4 ms·
"The complaint itself is somewhat unusual in that it doesn't seek anything specific from Hillary. Rather, all it asks is for the court to certify that [the bank
by tedunangst 17y ago
"The complaint itself is somewhat unusual in that it doesn't seek anything specific from Hillary. Rather, all it asks is for the court to certify that [the bank's] systems are reasonably secure."
- ams6110 17y agoPresumably the victim's credentials (likely just a password or PIN, and possibly the proper response to a "secret question") were obtained with a trojan keylogger or some other means. The question is who's fault is that? Not really the bank's. The bank's claim that they honored a properly authenticated transaction is not completely unreasonable. What the court is really being asked to decide is whether simple password authentication is "reasonably secure." What are the alternatives? Seems that they'd have to use a physical smart card or fob device to generate one-time passwords, or use an alternate communication channel (email? SMS?) to verify that the authorized user is attempting to authenticate. Any of which substantially decreases the perceived usability of the system by a typical business customer.
- electromagnetic 17y agoNo it's not unreasonable that they honoured the transaction. However my bank, HSBC, required me to call and contact them to make debit withdrawals over $400 when outside the country. Their approval period only lasts for 6 months (the length of time you're legally allowed to stay in most foreign countries) before renewing it. At the time I also had to clarify that I would be making wire transfers to a foreign account. I believe my parents had to do the same from their bank when they transferred over 10K into their own foreign account. Why UK banking has these protocols in place for consumers that are far likely to transfer money over seas is bizarre if they're not in place for business. However, this could likely be due to different banking regulations. I know I've heard people being warned against getting US bank accounts here in Canada, they recommend getting a US-Dollar account with international transaction fees waved as you're money is, allegedly, a lot safer.
- pcc 17y agoI doubt there is really a usability decrease. A former bank of mine implemented a system where: (1) you were highly advised to enter your banking pin via mouse using a pad; (2) in addition to entering your password, you also had to have a further passphrase, from which you would be prompted to enter a few characters at random indexes; (3) you could not simply wire funds to any random account; you first had to "add" that account "as beneficiary" -- and this "add" action had to be confirmed via a code SMS'd to you by the bank. Not to say this makes things completely secure, but it certainly raises the barrier. This was deployed 7 years ago by a third-world-country bank, afaik its still in effect today.
- flatline 17y agoThey are presumably trying to set precedence. The East Texas District Court is notorious for upholding software patents, this is the area where many patent trolls have set up shop. It wouldn't surprise me if the bank thinks that it will have a good chance of being favored in the case, and because it's a federal court, a ruling could have a much wider reaching impact.