4 ms·
Perhaps if you've drank the imaginary property kool aid. How does what they actually did differ from what I said? I see nothing about them stealing the original
by mindslight 11y ago
Perhaps if you've drank the imaginary property kool aid. How does what they actually did differ from what I said? I see nothing about them stealing the original copies or forcing people to download from them.
- ceejayoz 11y ago"Communicate within voluntary relationships" could be used to describe distributing stolen credit card numbers, hacked medical records, passing child pornography around, etc. Clearly, they're not in trouble for sending emails. The emails were simply the evidence of the crime they got caught carrying out.
- mindslight 11y agoThe downloads themselves are the communications I was referring to. The existence of encryption implies freedom of speech, especially between two private parties, is a fundamental right. Child pornography sure makes for a nice disgusting bogeyman, but at least it's rare and isolated. Unlike totalitarian policing of private interactions.
- oh_sigh 11y agoHow do you feel about people buying/selling stolen credit card numbers?
- irixusr 11y agoThat its largely a symptom of credit card companies not giving a darn about security or their customers. I get more upset by the companies getting hacked once their negligent practices come to light.
- mindslight 11y agoIs it possible for a datum to be any more intrinsically worthless than an account number? Or a system to be more broken than to authenticate by 21 digits printed right on the card? Credit card companies have had two decades to switch to an appropriate system for scalable online transactions, but why bother if they can simply screw over merchants while guilting users into thinking they're responsible for "their" number? And despite all this the subject has become a routine talking point for censorship proponents, nicely demonstrating a warped framework that prioritizes centralized whims over individual rights.
- crdoconnor 11y agoShift liability to the credit card companies and you can watch that problem take care of itself.
- anon4 11y agoIf the number is linked to me, i.e. if they're selling "anon has cc X", then that should fall under existing breach of privacy laws. If it's just the number, i.e. "A cc with number X exists", I'm ok with that. If they use the number to make purchases, that's a criminal offence separate from knowledge of the number per se. Think of it like this: seeing a person get murdered isn't a crime. Facilitating murder in any way is.