3 ms·
That's a really good argument - and emphasises the value of living in one country over another - very reminiscent of city state style arbitrage. I feel there i
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
That's a really good argument - and emphasises the value of living in one country over another - very reminiscent of city state style arbitrage.
I feel there is another "fair" - that of paying the same percentage of income or wealth as everyone else. This is easier to explain and appeals to a more monkey brain part of us.
As an example (from the cbsnews link)
While the tax rate on dividends has since jumped to 20
percent for people earning more than $400,000 annually,
that's still far below the tax imposed on wages for
America's highest earners.
20 percent on dividends !? That can't be right ? In the UK we get the same rate as all other income (40 rising to 45).
Can I move ?
- twoodfin 11y agoDoes your boss ever say to you: "We're having a really bad year. Instead of paying you $50,000, I'm going to have to pull $50,000 out of your savings account"? That's the difference between taxes on investments and on income. Investors are risking loss in a way that workers are not: If your boss stops paying you, you stop working.
- rayiner 11y agoI don't see how the risk is relevant. If you lose $50,000 as an investor, you can carry that forward as a loss to offset future gains.
- malyk 11y agoBut society provides an unfair distribution of the benefits of society. A black male born in west Oakland doesn't receive nearly the societal benefit as a white male born to a family a couple miles away in Peidmont. So why should we tax the first guy at the same percentage of the second when the second is receiving extremely more than the first?