4 ms·
Homme de Plume: What I Learned Sending My Novel Out Under a Male Name
- dawnbreez 11y agoNow here's the question: Who rejected her while accepting "him", and why?
- nn3 11y agoShe explains it herself. I bet it's that. >>> Third: with my name, maybe my novel was taken for “Women’s Fiction”—a dislikable name for a respectable genre—but not what I was writing. If an agent was expecting that, I’m not surprised he or she would turn away after the first page or two. A George wasn’t expected to be writing Women’s Fiction, so he was taken on his own terms. <<<
- dawnbreez 11y agoShe guesses that, but that's just one of many possibilities. Ideally, she'd send a survey--which, in turn, would only be answered by a few people. We still wouldn't know much, but we'd be closer to the truth.
- stefantalpalaru 11y agoIt's a cultural thing. Publishers only care about selling the book they are gambling on, and it's easier to do that if the author will face criticism in a manly fashion instead of crying on the phone and stop writing because readers might not like this or that.
- etiene 11y ago"face criticism in a manly fashion instead of crying on the phone"? What the actual fuck? Ugh.
- stefantalpalaru 11y agoRead the article and you'll get the reference.
- pvaldes 11y agoIn resume, the novel of a woman well known as author of books for children was rejected, when send later more polished versions of the novel under a unknown male name without traceable past the editors show finally interest. A conclusion could be: "maybe the first version was plain bad", or "maybe I'm typecast as writer", or even "Editors are intrigued by a new fresh face"; but instead is a loud: "Editors (women and men) do not want novels writen by women; but, girl, you can create an atractive male persona, and when you have their interest, brag on internet under your real name about how clever you were and how stupid and mysoginist are those editors, unable to recognise feminine talent". Not a very smart move, probably. Yep, surely editors run away when see in the title "written by Joanna Rowling" or "Patricia Highsmith". This later is in fact a nom de plume so... maybe the problem could be in the name, not in the gender. I think that this is a valuable history for HN. An interesting case of a writer trying hard to be free of the typecast jail and then succesfully boycotting herself in the last second.