6 ms·
It's actually even more insidious than that. The behavior of the "good guy" is used to define what is acceptable and vice versa. The most glaring example of t
by lisper 11y ago
It's actually even more insidious than that. The behavior of the "good guy" is used to define what is acceptable and vice versa. The most glaring example of this was the Al Qaeda attack on the USS Cole. The Cole was a war ship in foreign waters. You cannot possibly have a more legitimate military target. Nonetheless, the attack on the Cole is invariably labelled as a "terrorist attack" because, well, it was done by Al Qaeda, and whatever Al Qaeda does is, by definition, terrorism.
By way of contrast, the United States has killed orders of magnitude more civilians than Al Qaeda ever dreamed of (well over 100,000 in Iraq alone) but this isn't terrorism because, well, we're the good guys.
- pjc50 11y agoIt wasn't in Al Quaeda territorial waters, as AQ is not a state. That's why it's terrorism. There must be better examples; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Wrath_of_God https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Wrath_of_God ?
- lisper 11y ago> It wasn't in Al Quaeda territorial waters What difference does that make? The Iraqi civilians killed by the U.S. were not in U.S. territory. In that respect the situations are exactly equivalent. > AQ is not a state. That's why it's terrorism. That is exactly the kind of rationalization I'm talking about. Why is AQ not a state? Well, one might argue that it's because they don't control any territory. But ISIS controls territory, and yet they are still not considered a state. Palestine controls territory, and they are not considered a state. Why? Simply because the people who currently run the club of human organizations called "states" have decided not to admit them. So it's a totally circular argument: these groups are "not states" and hence their violence is "terrorism" rather then "legitimate" military action simply because some powerful elites have decided not to recognize them as states. And if you want to argue that these groups are not recognized as states because of their "terrorist" actions, there are counter-examples to that too, with Tibet being the poster child. There are also "state sponsors of terrorism", a label whose attachment has nothing whatsoever to do with the actual number of civilians killed. Iran, for example, is a "state sponsor of terrorism" but the U.S. isn't despite the fact that it has killed vastly fewer civilians than the U.S. Why? Because the U.S. decides who is and is not a "state sponsor of terrorism." There are also non-state actors whose actions cause more civilian death and suffering than Al Qaeda but which are nonetheless not considered terrorist organization simply because they are the "good guys": the Catholic Church (via their opposition to family planning and sponsorship of child sexual abuse). The NRA (via their opposition to reasonable controls on guns). I could go on.