4 ms·
I was with you until here: "'that's the way we do it' doesn't hold water in my mind." One way people can mean that is pure exercise of authority. "My way or th
by wpietri 11y ago
I was with you until here: "'that's the way we do it' doesn't hold water in my mind."
One way people can mean that is pure exercise of authority. "My way or the highway." I agree that's bunk.
But there's another way to mean it. Take driving on two-way streets. It doesn't really matter which side we drive on; driving on the right works just as well as driving on the left. But it matters a lot that we pick one and stick with it. Why do Americans drive on the right? That's just the way we do it.
As somebody who used to do page layout, I appreciate the convention of putting punctuation inside. As a programmer, I appreciate the convention of putting it outside. Neither is "wrong"; they're both fine ways of dealing with something. But in a given context, I think it's important to pick one; otherwise you get editing chaos and a bad reading experience.
Since the guy is a journalism professor, it's his job to teach students how to work in a professional journalistic context. Whether or not students personally think the comma should go inside or outside is irrelevant. They need to learn how to work within an organization's professional stylebook. Those things are filled with debatable points, because if everybody saw it the same way, there'd be no reason to write down a rule for it.
In docking points here, he's doing the right thing. He's not just demanding conformance with his personal preference. He's demanding that they learn how to write like professionals.
- n0us 11y agoI intended the first meaning if my original comment wasn't clear. I agree that could be read either way and indeed, convention is useful in some situations. As far as driving on one side of the road or the other, if there were a compelling reason to switch sides of the road and it were practical to do so then it might make sense to switch. I don't believe that is the case, especially because road safety relies on a homogeneous rule set. Writing is not this way and using one style when it is appropriate does not affect the legibility of another independent body of text as long as the rule set is applied consistently in a particular body.
- wpietri 11y agoI don't think the drive-on-the-right rule is only about safety. It's also about efficiency. We could also be safe without the rule, we'd just go a lot slower. I note that we have the same stay-on-the-right rule for walking, and it'd be hard to argue that it's mainly about safety there. As the author explains, for journalists the rule is widely consistent by country, which is a sign that, as with driving, there's something pushing us toward consistency. Given that there's a switching cost, and given that journalists change employers (and often write for multiple publications), and given that material gets reused between publications), I think there's good reason to have widespread agreement.