5 ms·
Hmm, I don't understand this story and links here. Why would a very successful person with family commit suicide over police-brutality? No comprendo. The app
by mixmastamyk 11y ago
Hmm, I don't understand this story and links here. Why would a very successful person with family commit suicide over police-brutality? No comprendo.
The appropriate response would be to get even through a court of law, or even paying to have some legs broken if it were justified.
Perhaps he was depressed or mentally ill?
- Nrsolis 11y agoThere has to be something else going on when a person is confronted by the police and they decide to arrest you. I can only imagine that he was agitated somehow and may have been either mentally unstable or intoxicated. Suicide is not a normal response to being locked up by the police for a few hours.
- purplerabbit 11y agoAgreed. He was definitely in a manic state, the poor guy.
- Nrsolis 11y agoFrom http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/12/30/ian_murdock_debian_founder/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/12/30/ian_murdock_debian_f... "According to the San Francisco police, officers were called to Steiner and Union St in the city at 11.30pm on Saturday, December 26, following reports of a man trying to break into a home – that man was identified as Ian Murdock. He reportedly fought with the cops, and was given a ticket for two counts of assault and one for obstruction of an officer. The techie had been drinking, according to the police logs. A medic arrived to treat an abrasion to Murdock's forehead, and he was released so he could be taken to hospital. A few hours later, on Sunday, December 27 at 2.40am, police were called again to reports of Murdock banging on the door of a neighbor at the very same block. A medic arrived to treat him for any injuries at the scene. Next, the cops took Murdock to the county jail where he was held in a cell. Murdock was bailed later that day, on Sunday, after a bond, said to be $25,000, was paid. He died the next day."
- SwellJoe 11y agoBullshit. Police beat the shit out of people, unprovoked, every day. They murder 12 year old boys without hesitation (Tamir Rice). They'll kill a woman in her jail cell because she knew her rights and tried to exercise them (Sandra Bland). They'll chase down (stealing a car to make the chase more exciting) and execute an innocent man because he happens to be black and trying to go into the bank where he has an account (Larry Jackson, Jr.). I could type all day and not finish the list of unarmed people who did nothing wrong who are dead by the hands of cops. The number who've been beaten by police is astronomically higher. Ian is a well-known quantity, and what we know is that he was extraordinarily kind and generous. I don't believe for a second that he did anything to deserve to have a police officer beat him up. Not all police are vicious bullies, but I'm more willing to believe Ian had the misfortune to cross paths with a vicious bully than I am to believe he deserved being beaten up.
- res0nat0r 11y agoIgnoring all the nonsense from the first paragraph above, it is most likely he was having some major mental issues just due to the tweets linked here. The police were called by someone worried about him, and he is taking his anger out on them and blaming them for intervening. There is nothing in the local papers about this so far, which is usually on par unfortunately with suicide. Sad to see another person gone due to unfortunate mental/emotional issues.
- Eleutheria 11y agoYou're a fucking shill trying to impose a suicide situation when it was clearly a police murder.
- dang 11y agoWe've banned this account for breaking the HN guidelines. If you don't want it to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com.
- cthalupa 11y ago>is most likely he was having some major mental issues just due to the tweets linked here I don't think we're in any position whatsoever to say this. Was he experiencing major mental issues when he wrote the tweets? Probably. Are such mental issues feasible to occur due to abuse at the hands of police? Sure. Is it also feasible that such mental issues could result in routine policework seeming like abuse? Yes. There's not enough information available to us for it to be anything but irresponsible to speculate on whether this mental condition was the cause or the effect of whatever it was that occurred with the police.
- finid 11y agoThat's why we need to get as much info as possible, so we know what let to it.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y ago> The appropriate response would be to get even through a court of law, or even paying to have some legs broken if it were justified Do you know anything at all about police and the courts in 2015's America.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- SwellJoe 11y agoI don't now any details of what happened. But, PTSD is a real thing and it can deeply effect people. Being assaulted by police and then having them charge you for the crime of trying to protect yourself is an entirely plausible cause for PTSD. I know several activists who suffer from and have been treated for PTSD based on their past interactions with police, and some have been suicidal and needed immediate hospitalization. And, the suicide statistics of veterans suffering PTSD are horrifying. In short: Ian may have been suffering from PTSD. It may have struck very fast and very hard, so much so that his loved ones didn't have time to get him the help he needed to cope with his pain. The idea that it is not comprehensible comes from a place of privilege of never having experienced something so horrible that it caused significant damage to your mind and sense of well-being.
- dguaraglia 11y agoI don't know. Assaults of any kind tend to mess you up. Just from personal experience, the last time I was robbed (I've been robbed three times in my life, but only the last time as an adult) I remember becoming irrationally violent. I remember thinking that, had I had a gun, I would've killed "the motherfuckers" without flinching. In retrospect, I would've probably regretted that for life. I can't even imagine getting that agitated about something nowadays. And yet, at the time, it all made "perfect sense" in my head. I guess in my case I was externalizing the violence towards the assaulters, but who knows what's happened to Ian? Everything is conjecture at this point anyway.
- RapLyricsFTW 11y agoBeing violated by the police for someone such as him is probably the most violence he's experienced in his 42 years of life. It can have a very different affect vs the people who have had to deal with their whole life. A hell of a wake up call to those who think it's a unreal issue.