7 ms·
The Closed Mind of Richard Dawkins (2014)
- micwawa 11y agoJust curious, did anyone read The God Delusion and find his central argument disappointing (complete nonsense)? I read the book after he promised to reduce the probability of existence of God to the probability of something completely absurd. His argument appears to be the following. First, when the universe began there was no God (this is the assumption.) So God would have had to come into existence by random chance, sometime after the creation of the universe, which we all can agree is absurd. Therefore, no God. Booyah. In your face Intelligent Design. I read this a couple times to make sure that I was understanding it correctly. But it still seems to me that this is about as blatant an example of question-begging that you can find. He's an entertaining author, sure.
- tamana 11y agoIt is a valid argument , until you get into the math and physics of the infinite and of compact manifolds. Dawkins is a biologist. I think Dawkins was too early. In more recent years, we have identified biological pathways for how humans generate spiritual thoughts/feelings, and we have economic models for how religious beliefs exploit trust and counterfactuals (that is, if you wanted to invent a lie and make it as widespread believed as Christianity, you would do marketing tricks that look exactly like Evangelism and Cults, and then L Ron Hubbard provided empiric proof with Scientology. (which maybe is what you meant by "probability").
- micwawa 11y agoThe argument may be valid, but only as far as it argues an irrelevant case: Hardly any religious person would suggest that God came into existence sometime after the creation of the Universe. Am I missing something? You're suggesting half of the Bayesian argument: Given a universe without God, it is quite probable that religions exist. But what I would like to see is the other half: Given a universe in which (some) God exists, the current universe is nearly impossible.
- philipov 11y ago"It's a valid strawman argument" isn't my conception of a valid argument. Validity includes relevance, not just internal consistency. The point of religion is that there is no such thing as disproving the existance of god, just as there is no such thing as a valid proof of the existance of god. Religion is built on faith, which is the rejection of proof. Dawkin's faith in science is a religious view, not a scientific one.
- TrevorJ 11y agoAn interesting point. I think ultimately he has the same problem of first causes that the argument for God does. In both arguments you have to draw a box around the universe/timespan/laws you will consider and then make an assumption about the initial state. In Christianity, the box is drawn outside the universe itself by considering God to exist outside of time and space and predating the universe itself. Dawkins just draws a slightly smaller box, but neither argument is without assumptions. Besides, these arguments all sort of start on shaky ground anyway because the nature of faith is that it's not based totally on things that are empirically provable. By it's nature it isn't something that claims to be rooted in empiricism. No matter what side of the argument you fall on, at a certain point after weighing all the evidence there is a chasm you have to cross between what is actually provable, and what you believe to be true.
- matthewtoast 11y agoThe God Delusion gives a handful of arguments both for and against the existence of God. Your summary comes across as a straw-man, a misrepresentation that's supposed to convince us that the real argument is poor. Where did he make this before/after argument? Intelligent design is just one hypothesis among many to explain the complexity (the apparent "design") of the universe. But it posits the existence of an even more complex entity. If we really need intelligent design to explain where eyeballs and bird wings came from, why don't we also need an explanation of the omnipotent designer?
- micwawa 11y agoYes, there's a handful of arguments, but at some point in the introduction he says (I don't have the book in front of me, so this is my best memory) that the main argument in the book will be the Boeing 747 Gambit, presented in Chapter 4. This is why I read the book. Then, he goes on to describe how unlikely it would be for God to form completely by chance. In order for this argument to make any sense, he has to assume that God happening by chance is something happens inside of the universe (or some universe). There's a few too many straw-men running around here. I'm attempting to summarize my view of an argument, and asking if that's correct.
- jbssm 11y agoIt'a quite clear after you understand semi-advanced physics that nothing could exist before the universe started. Now, you could contest the Big Bang, but from the moment you assume it happened then I don't see nothing absurd in the sentence: "First, when the universe began there was no God" Because unlike you put it, this is NOT an assumption. If the Universe did had a beginning (and all measurement indicate it did) then this (nothing existed before, not even God) follows directly from the laws of physics. In fact Dawkins greatest problem when trying to explain people this, is exactly the one I feel when trying to explain other parts to believers. They are ignorant about certain parts of science that make what they are saying impossible, and since it's fairly advanced science, they just refuse to believe it and trying to understand it. I would welcome to discuss religion with another person from my area (astrophysics) but I've never met an astrophysicist that was religious... I guess because it would be really hard to mix both things.
- TrevorJ 11y ago>It'a quite clear after you understand semi-advanced physics that nothing could exist before the universe started. The implicit argument here is limited to the type of things that make up the universe we can see and observe. It would be most accurate to say that the things that make up the universe could not have existed before the universe started. Philosophically speaking we can't preclude the existence of things that could be of a different type, or exist outside our own universe. It's the same problem explored in Plato's cave.
- jbssm 11y agoSorry, but you just don't understand physics and cosmology. It's not about the "type of things that make up the universe we can see and observe" it's about ANYTHING that makes up for the universe, including dimensions for instance. This is exactly the issue that I was pointing. People discussing these themes don't have enough knowledge to discuss them and they enter in easy - but totally incorrect - getaways like the one you just did. And when trying to explain them the science behind it, they realize it jeopardizes their faith and refuse to learn it.
- dpweb 11y agoJust started to check it out. I'm looking forward to reading the rest of the book. I've found the common atheist arguments (ie.. people start wars in the name of religion, therefore religion is bad) usually pretty weak. The first part looked interesting. I wanted to see exactly what he is attacking, and it seems to be specifically the idea of the supernatural. He notes that Einstein has been misrepesented as a believer (didn't know that - so I learned something already!). However, I would expect a physicist, engaged in deep study of the physical world - to deny the existence of the supernatural. Doesn't accepting that kinda ruin the whole basis of their life's work? Dawkins mentioning Einstein didn't believe proves nothing. Einstein not believing something doesn't make it false. Ultimately, what it comes down to, at least for me is - we know little about the origins of the universe, not to much about even our own minds, and nothing outside of our consciousness.
- catawbasam 11y agore "Doesn't accepting that kinda ruin the whole basis of their life's work?" Not for Newton, Pascal, Maxwell, Planck, Heisenberg, John Lucas, John Eccles, or John Stewart Bell -- all religious. There is also a group who aren't religious but see reason to believe in a universal consciousness, e.g. Bohm, Schroedinger, and Penrose. Biologists seem to be more prone to deny the supernatural, presumably due to the culture wars surrounding the teaching of evolution.
- innocentoldguy 11y agoI like this quote from the article, "If science, for Darwin, was a method of inquiry that enabled him to edge tentatively and humbly toward the truth, for Dawkins, science is an unquestioned view of the world," because it hints at what I see as the biggest flaw in Dawkins' science vs. religion debate. Science is fallible. Don't get me wrong, I love science and the many wonderful things it has brought into my life, but I view it as a tool to further our understanding, rather than an absolute truth. I don't see a difference between Dawkins' faith in science (his apparent belief that science is infallible and absolute) and the religious beliefs he likes to argue against. Both require a leap of faith, don't they?
- matthewtoast 11y agoVia Wikipedia, science is defined as: > a systematic enterprise that creates, builds and organizes knowledge in the form of testable explanations and predictions about the universe. The key word being "testable". The fallibility (or falsifiability) of scientific hypotheses is the great strength of science: We can improve, or prove wrong, our understanding. Dawkins writing celebrates this, and I think it's unfair to characterize his passionate (OK, sometimes strident) advocacy as "unquestioning" fanaticism. If it's a "leap of faith" to accept the axiom that we can refine/invalidate knowledge through experimentation, then "a leap of faith" isn't a very profound deed.
- pron 11y agoDawkins's critique of religion is neither scientific nor rigorous (nor knowledgeable), and philosophy is not his strong suit. Philosophy calls for a different kind of inquisitiveness which he lacks, and it is in this sense that Dawkins is unquestioning.
- innocentoldguy 11y agoI did not define Dawkins' beliefs as fanaticism. Don't inject words into a point that I never made. What I said is that Dawkins injects a large degree of faith into his opinions on science vs. religion. Do you deny that? Dawkins himself admits that he (and science) don't know everything about the beginning of the universe, life, evolution, etc. I agree with him there. I also agree with him when he questions why we would inject God into our attempts to observe and understand natural phenomena, thus complicating our research with an attribute that cannot be observed. However, he still does use his imperfect knowledge on many scientific subjects to reach a conclusion that makes him "6.9 out of 7" sure that God doesn't exist. Whether you like to admit it or not, that is faith.
- kazinator 11y agoWhat reasons are there to believe that Richard Dawkins is not prepared to be convinced of the truth of a proposition by rational evidence? (Or if that's not the definition of "closed mind", then what is?)
- tome 11y agoSome aspects of human society and culture are not really subject to empiricism per se, literature for example. Dawkins could well say "I don't believe in the existence of literature beyond words printed on a page, until you present rational evidence". That wouldn't be an unscientific approach, but would nonetheless be closed minded, I think.
- kazinator 11y agoI don't think Dawkins disputes the existence of religion in human culture, or the role of works like the Bible as cultural artifacts. He's just opposed to the classification of fiction as non-fiction.
- kazinator 11y ago> Coarse and tendentious atheists of the Dawkins variety prefer to overlook the vast traditions of figurative and allegorical interpretations with which believers have read Scripture. Of course, because that interpretation is hand-waving nonsense: replacing the actual words with something else that you wish the words really said (at the moment), with no justification. If the interpretation is valid, why don't they replace the scriptures with properly interpreted version which pin down the real meaning, once and for all? Macroexpand all the symbolism into its concrete terms, say that "this is it", and let's discuss that. Until then, the serpent in Eden was really a snake, the apple was really an apple and so on.
- pron 11y ago> If the interpretation is valid, why don't they replace the scriptures with properly interpreted version which pin down the real meaning, once and for all? Good question, which is thoroughly discussed and answered in various religious writings. But I could ask you the opposite question: why would you assume that a text -- let alone an ancient one -- is anything but allegorical? Why would you assume that a text, by default, is literal until proven otherwise? Throughout history, there have been periods when it's been assumed that most written (let alone canonical and holy) texts are allegorical. It is your assumption that a text is literal unless proven otherwise which is recent and anachronistic. In any case, whatever your views on human texts and their default literary genre, if you believe that a god wrote your scriptures, your interpretation of them would be based on the nature of your god and his preferred writing style, no?
- pklausler 11y agoI can't wait to read these complete, unambiguous, and mutually consistent religious writings. Links, please.
- pron 11y agoWhy do they need to be complete, unambiguous and consistent? Religion isn't math (and even math isn't complete). It isn't physics either (and even physics -- and certainly its interpretations -- can be quite ambiguous). For a broad introduction to the subject, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biblical_hermeneutics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biblical_hermeneutics I found this external overview of allegorical interpretation of the bible: http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/1256-allegorical-interpretation http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/1256-allegorical-... For a more internal view, see the writings of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avivah_Gottlieb_Zornberg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avivah_Gottlieb_Zornberg
- ommunist 11y agoI recall a good definition of prayer by Mr. Bierce in this connection: “Pray, v. To ask that the laws of the universe be annulled in behalf of a single petitioner, confessedly unworthy.”
- alfapla 11y agoI wouldn't call Richard Dawkings close minded. Here's a man who abandoned a successful career in biology because he found contemplating God more rewarding.
- tome 11y agoJust found this nice counterpoint. http://www.newstatesman.com/culture/2014/10/richard-dawkins-doesn-t-deserve-fellow-atheist-s-smears http://www.newstatesman.com/culture/2014/10/richard-dawkins-...