3 ms·
I've got a hypothesis, but it's kinda out-there. It has to do with shifting time priorities across society. The generations that grew up in the 50s-80s could
by nostrademons 11y ago
I've got a hypothesis, but it's kinda out-there. It has to do with shifting time priorities across society.
The generations that grew up in the 50s-80s could be reasonably confident that the world a decade later would be more or less what it was before. Fashions would change, social movements would get started, more home appliances would be introduced, but as long as nuclear war never happened, the basic economic underpinnings of society wouldn't change too much. And so it made sense for them to buy things for the long term, because the purchase they made now would still be relevant & useful in 20 years.
Starting with the Netscape's IPO in 1995 and perhaps exacerbated by the fall of communism in the early 90s, that changed. Even before they came of age, Millenials had witnessed the dot-com boom & crash (in which many of their elders lost their life savings); obsolescence of PCs every 2-4 years; 9/11; the rise of MP3 sharing and then its clampdown; the rise of cellphones, their replacement by smartphones, and then the 1-2 year upgrade cycle of continually getting a new smartphone; the 2008 financial crisis; manufacturing jobs moving from the U.S. to Japan to India to Bangladesh to China to Southeast Asia; and the rise of sharing-economy companies providing services that you previously needed to buy a product for. Many have also been personally burned by investments in skills that were supposed to be a sure thing, like taking on $100K in student loan debt and not being able to get a job afterwards or landing your dream job and then being fired or laid off 3 months later.
The combined effect of all these is to send the message that the future is not worth planning for. There will be better products on the market in 2 years. There will be new services. That skillset that's so hot right now may be completely obsolete. The education that everyone says is crucial to your future won't get you a damn thing. The financial investment that's up 400% now may crash to zero tomorrow. You may have to move to a new city to find work, or to follow a significant other who needs to find work.
When the future becomes radically unpredictable, it makes sense to buy for the here-and-now, because the durable product you carefully invested in may be useless anyway.
- jacquesm 11y agoThis trend was already well underway in the 70's. Especially in things like consumer electronics, vehicles and furniture. Cheap credit drove it in the US, miniaturization (Moore's law) and cheap overseas labor added to it and drove it abroad. You can see it clearly in things like tool and machinery quality. 60's stuff is nigh on indestructible and still in use today, 70's stuff is gone as if it never existed.
- tezza 11y agoHmm. 1960s was a particularly fashionable decade so less of it was thrown away. Lots of Art Deco stuff survives (1920s) for the same reason although the manufacture was quite poor. Also Plastics technology improved and started to be widely used during the 1960s. This took into the 1970s to be widespread.
- pjc50 11y agoThis sounds very plausible to me. The world is uncertain enough that it's safer to pay for it month by month rather than risk a stranded investment in the wrong thing. The only "stable" investment is real estate, which has therefore shot up in price. Physical "durable" goods are by comparison very cheap.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's flawed reasoning. The uncertainty should cause you to save before you spend and to own rather than rent on a contract that you can't get out of. After all, even if you have a stranded investment it will not cost you more for the next x months. But a rental agreement will usually have termination conditions that need to be met and if you can't get out of it then you're much worse off than if you owned the item outright. The biggest money maker for such subscription type purchases are impulse purchases. Buy now on cheap credit, pay a premium for a long time on top of the value of the item. And for those type of purchases if you were to do them with money saved over time you probably wouldn't buy them at all. (And your life would be better, not worse, all this stuff is really owning us.)
- pjc50 11y agoI suspect we also need to look at carrying costs. Let's go back to the list from the comment above: car ownership => leases => Uber suburban homes => urban apartments vacation homes => timeshares => prepackaged "experiences" careers => gig economy pay for printers => pay for ink books => the Internet videos & DVDs => Netflix CDs => Spotify exercise bikes => gym membership building companies to last => hitting quarterly numbers. Gig economy and short-term companies are arguably not a choice but exogenous. The job for life has been replaced by "at will" redundancies. Home downsizing is clearly down to rising cost; saving up gets less and less feasible. But the move from suburbs into the centre is cultural. Home gym => gym membership I suspect is also down to increasing real estate cost. A gym is much cheaper than the incremental mortgage cost of an extra room. Media libraries => Spotify/Netflix is about increasing choice. They're not entirely replacing the library (people are buying more vinyl for totemic ownership), but replacing the radio and TV channels. Replacing someone else's limited range of choices with a much wider one. It then gets put on in the background as wallpaper. (dear god this site needs a formatting reminder and preview button)