7 ms·
I immediately thought of the "5 monkeys and a ladder" psychology study, in which the first monkey attempts to climb the ladder to get a banana and all of the mo
by danso 11y ago
I immediately thought of the "5 monkeys and a ladder" psychology study, in which the first monkey attempts to climb the ladder to get a banana and all of the monkeys are sprayed with water. Then one of the monkeys is replaced with a newcomer, who then tries to climb the ladder, but this time, the remaining original monkeys attack it. And so the replacing of the monkeys continues, until none of the monkeys knows what the deal with the ladder is and yet none attempt to climb it.
This is a popular story in dev/product culture but after a little more Googling, apparently it's apocryphal: https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/games-primates-play/201203/what-monkeys-can-teach-us-about-human-behavior-facts-fiction https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/games-primates-play/201...
- devonkim 11y agoThis appears related to learned helplessness except on a sociological basis rather than individual basis.
- taurath 11y agoAnd as a corollary the moment someone breaks an "unbreakable" record in many sports that record can sometimes be frequently broken right after.
- devonkim 11y agoCompetitive eating is a great example of this. Never really thought this carried over in general to other forms of sport / competition.
- coderzach 11y agoThe best example I can think of is in middle distance running, when Roger Bannister broke the 4 minute mile.
- kovacs 11y agoI think the best and most relevant example of this for the HN crowd might be Donkey Kong :-) Ever since the documentary "King of Kong" came out, and that douche Billy Mitchell's record was broken, there's been a stream of new records. BTW if you haven't seen "King of Kong" you owe it to yourself to watch, regardless of whether or not you're a video game person. It's hilarious.
- mattkevan 11y agoIt's a bit like when there's two cash machines, with a long queue at the first but no-one at the second. You can see people looking at it, wondering whether it's worth the humiliation of finding it's broken and having to go to the back of the queue, or the joy of finding it is working and getting one over everyone else. Often nobody cracks.
- quanticle 11y agoI had this exact experience at the movie theater, yesterday. There were two cash registers at the concession stand, but there was some ambiguity as to whether the second one was staffed. So, at first, like everyone else, I queued up at the first register. I asked around and nobody seemed to know whether the second register was open. However, I noticed that the line on this register was moving rather slowly, and not wanting to be late for my film, I decided to take a risk and walked up to the second register. Lo and behold, it was actually open, and I had my popcorn in about a minute. If I hadn't been late for my movie, I don't think I would have gone to the second register.
- klenwell 11y agoI actually come across this scenario quite often in retail outlets with poorly designed queue layouts (e.g. an H&M with with 2-4 registers behind a long counter and a single ad-hoc queue lined up in front of one of them). My reasoning is a little different (and a little more charitable I suppose in its generalization about human nature): I don't want to go step in front of the register with no one waiting in it because I don't want to look like a sociopathic jerk. I also assume that is why most people haven't done so. At the same time, I know as soon as someone does step up and do it, people will grumble but the single ad hoc queue will redistribute itself into 3 more balanced queues. I'm usually waiting for someone else to be that sociopathic jerk. What I wish is that the manager of the store gave a little more thought to this issue in the first place.
- paulddraper 11y agotl;dr Thank goodness for sociopathic jerks
- moonchrome 11y ago>apparently it's apocryphal It sounds like a fable. I know that primates are smarter than other animals but I doubt that without some strong negative association they would be able to keep up that convention when there's an obvious prize right there, especially if they got hungry.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lamby 11y ago> apparently it's apocryphal This shouldn't affect its value as a story, though.