8 ms·
> The JVM is already open source. From what I understand open source and imunity from litigation are orthogonal. Open source code and still be a patent minefie
by rdtsc 11y ago
> The JVM is already open source.
From what I understand open source and imunity from litigation are orthogonal. Open source code and still be a patent minefield.
- pron 11y agoOpenJDK has a full patent grant[1]. It is 100% open source in every way possible, its use is unrestricted, and it is released under the same license as Linux. AFAIK, Oracle has never sued anyone making use of it for whatever purpose whatsoever. It is important to remind the undisputed fact that -- at least so far -- Google has chosen not to use OpenJDK (or, in any case, they did not comply with its license), and therefore its open source status is irrelevant to the court case. [1]: That grant is automatic, by the open source license. In addition (and unrelated to OpenJDK), there is an explicit patent grant to conformant implementations of Java (be they based on OpenJDK or not).
- rdtsc 11y agoI see, good point. I was saying in general, if something is released as open source, that doesn't usually come with a default immunity from patent litigation.
- rewqfdsa 11y agoOf course, if you don't conform, Oracle will sue you into oblivion. Java is free software as long as you use it in exactly the way Oracle wants, right? It's for this reason that Java is poison to any of my projects. I'll choose Node-fucking-JS over Java, because nobody is going to sue me for using JavaScript the way I want.
- pjmlp 11y agoNo one expects JavaScript to run unchanged across all VMs anyway.
- pron 11y ago> Of course, if you don't conform, Oracle will sue you into oblivion. What? OpenJDK is as free as they come. No conformance with Java necessary, you can do with it whatever you damn well please. You can use it to implement .NET if you want. Oracle has never (to the best of my knowledge) sued anyone for the use (or modification) of OpenJDK.
- rewqfdsa 11y agoOkay, so can I modify it so that it doesn't conform to the Java specification? Can I modify it bit-by-bit until it's bytewise identical to Harmony? Of course I can't. Because if I do, Oracle will sue me. Oracle is lying. They claim to be offering free software, but will sue you once you take advantage of that freedom. It's a fucking trap. Do you really expect the technology community to embrace Oracle technology after Oracle spits in their food and shits in their sink?
- pron 11y ago> Okay, so can I modify it so that it doesn't conform to the Java specification? Can I modify it bit-by-bit until it's bytewise identical to Harmony? Absolutely (on both counts, although if it is identical to Harmony you may be in violation of the license due to a collision between GPLv2 and ASL, as ASL imposes further restrictions which GPLv2 does not allow -- see the next paragraph). > Because if I do, Oracle will sue me. They will not. In fact, they explicitly allow you to do whatever you want with it. They are not placing any restrictions; their own license (same as Linux's) does not allow them to do so (section 6 says: "You may not impose any further restrictions on the recipients' exercise of the rights granted herein"). Oracle sued Google, not you. They didn't sue them for using Java, and they certainly didn't sue them over OpenJDK. Of course, it has been Google's PR department's strategy to make you think that the lawsuit may apply to you, but it doesn't. The circumstances leading to the lawsuit were very unusual. > Oracle is lying. Maybe about other things (I don't know a large company that doesn't lie), but not about this. > They claim to be offering free software, but will sue you once you take advantage of that freedom. It's a fucking trap. Again, to the best of my knowledge, that has never happened. > Do you really expect the technology community to embrace Oracle technology after Oracle spits in their food and shits in their sink? I don't expect anyone to do anything other than to understand the facts and then make their decisions[1]. Oracle has earned the distrust of many developers, but I don't find Google to be any more likable. Personally, I'll take Oracle's old-school greed over Google's sneaky espionage and manipulative PR, but that's just me. ---- [1]: I am willing to bet that very few people understand what the Oracle v. Google court case is all about, and the loudest voice was by far Google's PR.
- lmm 11y agoAll code can be a patent minefield. I predict we'll see patent trolls going after browser makers as soon as WebAssembly becomes popular. The fact that Java has a single, notoriously litigious owner actually works in its favour here - anyone trying to patent-troll Java will be issuing an invitation to Oracle's attack dogs, whereas WebAssembly could easily suffer a tragedy of the commons where no one browser vendor wants to spend the money to defend it.
- ndesaulniers 11y agohttp://www.w3.org/Consortium/Patent-Policy-20040205/#sec-Requirements http://www.w3.org/Consortium/Patent-Policy-20040205/#sec-Req...
- lmm 11y agoThat only covers patents held by members of the working group.