3 ms·
> What Apple owes is clear to me: pay the standard U.S. corporate tax on the standard U.S. profits. This is exactly what they pay currently. > Do the same for
by jacobolus 11y ago
> What Apple owes is clear to me: pay the standard U.S. corporate tax on the standard U.S. profits.
This is exactly what they pay currently.
> Do the same for all countries.
This is what they just settled with the Italian government about; previously they thought they were legally in the clear paying Irish corporate taxes for profits from across the EU.
> The Apple problem is that its lawyers are deliberately avoiding using current tax codes, and instead essentially claiming that Apple is based in Ireland, then playing shell games with what counts as U.S. sales, U.S. profits, and also U.S. property. Apple ends up paying ~10% U.S. tax, rather than ~35%.
Apple does pay standard US corporate tax on profit from all US sales, the same 35% as any other company, and makes no claim that Apple, Inc. is located in Ireland. The Irish subsidiaries are money pools that collect Apple’s foreign profits, so that e.g. in Europe Apple pays VAT in each country but only small amounts of corporate taxes. They can then take that money and use it to acquire foreign companies, run their foreign retail/support operations, invest in manufacturing capital, fund overseas R&D offices, et cetera, or just hoard a pile of cash. In the US, Apple has simultaneously taken out big loans (because they currently get ridiculously low interest rates) which money they can use for capital expenditures in the US or dividends or whatever.
But Apple isn’t playing any shell games about US sales, profits, or property, per se. In my opinion you should do some basic research before making such obviously false accusations.
There’s plenty about the Irish tax setup that is questionable, and arguably Apple should repatriate more of its foreign profits back to the US and pay US corporate taxes on them. However, the discussion should be focused on what they currently do vs. what they should be forced to do by an improved tax code, not on some imaginary scenario based on what some other companies do.
- jph 11y ago> But Apple isn’t playing any shell games about US sales, profits, or property, per se. > In my opinion you should do some basic research before making such obviously false accusations. I've done research. Here are examples from news summaries and the U.S. Senate report. "Apple Inc. transferred the economic rights to its intellectual property through a cost sharing agreement with its own offshore affiliates, and was thereby able to shift tens of billions of dollars offshore to a low tax jurisdiction and avoid U.S. tax. Apple Inc. then utilized U.S. tax loopholes, including the so-called “check-the-box” rules, to avoid U.S. taxes on $44 billion in taxable offshore income over the past four years, or about $10 billion in tax avoidance per year. The hearing will also examine some of the weaknesses and loopholes in certain U.S. tax code provisions, including transfer pricing, Subpart F, and related regulations, that enable multinational corporations to avoid U.S. taxes." "In annual reports between 2009 and 2011, the company told investors it was setting aside $13.7 billion to pay federal taxes—but it has actually paid only $5.3 billion. " "The report alleges more than just the avoidance of US taxes on foreign sales of Apple’s products. It also argues that Apple is effectively sending US profits to its Irish subsidiaries, too. How? Transfer pricing. Apple has set up a cost-sharing agreement with its Irish subsidiaries that gives them a disproportionate share of the profit from research and development that occurs in the United States. From 2009 to 2012, Apple allocated $4 billion in R&D costs to its US unit, which had $38.7 billion in profits, while its Irish subsidiary had $4.9 billion in R&D costs—and $74 billion in profits." Here's a Forbes summary URLs that may interest you for more specifics that I'm reading-- feel free to provide counter-examples or point to better research if you're aware of it. http://www.forbes.com/sites/beltway/2013/05/21/the-real-story-about-apples-tax-avoidance-how-ordinary-it-is/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/beltway/2013/05/21/the-real-stor...