3 ms·
Hey, if the IRS recognizes them as a religion[1], not doing so in your non-profit/religion grant system is likely to get you sued by them. In truth, that's pro
by kbenson 11y ago
Hey, if the IRS recognizes them as a religion[1], not doing so in your non-profit/religion grant system is likely to get you sued by them. In truth, that's probably how it should be. In this case, a lot of us may dislike it, but if it was reversed and Google wasn't recognizing the EFF as a nonprofit a lot of the same people would likely be in arms. It's a lot like freedom of speech, we uphold it for all not because we believe everything that is said, but because when we allow individual judgement on the matter we descend into a morass of argumentation based on peoples differing concepts of what qualifies, and the ideal is too important to allow that.
1: Yes, I know the IRS was browbeaten into it. That actually supports my initial point.
- jellicle 11y agoI don't believe that getting recognized as a religion by the IRS gives you the right to receive grants from a private company that are awarded on a competitive basis. Google will happily refuse your ad or your business for a very large number of reasons, many of them quite opaque. Google hasn't refused Scientology, and has actively encouraged them to spread their message. That's a choice they've made, not one forced on them by any law. They should accept the praise/blame for that action - they've earned it.
- jjwiseman 11y agoGoogle used to refuse Scientology ads. I think they began accepting them in 2011.
- kbenson 11y agoI'm not interested in Google becoming in arbiter of what is and is not a religion. I think it's entirely acceptable to fall back on what your national government has defined as religious and non-profit organizations, for exactly the reasons I outlined in my original comment. Similarly, I wouldn't want them making distinctions about political non-profits. I am happy they don't censor some ostensibly Democratically leaning health organizations, and I'll accept that they don't censor the NRA at the same time as the price of their neutrality.