5 ms·
Previous thread about Ian Murdock: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10803924 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10803924 This news is, tragically, new in
by minimaxir 11y ago
Previous thread about Ian Murdock: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10803924 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10803924
This news is, tragically, new information. :(
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yen223 11y ago> [dead] “I'm committing suicide tonight” Seems a tad insensitive...
- colinbartlett 11y agoAll links on HN that are deleted say "[dead]" so it's just an unfortunate coincidence.
- duskwuff 11y agoIt says "[flagged]" for me, FWIW.
- gall 11y agoWould the increase in time critical public awareness had that thread not been deleted have made a difference? Perhaps the chance that it could should outweigh the urge for propriety in future admin decisions.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's an impossible thing to do right, you let it it it might turn ugly, you take it down you get this. Dang made the right call here, I've been in that position several times with camarades/ww.com and it is extremely un-nerving. The problem is that since the authorities were the apparent main cause of the problem here there would likely not be much positive effect from alerting them (something I did do in the cases where it might have made a difference and in at least one of those it did). Police are one of the more blunt instruments in the toolbox. What possibly would have helped if someone close to Ian spotted this and would have done something about it but one can easily imagine that those people all follow Ians twitter feed and would already be better informed than any of us. Secondguessing is easy.
- stefantalpalaru 11y ago> you let it it it might turn ugly Or some friend/acquaintance sees it and pays the guy a visit. But dang's comfort is more important, isn't it?
- jacquesm 11y agoWhat an absolutely ridiculous comment. Yes, some friend/acquaintance could have paid him a visit. How big do you think the chances are that HN would be the channel that would alert a friend or acquaintance of Ian that would not already be aware of this through his twitter feed? > But dang's comfort is more important, isn't it? No, it obviously isn't but he made the right call in shutting down that thread and it looks to me as if you're trying to blame Dan for the death of Ian, which is utterly reprehensible. As I wrote above there is no way to do this right but with hindsight you too would have known what to do. Fucking backseat drivers. I've been thinking really hard lately about why I feel that HN is no longer the nice place it used to be and it is comments like these that ram that home in a way that not much else ever could.
- isolate 11y agoI think that startups becoming trendy made HN trendy, and trendy anything is bad. I've been here for a long time too (I ditch my accounts) and it really does seem there's been a gradual increase of nasty children and a corresponding departure of nice adults. Whenever I go away and come back it seems worse. The worsening also seems to be marked by big events like the Reddit fiasco, that women-in-tech stuff, Steve Jobs dying, Snowden, etc. I think when pg left that was it. I just want to have conversations with intelligent people but that doesn't seem to be the point anymore.
- jacquesm 11y agoSubject of a long running thread with another HN'er. You probably are on to something with major events catalyzing the slide downward.
- 11y ago
- puredemo 11y agoAnd this is exactly why I have such a deep distaste for typical forum "moderation" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10804163 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10804163 Dang seemed to presume that everyone here would just "gawk" at Ian's issues. He assumed that Ian's cries for help would be responded to in bad faith. Had "Dang" simply left the post alone, it's very likely that some people here could have touched base with Ian and prevented this suicide from happening. Instead the thread was deleted, for no reason other than a moderator unilaterally decided to remove it based on prejudice. Now Ian is dead without anyone here being given a chance to intervene, when they would have had the opportunity if the thread front-paged.
- jacquesm 11y ago> Had "Dang" simply left the post alone, it's very likely that some people here could have touched base with Ian and prevented this suicide from happening. That is something you don't have a shred of evidence for and which indirectly lays blame for Ian's suicide with Dan and I really don't think you should be writing stuff like that here or elsewhere, it is in complete contradiction with the facts. If you think that you have the right of way here then by extension HN should from now on be renamed suicide watch and each and every twitter post about someone who writes they want to commit suicide should get top billing and be sticky until the person is tied to a stretcher somewhere. Try not to be a dick around here, it really does not help, for one it ruins the atmosphere and for another you are causing a thing that hurts to cause even more pain. And if you can't keep the bile out of your comments then simply don't comment at all.
- puredemo 11y ago>it is in complete contradiction with the facts. My statements are 100% aligned with the facts. Had the post stayed up people could have gotten in contact with Ian, he obviously knew dozens of people here. In fact, Ian specifically asked people to post to YC to bring attention to what he was going through. Then when someone did so, that post was removed, so the only attention Ian got instead was from twitter trolls who egged him on, rather than from the community he reached out to. If you don't see that as a failing you're being incredibly myopic. >extension HN should from now on be renamed suicide watch and each and every twitter post about someone Ad absurdum argument. Ian's posts weren't the attention seeking behavior of some high-school drama hound, this was clearly a legitimate meltdown by the founder of Debian, who was recently injured, someone who was a part of this community, not someone random as you suggest. That's why the post about his tweets was being upvoted -- people recognized there was a legitimate issue that needed attention. Then Dang intentionally removed the post, blinding everyone to what was happening simply because he didn't want people to "gawk." That's fairly reprehensible, in my opinion, and though I'm sure it wasn't intended that way, actions have consequences.