3 ms·
See my other comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10818113 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10818113). You're confusing "religion" (or even monothe
by pron 11y ago
See my other comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10818113 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10818113). You're confusing "religion" (or even monotheistic religion) with Christianity. In Judaism, very early on (classical period, or middle ages at the latest) it was understood that the scriptures are not an exact description of the physical universe, and that the stories (like the creation story) must not be taken literally. In any event, once science came about, Judaism -- unlike Christianity -- didn't clash with it. But I guess I would still be branded a heretic on many other grounds...
- pklausler 11y agoIs the YHWH character allegorical?
- pron 11y agoThat depends on what you mean by "allegorical" (it usually means "stands for something else", but in this case whatever that something else is, we can just call that "God"), but there's much discussion (and disagreement) about the role god plays in the physical universe, if any. Just to get a sense for Jewish theology, see this quote by rabbi David Hartman: "I never had a clear concept of God. As a people with multiple traditions and different strands, today we stand before a multiplicity of models and are expected to declare which one we identify with"[1] One of the greatest modern Jewish orthodox philosopher, Y Leibowitz[2] (who was a scientist, too; a professor of biochemistry, organic chemistry and neurophysiology), believed that the Jewish god is not even necessarily personal (in the sense that he possesses a persona). He said that all questions about the nature of god are meaningless and idolatrous. He believed that the only relevant question about god is whether it is an entity worthy of worship. I.e. God is "that which should be worshiped". He also believed that the relationship between God and man is completely one sided and consists solely of man worshiping god, which in Judaism means to observing Halakha. So to him, religion was definitely not an explanation of anything, but an obligation -- a discipline -- one chooses to take upon oneself (and the observance of that obligation = belief in God). Leibowitz believed that his views simply mirrored those of Maimonides', who called them (in the 12th cetury) "negative theology". Simply put, Maimonides said that there can be no contradiction between the truths which God has revealed and the findings of the human mind in science and philosophy (simply because the two involve different realms) [3]. He even said that one cannot say that God exists, but only that God is not non-existent (which echoes modern intuitionistic logic, which lacks the axiom of excluded middle). [1]: http://hartman.org.il/Blogs_View.asp?Article_Id=33 http://hartman.org.il/Blogs_View.asp?Article_Id=33 [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yeshayahu_Leibowitz#Religious_philosophy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yeshayahu_Leibowitz#Religious_... [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maimonides#Negative_theology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maimonides#Negative_theology
- kazinator 11y agoI'm absolutely not confusing "monotheistic religion" and "Christianity", which would entail that I'm ignorant about the existence of all other monotheistic religions. The topic is Dawkins, and his focus has been Christianity. In the submitted page, he's accused of closed-mindedness in that context. A big part of Christianity is flatly believing things which are written in the Holy Bible, and so if we critically examine Christianity, that's going to be a big part of the argument. It's not an attack on the Bible as such, but its use by a group. It may be that Judaism doesn't have this same "attack surface" due to its different treatment of scriptures. Scripture or not, followers of Judaism surely must have some common beliefs which can be articulated and examined.
- pron 11y ago> Scripture or not, followers of Judaism surely must have some common beliefs which can be articulated and examined. Articulated -- definitely. Examined? I don't see how. How do you examine the belief that one should not light a fire on the Sabbath or that one should eat matzo on the first day of Passover? Jewish "belief" is simply accepting the obligation to follow a long set of rules. Prominent Jewish philosophers explicitly say that those rules have no purpose or consequence (though others disagree).