3 ms·
>>Quantum mechanics ... allows us to describe elementary particles and fundamental forces, to understand chemical reactions, and to construct lasers, transistor
by sandworm101 11y ago
>>Quantum mechanics ... allows us to describe elementary particles and fundamental forces, to understand chemical reactions, and to construct lasers, transistors, and computers.
What? So much for purifying the discussion. I know a little about the history of electronics and do not remember any discussion of quantum mechanics by those building the first computers, lasers or transistors. These were rather practical inventions based on easily observable experimentation.
The field of quantum physics certainly allows us to better understand how and why these devices work, and to improve them, but it is not responsible for their existence.
- swehner 11y agoOne explains semiconductors using quantum mechanics. Computers are constructed with semiconductors.
- sandworm101 11y agoThat was my point. The OP states that quantum mechanics "allows us to construct", not only describe.
- typon 11y agoIncorrect. Lets say I grant you that Shockley and Bardeen didn't know anything about quantum mechanics and constructed the first transistor purely due to "observable experimentation" (whatever that means), that idea is completely false today. I use and write atomistic simulators and semi-classical (finite-element analysis based) simulators to simulate modern FET devices every day as part of my research. I literally use quantum mechanics to write the algorithms behind the simulator (DFT, NEGF in my case). Moreover, if you look at the manual for Synopsys Sentaurus (which is the semi-classical simulator), they have hundreds of pages describing the derivation of their mobility models and structural models from basic quantum theory. In summary, modern transistors are most definitely constructed taking quantum mechanics into account because without it you wouldn't have transistors functioning at 90nm much less at 14nm. You wouldn't take into account gate-leakage, tunneling, stress, bandstructures, and a host of other properties of modern transistors.
- sandworm101 11y agoRead the early experiments with crystals (not wikipedia, which most deals with stuff post-patent). They didn't start with physics textbooks. They started with odd electrical behavior observed in practical experiments.
- typon 11y agoI already granted you that.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoI believe that the first lasers were explicitly based on quantum theory, not on observed macroscopic behavior. There wasn't an experiment that showed something lasing, and then trying to figure out how it worked. Instead, there was "Hey, quantum theory says this might happen - let's try it."