3 ms·
Where is it that you were taught to take a part of a quote, turn it into a strawman, and knock that down? My quote said effects range from a percentile (low eff
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Where is it that you were taught to take a part of a quote, turn it into a strawman, and knock that down? My quote said effects range from a percentile (low effect) to 50x. That means it has minimal effect over CPU's on some with 50x on others. Try to stick with what I said, eh?
Also, some algorithms can do over 100x. The good ones are just more likely to get less than that so i left it off. I've seen 10-50x in all kinds of papers, though. And those were academics rather than FPGA pro's.
- badsock 11y agoI think revelation was specifically referring to the word "arbitrary" in your post. That makes it sound like FPGAs can speed up any given algorithm, which is obviously not the case.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoCould be misleading to some. The intent for arbitrary was that you could implement any algorithm on them. Whereas, custom hardware is usually fixed and some programmable ones are more limited. Plus, I think you can speed up any algorithm at least a little if putting it on FPGA on more advanced node. Reason being there's no other processing besides the algorithm and it's harder to get GP CPU's that optimal at given process node. That said, the likes of Intel, AMD, and IBM put so much work into CPU's at most advanced nodes that some sequential algorithms will likely do better on them. Synthesized, amateur FPGA bitstream just can't compete with custom, pro, hard blocks designed for exact purpose.