3 ms·
> UI sliders were certainly not novel in 2006. The patents at issue are design patents, not utility patents (what we know of as inventions). Sliders as functi
by otterley 11y ago
> UI sliders were certainly not novel in 2006.
The patents at issue are design patents, not utility patents (what we know of as inventions).
Sliders as functional UI devices weren't novel, but the particular design at issue was unique to Microsoft when they filed for their design patent.
- dvirsky 11y agoWeren't there exactly such sliders in Photoshop, like 5-10 years earlier?
- frik 11y agoYep, at least since Photoshop 3 (which runs just fine on Win7 btw). Macromedia Dreamweaver (now Adobe) had a Ribbon (toolbar with tabs) many years before Microsoft Office 2007 too, nevertheless Microsoft filed patents for it.
- throwawaykf05 11y agoIf you can show that those UI controls looked exactly like the designs in these patents, you may have found invalidating prior art.
- sbuk 11y agoI've been using Photoshop since it's release. I use it daily and I have to be honest and say that I don't recall sliders looking like that, ever. Can you provide an illustration?