8 ms·
Please let's not dig up links or make speculations about what happened. He was the founder of the Debian project, let's remember him for that or other contribu
by rdtsc 11y ago
Please let's not dig up links or make speculations about what happened.
He was the founder of the Debian project, let's remember him for that or other contributions he's made to the tech community.
Debian has grown to be one of the most well known and popular Linux distribution, used in production, in the cloud, as the base for SteamOS, Ubuntu and other projects. It is and was a major part of what made Linux popular.
- poikniok 11y agoI disagree. It seems he might have died fighting for a cause. We might do well to serve his memory by thinking about and understanding his cause. To do otherwise would be to admit that we can change nothing.
- spb 11y agoI think we can stand to wait for those closest to him to release more information when they're ready.
- zipppy 11y agoThe people closest to him may never have nor look for more information.
- eddieroger 11y agoUnfortunately we don't have anything to go on - he never wrote he promised blog post, and his thread is gone. It's not our story to tell, and he didn't leave one behind. Anything we do is speculative now. Hopefully he left something for his loved ones that they can share and we can run with.
- mst 11y agoOne can honour both man and cause by grieving now and avenging later.
- rdtsc 11y ago> To do otherwise would be to admit that we can change nothing. HN allows you to post and create new topics. Maybe leave avenging and figuring out the details in a separate discussion? How about remembering something nice about him or about Debian or other stuff that's not about the exact details how he died (which it seems nobody here is 100% sure of and just goes by twitter posts, and Reddit discussions).
- finid 11y agoWell, we should at least try to find out what happened. It's the natural thing to do, and the easiest way to do that, is to dig up links related to the matter, so we know the true story.
- sp332 11y agoEasiest yes, but hardly the most accurate or sensitive.
- ewindisch 11y agoThis is a terrible loss. I've been a Debian user since Bo (1.3) and have interacted with Ian on a number of occasions. RIP What I'd like to know going forward is what we can do as a community to help when we see this happening. Ian was clearly suffering, and I know that a number of folks did their best to help. Yet, those efforts were in vain. It occurs to me now that perhaps the community could have done more? Perhaps Twitter could have done more? Perhaps I could have done more? Did HackerNews make the right call in closing that thread? I'm not seeking to assign blame, but to ask what we can do to help the next person. If there is something more the community can do to help the next person, we should identify and address it. Someone I know likes to say, "bugs in process are like software bugs, we need to file an issue and fix them". Twitter just yesterday released new policies and procedures for reporting on self-harm and harassment. I'm afraid they may not go far enough, but I'm happy to see some effort there. Perhaps the time for this conversation is too early, but I look forward to having it when the time is right.
- mbubb 11y agoExcellent points. Hard not to rage at this though. It is beyond distressing.
- rbanffy 11y agoDon't let rage cloud your judgement. If you want to be useful to whatever cause Ian was fighting for, you have to wait until it is clear what he would like you to do. Right now we know nothing.
- kragen 11y agoOn the contrary: let's dig up all the links we can so that we can find out who was responsible, and prevent it from ever happening again. Just before he died, Ian had said he was going to devote the rest of his life to fighting police brutality: http://pastebin.com/dX3VSPkM http://pastebin.com/dX3VSPkM Not only would we dishonor his memory by not digging up links and making speculations about what happened (did he commit suicide, possibly due to a brain injury from the police beatings? Or was he killed by the police? If so, by whom?), we are also putting ourselves in danger. What happened to Ian could happen to any of us. Of course we should be sensitive to his family and friends and not traumatize them further. But that's no excuse for leaving the criminals who did this to walk free and kill more of us. Don't "wait for the family to release more information". Find the information yourself, in Google Cache, on Twitter, wherever you can. It may not be there tomorrow or the day after. And don't wait until people are no longer paying attention. That's a losing public relations strategy. Seize the day.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 11y agoI meant to say, let's fight criminals tomorrow or wait for the family to release more information. Also please note this message on Debian's site from his family: "His family has asked for privacy during this difficult time and we very much wish to respect that." https://bits.debian.org/2015/12/mourning-ian-murdock.html https://bits.debian.org/2015/12/mourning-ian-murdock.html
- abtinf 11y ago> let's fight criminals tomorrow Given that Ian's twitter pointed the finger at law enforcement for inciting this, what you are really saying is let's give the police time to cover up the details of what happened, obscure or destroy evidence, recruit prosecutors to their defense, and wait for months or years while an alleged internal investigation occurs. A close relative of mine committed suicide. It was a difficult time and I empathize with the family's situation. However, assuming Ian's twitter posts bear some relation to reality and are not pure hallucinations, then the family is wrong to ask for privacy and space. To do so is to sacrifice justice for an imagined peace and to grant an undeserved mercy to those responsible.
- cakes 11y agoAgreed - as much as anyone may want to know the exact reason(s) and or the "true" story...we may never know and while some form of closure is preferred we should avoid trying to figure out ourselves
- coldtea 11y agoAgain, why not? Citizen (and internet/crowd-sourced) journalism has worked wonders in the past, getting to reveal things that happened etc. Of course we won't ever be able to read his mind, but we can find much about what happened in the incident before he decided to commit suicide.
- cakes 11y ago> but the overall incident with the police etc, is a public issue. I'm not trying to specifically argue about this point of information but we don't even know the whole of that story or if it is even related to this at this time. I'm not saying it is or is not or anything like that. Just that we really don't know anything about what happened (yet and again, if ever).
- coldtea 11y agoBut, obviously, "that we really don't know anything about what happened" is not an argument against trying to look into what happened. If anything, it's the prerequisite for wanting to look into what happened.
- hyperpape 11y agoDon't forget how Reddit smeared a dead man after Boston. There's a difference between fighting injustice and speculating based on thin evidence. I want to hear something from witnesses, family members or friends who talked to him in his final days before I start having "theories".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 11y ago>Please let's not dig up links or make speculations about what happened. Why? Seriously asking (I sometimes sneer, but I never troll). Perhaps the exact things that went through his mind to make this do this are not productive to speculate upon, but the overall incident with the police etc, is a public issue.
- spb 11y agoThe problem with digging/speculation when emotions are high in general: Person A makes a speculation. Person B interprets Person A's speculation as the most likely explanation of the situation. Persons C, D, and E overhear Person B describing Person A's speculation as fact, and start a mob over it. (Person A was wrong, by the way.) This continues to snowball until people who were originally close to the situation (and are themselves still struggling to put the pieces together) are put through even more unnecessary trauma by complete strangers, in the middle of one of the most upsetting moments of their lives. The alternative is to wait until the people most directly affected have had time to cope, get affairs in order, and figure out how to adequately convey what's happened to the greater population.
- rdtsc 11y agoBecause we don't know the details. It doesn't seem anyone does. It seems from the previous day something unpleasant thing happened based on his twitter account posts. It seems there was police involved, he used some slurs some found uncharacteristic him, he threatened to kill himself, and that might be a cause of his death. His family asked for privacy probably because they are trying to deal with this and don't want anyone online or real life to start speculating / discussing or making insinuations (he was already called "unhinged", there is a call to start arresting some cops etc). Maybe I am being silly wanted to turn this into people trying to say something positive about his life, or his contribution, maybe someone knew him. Everyone probably used or touched Debian in one form or another etc. But oh well, people want to gawk, speculate, call names, seek revenge without knowing what happened, can't stop it, I tried.
- skylan_q 11y agoPlease let's not dig up links or make speculations about what happened. Is there something you want to hide?
- abtinf 11y agoThis is the most fundamentally immoral comment I've ever read on HN. I can't even imagine the scale of community outrage if this comment were made after Aaron Swartz passing. The world has lost a tremendous value with Ian's passing, and there is evidence directly from him that he was pushed into it. It appears from his twitter feed that his dying wish was to expose a tremendous and violent injustice committed against him. Ask yourself: if evil pushed him to end his own life, then is it good or is it evil that benefits if we fail to demand a full investigation? And given the widely publicized difficulty of holding the police the account for anything, do you think there is any possibility of such an investigation without widespread and vocal community outrage?
- rdtsc 11y agoWell downvote it then and move on. > I can't even imagine the scale of community outrage if this comment were made after Aaron Swartz passing. I can, they'd call for the same thing in a thread titled "In Memoriam: Aaron Swartz" > and there is evidence directly from him that he was pushed into it. You are welcome to start new thread discussing that. > if evil pushed him to end his own life, then is it good or is it evil that benefits if we fail to demand a full investigation? This thread is probably not the place to fight the evil. We can fight the evil later, given that we find what/who this evil is. Chances are evil is not going anywhere. It will be there tomorrow. > do you think there is any possibility of such an investigation without widespread and vocal community outrage? In general outrage has to be calculated, directed at the right place, and happen at the right time. Something tells me you don't have any evidence or anything to go on and it will be just guesswork based on twitter comments and Reddit discussions. Even if you have any extra evidence that you have to discuss, ask yourself if this is the right place and time for it.
- jacquesm 11y agoAgreed completely. There are already murder accusations in this thread it is really not proper.
- cc81 11y agoDo you think his family would completely ignore any injustice? What people are saying is that you should take a deep breath before you start harassing people (which is often how these things end up). This could be a mental health issue so please just calm down before you know more.
- venomsnake 11y ago> Please let's not dig up links or make speculations about what happened. The links that were dug were extremely helpful in putting the context of what happened. I will save my strong words for later. Or other venues. First Aaron, now Ian - two wonderful guys that wanted only to bring openness to world are gone after having brief encounters with the system. Make what you will of that.
- multinglets 11y agoYou mean, links like archives of his now-removed tweets where he himself is imploring us to investigate what's happened to him? Nonsense. Absolute nonsense.