3 ms·
The Laffer Curve deftly illustrates that lower tax rates can result in higher revenue than higher tax rates. The hypothetical does not demonstrate that there is
by maxerickson 11y ago
The Laffer Curve deftly illustrates that lower tax rates can result in higher revenue than higher tax rates. The hypothetical does not demonstrate that there is a single sweet spot, and as noted in the Wikipedia article The shape of the curve is uncertain and disputed.
It could well be that current taxes rates are at a point on the Laffer Curve where increasing tax rates would increase revenue.
- cbeach 11y agoPersonally I think tax and welfare should just be simplified to a flat rate of tax and a universal basic income to all citizens. That way we avoid welfare being a trap (no welfare is lost when the claimant gets a job). And we simplify both the collection of tax and the payment of welfare, saving significant cost. Finland are going to pilot this: http://finlandpolitics.org/2015/11/05/710/ http://finlandpolitics.org/2015/11/05/710/ I think it's an idea that could appeal to both the Right (like myself) and the Left.
- SilasX 11y agoThat cuts both ways. The more complex you claim the curve's shape is, the less confidence you have in "tax cuts reduce revenue" as well. So what's the bottom line? "hey, we shouldn't cut taxes because we might just be moving to a different sweet spot"?
- maxerickson 11y agoThe bottom line is that the Laffer Curve as a concept should be dismissed as a rhetorical device and we should demand an elucidation of the likely consequences of tax cuts and tax increases given our current situation. (The CBO spends a lot of their time doing exactly that, scoring bills and whatnot)
- SilasX 11y agoThe fact that there are diminishing revenue-returns and (socially) wasteful behavioral responses to taxation is not at all theoretical, but has tangible implications for policy. Even the very CBO you cite is implicitly recognizing these effects. Both a $0 and a $1 million tax on shoes will raise approximately zero revenue. Why is is the former so much better? Your answer is going to make the very same points elucidated by the Laffer Curve.
- maxerickson 11y agowe should demand an elucidation of the likely consequences of tax cuts and tax increases given our current situation. isn't exactly a rejection of your first paragraph there. It's basically a synonym for tangible implications for policy. And dismissed as a rhetorical device doesn't mean it is useless, it just means that the concept itself isn't worth a whole lot in a policy discussion, at least not once you've got everyone in the discussion to agree that cutting taxes can be beneficial (which I hope is not usually something that requires much discussion).