4 ms·
Some of what you point out is that macroeconomics is difficult. Even micro is difficult, because you can't just go running all the experiments on people that y
by davidw 11y ago
Some of what you point out is that macroeconomics is difficult. Even micro is difficult, because you can't just go running all the experiments on people that you'd like to, but running experiments with entire countries is "kind of" difficult.
That doesn't mean it's worthless or mostly partisan or 'religious' (that seems particularly nonsensical).
It's fair to point out that economics - like most human fields of study and endeavor - has its problems, but I do object to the broad-brush one-liner style of discussion.
- cs702 11y agoLOL. Yes, running experiments on entire countries is "kind of" difficult, to put it mildly. But the links I shared suggest the divide in macroeconomics goes well beyond that. Quoting from Romer's blog post (http://paulromer.net/mathiness http://paulromer.net/mathiness): "The goal in starting this discussion is to ensure that economics is a science that makes progress toward truth. A necessary condition for making this kind of progress is a capacity for reaching consensus that is grounded in logic and evidence. Given how deeply entrenched positions seem to have become in macroeconomics, this discussion could be unpleasant. If animosity surfaces, it will be tempting to postpone this discussion. We should resist this temptation." In the most nice and polite way possible, he's accusing his colleagues of engaging in cargo cult science.