4 ms·
It always is the appeal to fairness - if the folks at the top get away with it, it's like Soviet Dachas, Popes with mistresses etc. The top must be made to be
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
It always is the appeal to fairness - if the folks at the top get away with it, it's like Soviet Dachas, Popes with mistresses etc. The top must be made to be equal if society is to be equal.
The how - is what is in the wind - international cooperation.
- rosser 11y ago...if society is to be equal. What you're missing is that people who are in favor of these kinds of shenanigans tend also to be emphatically against this "equality" rubbish.
- twoodfin 11y ago"Get away with" paying $56M in taxes annually? That was the average "top 400" taxpayer bill in 2012. https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/12intop400.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/12intop400.pdf Life in the U.S. is good, but nobody is getting an "unfair" allocation of all the great benefits and opportunities the federal government provides if they're paying $56M for it.
- rayiner 11y agoThe average income of the top 400 taxpayers is $335 million/year. Had those people been born and grown up in Bangladesh, instead of the U.S., I doubt it would be 1/10th as much, if that. So $56 million a year doesn't sound so bad for the privilege of living in a society that enables wealth creation like few others.
- twoodfin 11y agoNeither would $100M or $200M. And for someone making $50,000, paying a 50% effective rate sounds like a great deal compared to living in Bangladesh. I don't think that argument implies anything about what rates should be, which makes me wonder exactly what it's supposed to demonstrate.
- rayiner 11y agoPresumably, it's "fair" to tax people somehow proportionally to the amount of benefit they derive from living in the U.S. with its government. If someone would make $10 million were they born in Bangladesh, but make $100 million having been born in the U.S, that excess $90 million is a benefit they derive from the U.S. and it's fair to tax them up to $89 million of that. They're still $1 million better off than the baseline. Now, that's the limit of what's morally "fair." What's "optimal," taking into account competing developed countries, may be a lot lower. But taxing up to that limit is "fair."
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoThat's a really good argument - and emphasises the value of living in one country over another - very reminiscent of city state style arbitrage. I feel there is another "fair" - that of paying the same percentage of income or wealth as everyone else. This is easier to explain and appeals to a more monkey brain part of us. As an example (from the cbsnews link) While the tax rate on dividends has since jumped to 20 percent for people earning more than $400,000 annually, that's still far below the tax imposed on wages for America's highest earners. 20 percent on dividends !? That can't be right ? In the UK we get the same rate as all other income (40 rising to 45). Can I move ?
- twoodfin 11y agoDoes your boss ever say to you: "We're having a really bad year. Instead of paying you $50,000, I'm going to have to pull $50,000 out of your savings account"? That's the difference between taxes on investments and on income. Investors are risking loss in a way that workers are not: If your boss stops paying you, you stop working.
- rayiner 11y agoI don't see how the risk is relevant. If you lose $50,000 as an investor, you can carry that forward as a loss to offset future gains.
- ryandrake 11y agoIn 2012, the top 400 earners reported average income of $335.7 million [1]. $335 million! The ultra-wealthy get a huge allocation of "benefits and opportunities" from the government, much more than anyone else. $56M seems like a fantastic deal, as it pays for the system that is set up pretty much entirely to ensure these top earners make gobs and gobs of money forever. 1: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-400-highest-earning-americans-very-very-good-year/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-400-highest-earning-american...