4 ms·
The thing that bothers me is that they should've already made this connection. That's due to the same precedent the media should be all over: J Edgar Hoover. Ho
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
The thing that bothers me is that they should've already made this connection. That's due to the same precedent the media should be all over: J Edgar Hoover. Hoover pushed for greater power for FBI, including surveillance, to combat the communist threat. They encouraged people everywhere to tip them off with innocent people often being harassed. Sound familiar post-9/11?
Anyway, Hoover decided surveillance power had a better use: digging up dirt on politicians, media people, judges, whoever. This was back when FBI agents had to physically tap phone wires or sit outside your house. Nonetheless, with very little capabilities, he got enough dirt to blackmail Congress into increasing his power and reign for decades. So, one person already took control of Congress via unlawful use of surveillance.
Now, we have an agency that can spy on everyone and everything simultaneously with algorithms looking for juiciest tidbits? And Congress doesn't see how this could be bad for them? Even one rogue group with unlogged access to the collection tech could get enough dirt on key committees probably in weeks to months. Whole NSA could be honest except them and still a huge threat to democracy.
This is why I argue that we need to push Congress and business elites to roll back government surveillance while constantly reminding them of J Edgar Hoover precedent. I was sure they'd be spying on at least some of Congress. Articles like this only make our claims stronger. Keep asking them if they want to be working for NSA employees with copies of incriminating messages, photos, or meetups? Or do they want to keep their power over their own fiefdoms?
Gotta be in their self-interest and risks they understand. Like blackmail and how dots can be connected between them and lobbyists financiers.
- Sharlin 11y agoOf course, one possibility is that they already are blackmailing everybody...
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI agree. I brought it up on Schneier's blog. Particularly, all the things that pass quickly and without a hint of discussion. So we need a strategy to counter that, too.
- CaptSpify 11y ago"Those that don't understand history blah blah blah". And that's why we have things like The Constitution, Bill of Rights, etc. They are a focal point for us to say "Oh right, we were getting a bit emotional and got carried away. We should probably scale this back a bit."
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat should apply but apathy prevails. Whereas elites and politicians stay active on legal issues that impact them. Hence, suggesyion to focus on getting their support instead of voters.
- a3n 11y ago> Even one rogue group with unlogged access to the collection tech could get enough dirt on key committees probably in weeks to months. No power goes unused. I'm quite certain that the NSA is doing this now; no rogues required. As you point out, Hoover was the example. I'm quite sure the NSA has learned that bit of tradecraft.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoManning and Snowden showed so much access with so little monitoring that they might not even need tradecraft. My hypothesis was a USAP doing this stuff with a cover story justifying secrecy. Could evdn do it with guise of protecting Congress from foreign attack.
- CWuestefeld 11y agoThe thing that bothers me is that they should've already made this connection. It bothers me, too. But I'm not even mildly surprised. Look also at the historical record of Prohibition. There's no escaping the parallel between that and the modern (failed) War On Drugs. Prohibition caused huge suffering, and endless societal problems, and much of it was cured after the 21st Amendment. One needs to be quite stupid not to see the parallels. Maybe they're not so stupid, though. While Prohibition was quite damaging to the nation as a whole, it was a blessing to the few who were in a position (and of sufficiently flexible morals) to capitalize on it. This was the foundation for the power of many, including (implicated by circumstantial evidence) the Kennedies. I don't think it would be surprising if some of the less scrupulous understand the risks, but think that they can ride the tiger well enough themselves to make hay (and mix metaphors!) from it.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou actually have a good point. Just financially speaking, many promoters of NSA have stock or campaign contributions tied to defence contracts. They do better when DOD corruption is higher. Also the power networks to considet but they're harder to map. Finally, there's image benefits for looking like one's taking action on terrorism.