2 ms·
Nobody is accused here. Let's not get too excited. Privilege is a loaded word so I should have used another one perhaps. Privilege is strategic position of adv
by rdtsc 11y ago
Nobody is accused here. Let's not get too excited.
Privilege is a loaded word so I should have used another one perhaps. Privilege is strategic position of advantage. You have or have access to time, money, wealth, power, super-power etc that other don't have. And it is relative.
I'd say tech people have that power compared to workers in an Amazon warehouse. We can work from home, can demand our own salaries, jump to cool exciting companies. Don't have to break our backs. Instead of thinking about what to feed the children with we think what type of Apple watch to buy etc.
So far we haven't talked how each individual or cohort as a whole reached that level. Some worked hard, some didn't. Some got lucky by picking the right field to go on. Some were just passionate about a hobby (me). Some were bullied and got to spend more time inside (me) and apparently OP.
> Privileged? Even an average person has to overcome a ridiculous amount of adversity to be successful.
And now if they live in a Western country, with a great healthcare, good weather, police protection. They are privileged compared to those that are being bombed, raped, or are starving in many parts of the world.
And my point is, looking back those people will say "I am here because I worked hard and everyone one else who is complaining is kind of lazy and should have worked hard as ". I say "it's complicating" and people will often attribute too much to their hard work and discount luck, and other factors -- family connections, good neighborhood, safe area, a good health insurance, maybe a specific literacy program promoted by their government, or other factors (even negative ones like "I was bullied nerd so I was in the house more and that gave a me a chance to focus more on study").
> Instead, I think it's much more effective to use "lucky" or "fortunate".
Those are good to describe how they got to the position of privilege. Which often has a mix of things like luck, hard work, and others. That is why used the word. Using something like "strategic life advantage" sounds a bit odd though.
- marknutter 11y ago> And my point is, looking back those people will say "I am here because I worked hard and everyone one else who is complaining is kind of lazy and should have worked hard as That's a ridiculous straw man. I don't think anyone in this thread would agree with that statement. > Those are good to describe how they got to the position of privilege. Which often has a mix of things like luck, hard work, and others. That is why used the word. Using something like "strategic life advantage" sounds a bit odd though. Of course we all rely on a bit of luck and help from others. But the problem with telling someone you've never met before that they need to "check their privilege" is that you don't know a thing about them. It's offensive in exactly the same way that accusing the poor of being lazy is. If you don't take the time to get to know someone and learn about what they've been through and why they are where they are then you don't get to say things like "you're lazy" or "you're privileged". If you'll pardon my French, "you don't fucking know me".
- rdtsc 11y ago> "I am here because I worked hard and everyone one else who is complaining is kind of lazy and should have worked hard as Nobody here does but it is a common attitude, I have heard it many times from conservative acquaintances and family. This phenomenon was epitomized by the "welfare queen" PR term in US in the 90s and early 2000s, and to some extend I believe "unwed single mother" in UK. It as a figure put up a prototype of how poor people are just waiting for handouts, are lazy and if they just work harder would be successful business owners. > to "check their privilege" I didn't say that. Is that a strawman I see ;-) ? > If you don't take the time to get to know someone and learn about what they've been through I didn't direct my comments at anyone in particular. I responded to a comment because they brought an interesting point my mind but I didn't accuse or insult them. What I said in general is that there is a tendency for people who have made it to ascribe their results to their hard work and willpower even if in reality it was a complicated mix of country they were born, parents, good networking (friends), etc. > If you'll pardon my French, "you don't fucking know me". Alrighty then...
- marknutter 11y ago> It as a figure put up a prototype of how poor people are just waiting for handouts, are lazy and if they just work harder would be successful business owners. Kind of like how the social justice crowd has put up a prototype of rich white people as being privileged, uncaring, willfully ignorant, and unsympathetic. It kind of sucks to be generalized, doesn't it? > > to "check their privilege" I didn't say that. Is that a strawman I see ;-) ? Good Lord, pedant much? I knew when I wrote that phrase I should have worded it differently but I gave you too much credit. You know what I mean – I'm talking about people, like you, who like to remind other people of their privilege. > I didn't direct my comments at anyone in particular. I responded to a comment because they brought an interesting point my mind but I didn't accuse or insult them. That's exactly my point. You directed your comments at large swaths of people whom you know nothing about. It's like me saying "poor minorities are just lazy". > > If you'll pardon my French, "you don't fucking know me". Alrighty then... Are you struggling with this conversation? I would hope that you understood by "you" I meant anybody who tries to generalize me with statistics, and not "you" rdtsc.
- xiaoma 11y agoIt does seem like you've somewhat oddly-defined the word. Would you also apply it to a chess player who has even material and two passed pawns 35 moves into a game? That would be a strategic position of advantage. Or how about a Roman general picking apart less nimble Greek phalanxes with a manipular legion? Would you apply the word there?