2 ms·
> could build a team of encyclopedia-compilers OK, but if we want better science articles, we need to find a way to get practicing scientists to contribute.
by jessriedel 11y ago
> could build a team of encyclopedia-compilers
OK, but if we want better science articles, we need to find a way to get practicing scientists to contribute. You can't improve the article on quantum memory without them.
> ...that could put together a better free, online encyclopedia than Wikipedia
What's the advantage of making it separate from Wikipedia? The only one I can think of is that you can put domain experts in charge who are allowed to appeal to their expertise rather than verifiability. But in this case, you want domain-specific encyclopedias rather than general purpose ones, like the celebrated Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
- ghaff 11y agoArguably, you want better science writers to contribute who may or may not be practicing scientists. After all, the goal probably shouldn't be to replicate physics journal depth in Wikipedia but, rather, to provide a mainstream source of information for those who may have some background but are not specialists on a given topic.
- jessriedel 11y ago> ...you want better science writers to contribute who may or may not be practicing scientists. The practicing scientists don't necessarily need to be controlling the whole process, but if they aren't playing an integral roll then the encyclopedia will be bad. Even in the mainstream news, reporters know that they can't just read a few journal articles and then start writing up a popular piece. They have to interview scientists. In practice, I think the only way to do this for a reasonable price is to use non-monetary incentives (e.g., fame) to get the scientists to do at least some of the writing themselves. But maybe someone can figure out how to start a foundation that hires professional writers to interview scientists. (As an aside, this does make me wonder why, when there is a collaboration between skilled writers and skilled scientists, the writers are always in charge and use the scientists as a resource. You'd think there'd be room for a model where the scientist outlines all the bullet points and uses the writer as a resource.) > ...the goal probably shouldn't be to replicate physics journal depth in Wikipedia... The question of whether to purge all physics topics from Wikipedia that have no hope of being useful to laymen (of which there are many thousands) is more-or-less the inclusionist/deletionist debate. Personally, I don't see why you'd want to get rid of them.
- ghaff 11y ago>As an aside, this does make me wonder why, when there is a collaboration between skilled writers and skilled scientists, the writers are always in charge and use the scientists as a resource. Probably because it's the writer who is publishing the book whereas most scientists are far more focused on journal articles. That said, I'm sure that many of the well-known working scientists who also publish books had plenty of editorial help--as, indeed, do most published writers. >is more-or-less the inclusionist/deletionist debate I'm actually mostly in the inclusionist camp myself. I think notability is pretty hard to define because it's so dependent on context. Pretty much everything/everyone is notable if you get local enough.
- DanBC 11y ago> What's the advantage of making it separate from Wikipedia? You don't get sucked into half a million words on what type of dash to use in page titles.