2 ms·
If they are using them as part of their official duties, then yes, special privileges can be reasonable. But then logically surveillance is one of the things th
by wpietri 11y ago
If they are using them as part of their official duties, then yes, special privileges can be reasonable. But then logically surveillance is one of the things they can't really object to; if they are only doing the business of government, then why shouldn't government know what they're up to?
- JackFr 11y agoBut they are not doing the business of government, they are determining what the business of government is. And in particular as Congress is a co-equal branch of government to the Presidency. Just as Congress shouldn't ask the GAO Office of Special Investigations to bug the Oval Office, the President should not have the NSA conduct surveillance on members of Congress.
- wpietri 11y agoSure, but citizens are also determining what the business of government is. "Of the people, by the people, for the people." One could argue that government shouldn't be in the business of wholesale surveillance. One could also argue that the government should be hoovering up everything, because safety (or whatever). But when lawmakers argue for wholesale surveillance of everybody except themselves, I don't think there's any sort of logical consistency there.
- vidarh 11y ago> if they are only doing the business of government, then why shouldn't government know what they're up to? The "business of government" is not a single, unified thing. The "business of government" for elected representatives involves debating and deciding when and how to change laws. Part of doing that properly may involve gathering information from people that if they fear surveillance may be unwilling or unable to communicate openly or truthfully. Consider England and Wales (specifically England and Wales, not the UK, as the laws were changed separately for England and Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland etc.). Consensual gay sex was only made legal in England and Wales in 1967. Surveillance would put anyone gay petitioning their MPs (members of parliament) at risk of legal sanctions up to and including prison and chemical castration if they were to be caught admitting to having had gay sex. For a long time afterwards, they were at risk of being imprisoned for statutory rape if they admitted to having had sex with someone over 16 (the legal age of consent for straight sex now and then), as the age of consent for homosexual sex was set higher. At the same time, MPs had a legitimate interest in hearing exactly from such constituents, whose lives were substantially affected by unfair laws. There are many issues here - not subjecting MPs to scrutiny also allows undue influence from lobbyists, or outright bribes, for examples, so there are tradeoffs both ways. But there are many situations where an elected officials duties to to their constituents may be in jeopardy if their communications are subjected to surveillance or even if people believe they are under surveillance because it creates barriers against effectively petitioning them. To take a more contemporary issue: Imagine if surveillance agencies could legitimately pick up all discussions about cannabis legalisation between constituents and lawmakers and use private admissions to lawmakers of use as evidence against the people involved. As much as it might be inadvisable for people to admit to illegal acts when talking to lawmakers, it is often certainly part of "doing the business of government" for lawmakers to listen to such admissions to get an understanding of their constituents wishes. Something they should be doing more of, not less of.
- wpietri 11y agoPersonally, I think the surveillance state is bunk, so I agree with your basic thrust here. But I still think the notion that elected representatives alone deserve special surveillance exceptions makes no sense. Representatives represent. If they can't do their work fairly while being recorded, then citizens can't either. Sure, you should be able to talk to your elected reps about how they should vote on cannabis. But if you can't talk to your friends, family, neighbors, and colleagues about an issue, then you may not even know why you should talk to your representatives or what to say.
- legel 11y agoThere's a great book called The Circle by Dave Eggers that features a scenario with representatives also under constant surveillance. It wasn't painted to be too pretty. But I would agree that accountability in the face of "corruption from special interests" is one of the greatest issues in government.