3 ms·
Is this a sensible approach: You have offered me X ordinary shares which is y % of total outstanding. I want a contract that guarantees me the same % of this
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
Is this a sensible approach:
You have offered me X ordinary shares which is y % of total outstanding.
I want a contract that guarantees me the same % of this class of shares, and the same % of any other more privileged class of shares, and I am given an opportunity to participate in every liquidation event pre public offering
Seems to cover many of the horrors people have hit?
- sokoloff 11y agoUnless you're an irreplaceable employee, you won't get that. In particular, it's unreasonable to take the initial percentage and demand the same percentage of preferred shares (or venture debt convertible into shares at the lender option). Many of these "horrors" are a reality of the angels and VCs protections that enable and are essential to the company financing. IOW, attempting to tunnel under those protections for employee benefit runs counter to the investor interests, sometimes to a degree that it would preclude investments entirely. Even the liquidity provision is problematic. Suppose investor A wants to sell their stake to investor N in a private negotiated deal. Maybe fund A is collapsing. Are they obligated to tell you the terms of their negotiations? Obligated to also purchase some of your shares at your sole discretion? How would they even know that you have such a provision?
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoVCs get dilution protection, why can't other "investors" who invest time and effort. If that dilution protection is some other form than stated, well I need to read up on it. But my general approach is that just because you are an employee not a capital investor does not mean you should just take whatever shit is doled out. Especially not these days. That whole thread is about finding better terms and protection to take options on. "They won't let you" is close to "shut up and take it". (Not the same but a bit too close for my ckmfort
- sokoloff 11y agoI don't view it as "shut up and take it", but rather "here's what we're offering; would you like to take it?" The most common form of dilution protection is the right to invest more cash in future rounds pro-rata. (So you can pay to stop being diluted.) That you might be able to get if you hold shares, but you're going to need to pay cash at each round to avoid dilution. You won't realistically be able to get it as an option holder in the employee option pool, and as a non-accredited person (by the meaning of CFR Title 17.II§230.501), I'm not sure of the legality of investing cash to protect existing holdings from dilution. (I'm not saying it's not legal; I'm just not sure as I meet at least one of those tests.) As both an employee of startups (in the past) and an angel investor (dabbler/dilettante), I can see both sides, but when I contemplate writing a check to "2 founders, an idea, and a powerpoint deck", you can imagine that many provisions of convertible/venture debt exist to make that make a tiny bit more sense and provide some limited downside protection for the "indefinitely horizontal" company trajectory. Once I invest, I have very limited input into how the CEO runs the company, but I'd advise a CEO to pass on a mid or late stage employee who is too much of a troublemaker about their options terms. Realistically, the company should not be negotiating and drafting custom options terms per employee and an employee who demands such is probably a better fit for someplace else. Quite literally, the terms of the company option plan are (often) set and modifying them is nowhere near the same as giving a signing bonus, flexible hours, a few extra vacation days, work from home on Wednesdays, or a different salary/bonus amount.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoI may have been more ... Assertive .. than I meant. Interesting. The right to invest as dilution protection I had not remembered (Is it stripe that surprised everyone by giving investors right to invest at the previous round prices?) I suppose that what I am trying to protect against is to not see dilution occur worse than that of founders. But then if you don't trust the founders that much at the outset, don't join. So, perhaps better advice is take the money not the options, and if you want a lottery ticket, start your own company. I think I will give up and form a co-operative.
- icedchai 11y agoRight. A "contract" like that will restrict their ability to raise money. They'll just move on to the next guy who knows nothing about options (most of us) and isn't so demanding.