6 ms·
I would love for you to explain why Apples shouldn't be paying taxes in the US instead of Ireland I simply don't get it.
by ThomPete 11y ago
I would love for you to explain why Apples shouldn't be paying taxes in the US instead of Ireland I simply don't get it.
- zepto 11y agoBecause the money is not made in the US
- npizzolato 11y agoIs all that money actually made outside the US? Or is it made outside of the US in the same spirit as how Hollywood movies never make a profit?[1][2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting [2] http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/09/how-hollywood-accounting-can-make-a-450-million-movie-unprofitable/245134/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/09/how-holl...
- nodamage 11y agoTo my understanding, this is money that is actually made outside the US. If Apple (US) sells an iPhone to an American customer, they will pay US corporate income tax on the profits from that sale. However, if Apple (Italy) sells an iPhone to an Italian customer, the 'double Irish' arrangement lets them avoid paying corporate income taxes on those profits. There are two issues here: 1. Some might argue that because Apple is based in the US and the R&D for these products occurs in the US, that when Apple (Italy) sells an iPhone to an Italian customer, Apple (US) should pay taxes on those profits. This is somewhat questionable, I think. 2. When Apple (Italy) sells an iPhone to an Italian customer, they should pay Italian corporate income tax on those profits, instead of being able to wipe those profits out using licensing agreements with Apple (Ireland). This is more straightforward and is the loophole being addressed by this settlement.
- gozur88 11y ago>If Apple (US) sells an iPhone to an American customer, they will pay US corporate income tax on the profits from that sale. Except they don't, really. They use the same "double Irish" scheme in the US. Apple has offshore holding companies that own the IP for that iPhone. When a US customer buys an iPhone, much of the actual profit gets shifted to the offshore subsidiaries as an expense. That's how they ended up with $200bn offshore and only $10bn or so in the US.
- HSO 11y ago> That's how they ended up with $200bn offshore and only $10bn or so in the US. Wrong. They initiated a capital return program a few years ago and ran down their US cash holdings while taking on debt "against" part of their overseas holdings. Once you account for the debt issues, their net cash holdings are a lot lower (though still substantial). Please don't make wild accusations if you don't know what you are talking about.
- gozur88 11y agoIt's not wrong. http://appleinsider.com/articles/15/07/22/as-apples-offshore-cash-pile-reaches-190b-us-congress-moves-closer-to-multinational-tax-reform http://appleinsider.com/articles/15/07/22/as-apples-offshore... They still can't repatriate that money without paying taxes. And as of two quarters ago they still have $200bn offshore and $10bn in the US. That offshore tax horde is still growing and it's still growing as a result of Double Irish flim-flam. Don't accuse other people of not knowing what they're talking about unless you know what you're talking about.
- HSO 11y agoFor the record, I said your assertion that Apple's cash position was due to Double Irish tax maneuvers on US income is wrong, and that net cash (once you account for debt issued to pay dividends) is significantly lower, both in absolute terms and in the disparity between overseas and onshore holdings. Before the initiation of the 140bn capital return program, relative balances were less skewed and more reflective of where profits were generated. I won't respond to you again in this thread because I can't deal with people who lack basic reading comprehension, logic, and fact-checking skills.
- npizzolato 11y agoThanks for the explanation. I agree with you that (1) is rather questionable, but to me, (2) seems like a fair tax.
- iofj 11y agoWe all know the answer. Because all governments feel they should spend that money instead of Apple. And they can take it, so they should. And the more left-leaning part of the aisle has this idea that they will get to decide what that money will be spent on. So they support this. (I'm not rightist, in fact I'm probably extreme left by American standards, but I just don't believe the government is on the people's side anymore) Of course there's a million different ways to say this, many are more polite, but it all boils down to this. They want money, they have the ability to take it.
- beatpanda 11y agoYeah, or, Apple benefits handsomely from money spent on their behalf by the federal and local governments (e.g. the roads and public transit infrastructure serving their headquarters, the funding for the public universities and subsidized loans for private universities from which they draw their employees), but apparently doesn't feel any obligation for funding those benefits. It's not about "feeling that they can spend the money better", it's that government already spent the money, and Apple (and other companies) benefited from it, and now they need to pay their share.
- digbyloftus 11y ago"Their share" is exactly what's up for debate. You make it sound like the US Government has a number and they're failing to collect because Apple is strong arming them. The US Government has the largest military in the world by a far margin and Apple has roughly zero physical might. If the US wants Apples money they can easily take Apples money. Until that point they're just talking.
- gozur88 11y ago>Yeah, or, Apple benefits handsomely from money spent on their behalf by the federal and local governments (e.g. the roads and public transit infrastructure serving their headquarters, the funding for the public universities and subsidized loans for private universities from which they draw their employees), but apparently doesn't feel any obligation for funding those benefits. It's hard to see any way to do the accounting such that Apple doesn't already pay for that and more. And if you're going to start doing that kind of accounting, shouldn't governments credit Apple with the personal income taxes Apple employees pay?
- simonh 11y agoIf a phone's components are made in Korea, Japan and China, assembled in China, then sent on Greek owned ships to Europe where they are sold for Euros by European stores to European citizens and paying European sales taxes, how much tax is due in America?