In the mean time, direct primary care is a legal loophole in the ACA that cuts out the middleman. Perhaps if it grows enough, we can eventually move towards something more civilized. Thank you for commenting.
- anigbrowl 11y agoI fully agree - I'd like to see single-payer tomorrow, but that's as much of a cultural as an economic change and as you point out there are large entrenched interests in place already; the ACA is a flawed by still necessary beachhead onto that economic territory. If I thought it could all just be improved by fiat I'd be urging people to vote for Bernie Sanders, but I'm not - having a beautiful ideal is mind does not automatically provide the tools and resources required to attain that vision, a problem which seems lost on many of his supporters.
- rayiner 11y ago> My understanding is that health insurance originated in this country as a means to plump up employee compensation in a situation where paying more wages was not desirable. You could not entice good employees by offering them a pay raise because it bumped them up into another tax bracket and it just wasn't worth it to them. Really hard to take the article seriously when it crams so much misinformation into one paragraph. There is no such thing as "bumping you up into the next tax bracket." The marginal extra dollar might be taxed at a higher rate, but the dollars below that will be taxed the same as before. Moreover, the fact that health insurance isn't taxed now can't explain the origin of the industry. Initially, health insurance was taxed just like any other non-cash benefit. A tax break on health insurance was implemented as a way to offer some relief from the wage controls of WWII: http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2012/12/04/166434247/the-huge-and-rarely-discussed-health-insurance-tax-break http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2012/12/04/16643424.... But such a tax break wouldn't have come about if the industry didn't already exist.
- eggoa 11y agoEmployee health benefits been tax free since at least 1954, and the top marginal rates were much higher then. So WWII controls were an early factor, but marginal tax impacts were significant too.
- Zombieball 11y agoSorry, could you explain what you mean by marginal tax impacts? I assume this is something along the lines of: Employer: "We can offer you an additional $3k/year in income but it will be taxed at 40%. Or we can offer you 3k in health benefits tax free. Which do you prefer?"
- triangleman 11y agoMore like: "We can offer you $3k/year in health insurance, but your take-home income will decrease by $1.5k/year as well."
- eggoa 11y ago
- bitwize 11y agoMy dentist's office offers this. My work didn't offer dental coverage but the clinic itself offered "coverage" in the form of paying a flat fee and getting your cleanings and exams taken care of for the year (with discounts for other care). I was on that like white on rice: my money went directly to the dentist, no middleman taking their cut out of my paycheck, and my basic dental care was paid for.
- stephengoodwin 11y agoIf you don't mind me asking, how much did you pay for the "coverage"? Did it offer any kind of discount for minor or major dental work (e.g., cavity removal, wisdom tooth removal)? Or was this covered by your health insurance?
- pbreit 11y agoEmployer dental care is one of the best deals you can get. Find a dentist who optimizes for insurance and you will get back way more than what you put in. This works because few do it.
- egoodz 11y agoThe problem you face with DPC is in the US you'd have to subscribe to 2-3 different healthcare providers, your GP, a hospital and perhaps another specialist (endocrinologist, cardiologist, etc.) Unless you have a DPC membership with a provider that supplies all of that. My GP has DPC, but I still have insurance from my employer that would cover any hospital visits.
- pbreit 11y agoThis post is confused. Employer-sponsored healthcare is excluded from both payroll and income taxation which makes it very attractive for employers to offer. The author doesn't understand how marginal tax rates work. Only incremental dollars are taxed at the higher rate so it's not like you hit some taxation cliff. If health "insurance" really was "insurance" it really would be a "bet". Instead, it's become more of a payment plan with an insurance component. "Real" insurance is now called "catastrophic insurance" and is dying in the US (I think Obamacare basically outlaws it).
- triangleman 11y agoActually, high deductible health plans ($10k+ deductibles) are on the rise after Obamacare was passed.
- pbreit 11y agoDeductibles are part of it but coverage is the bigger element. What is typically referred to as "catastrophic insurance" is only available to people under 30 or with a "hardship exemption". Higher deductibles and higher coverage (i.e., higher premiums) are basically the worst of the worst situation.
- mschuster91 11y agoWhat I don't get: why does the private sector have to be involved in insurance? In my opinion, as the right to health care is a basic human right, the state should be responsible for providing its citizens with health care - and as all citizens are equal, so should the health care be. Unfortunately, Germany isn't perfect either - privately insured patients get faster access to specialized MDs, they enjoy better quality of service (esp. dentals and glasses/eyewear) and the basic insurance (Gesetzliche Krankenkasse) is in fact a staggering number of distinct insurances, each of course carrying its own administrative bloat and its own deals with pharma companies. This may result in a doctor giving two identical receipts for medication - and because the two patients are insured at different companies, they get different generics with all the problems this causes (e.g. different colors of the pills, leading to lower stick-through rate because patients mistrust changes, or different composition leading to different absorption rate even though the medical compound is identical). There's a shitload of money wasted in healthcare, not only in the US, and the poorest people (as always) have to suffer.
- _ak 11y agoWell, privately insured patients pay for their privilege when they're getting old, when the insurances hike up their fees to no end. Everyone knows that, but people that earn enough to qualify are in denial because it provides them with a bit more disposable income in the short run. The situation of having that many insurances is certainly bloat, but interestingly enough, it led to the situation where some of them operate with a deficit, while others operate quite efficiently. With the current legal situation, and literally hundreds of companies still being around, I'm not sure this is something that can be streamlined in the next few decades. People would lose jobs, after all.
- lintiness 11y agoif public healthcare was wonderful, there'd be no private insurance business in germany. it baffles me that people think the same government that pisses away billions on big digs, pointless fighter jets, and whatever else would magically save us billions on health care.
- 11y ago