5 ms·
> As was the case 30 years ago, testing has no solid base of evidence, no proof that it succeeds. We don’t know if screening workers for recent drug use makes t
by pc86 11y ago
> As was the case 30 years ago, testing has no solid base of evidence, no proof that it succeeds. We don’t know if screening workers for recent drug use makes them more productive, lowers their risk of getting into accidents, or otherwise helps maintain the social order.
I've never heard anyone suggest that is does. The reasons in favor of drug testing I've always heard is that you don't end up hiring people who are so incompetent as to be doing drugs while applying for new jobs. It's just one more piece of signalling.
I was drug-tested when I accepted employment at my current job. I had 3 or 4 days to make it in. Even if I was the type of person to regularly consume illegal drugs, I certainly would not have done so while applying for work.
I don't think it does much good, it's probably a waste of money, and I don't care what my coworkers smoke as long they're not doing it at work, but I also don't see how anyone can be incredulous or indignant about it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mod 11y agoIt wouldn't make sense to do random drug tests for current employees if it was just a hiring filter.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoI can. The idea is extremely humiliating. My body is my business. You don't get to poke in it just because you want to. I would probably avoid employment where I would be expected to contribute not just code but also pee. P. S. I nearly don't drink[1], I don't smoke, I don't do drugs. Because I choose so.
- mod 11y agoYou're not really the class of employee that these policies are (or should be, at least) targeted at. I had to take a piss test to get a job where I drove a company box truck on a route every day, with a hazardous material endorsement. I was fresh out of high school, no other qualifications. I didn't then, nor do I now, have a problem with that piss test. I'm a programmer now. I'd have a problem with a piss test--which I would readily pass, even if it were effective.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoYesterday, journalists weren't the class of employee that these policies are targeted at, but today they became so. If this shit becomes the default (megacorp drones will think: why not extend this inexpensive procedure to everyony) we'll just live in even worse and more humiliating society than we do already. You think, therefore you resist.
- VLM 11y ago"we'll just live in even ... more humiliating society than we do already" This insight also applies to a world where HR filters (or keyword filters) based on decades of social media posts.
- kelukelugames 11y agoOne journalist at an unnamed "national" magazine was drug tested. The author then makes a joke out of it. The story was a set up for the rest of the article. Worrying it's becoming the default is just irrational as outrage over Starbucks' war on Christmas. Let me put this out there now, before you’ve read too far: I was not myself drug-tested before publishing this story. Neither was my editor, nor the copy editor, nor any of the designers, programmers, or art editors who worked on it. For all I know, the lot of them—the entire staff of Slate—could be huddled in a conference room right this very minute, passing joints around and shooting dope and snorting PCP. But ours is not the standard workplace in America.
- brazzledazzle 11y agoI once worked for a division of a company that had no drug testing policy. After that division was moved under another during a reorganization it was required that all new hires be drug tested. It didn't matter that we sat at desks all day. It was only through concerted effort on the part of management and key employees that we were allowed to stop doing it. It took close to two years to get it fixed. It's really no wonder megacorps have a hard time retaining talented or creative people when the only ones that can endure it are required to have incredible tenacity and patience.
- cableshaft 11y ago
- pc86 11y agoIs it none of your company's business if you're regularly engaging in illegal behavior? Does it not speak to character? We talk about cultural fit a lot here - what if the culture of a company is such that they want employees who obey the law, even laws that make little sense and they may not agree with? Or somewhat more realistic, they don't actually care if you use drugs they just want to make sure you're smart enough not to do it immediately before applying for a job with a new company? They're not asking for sexual history, they're not asking for a full medical workup, or anything else unrelated. You're being paid to perform an intellectual task, and unless you're suggesting that drug use has no effect on one's mental state, I think it's relevant.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoWhile I disagree with drug testing, there is a legitimate reason to do so: if an employee is consuming illegal drugs, that greatly increases the risk of said employee being caught with such drugs and being arrested and imprisoned. This means that at any time, an employee could be here one day and gone the next, which means that costly adjustments to overall workload must be made at the drop of a hat. Add in the possibility of multiple employees consuming illegal drugs together after hours and you run the risk of an entire team being the equivalent of hit by a bus. Many recreational drugs aren't bad. Marijuana is not harmful, psychedelics are generally non-addictive, and nearly everybody who's not Mormon or Muslim drinks. The problem - and risk - for an employer, is illegality.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoYou also have the risk of your employees quitting over drug testing, including entire team at once. Naturally you should consider what you fear more. Especially in the world that rapidly progresses towards decriminalization of recreational drugs.
- cname 11y agoBetter test everyone for alcohol then, since drunk driving is more prevalent than illegal drug use.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoDrunk driving is a far cry from drug possession. For one thing, you can get drunk frequently, show up to work on time, and never touch the wheel of a car. I'm not sure what you're getting at.
- soylentcola 11y agoSure, but by that token, you can smoke cannabis nightly, show up for work on time, and never touch the wheel of a car either. You'd still fail the piss test. The other thing not touched on too much is how cannabis (despite being one of the least harmful recreational drugs/drugs of abuse, and most commonly used) is one that can be detected the longest. I can go out on a bender drinking liquor and blowing lines of coke this weekend, get called in for a drug test on Thursday, and still piss clean. ...but if I went camping a few weeks ago and spent my evenings passing joints around the fire with friends, I could easily throw a flag for cannabinoids on a urinalysis weeks later. It's really kinda messed up in that way because the logic of "well, what does it say about you that you couldn't lay off the stuff long enough to pass a drug test?" goes out the window with pot. If you like to take a few tokes in the evening after work, that can show up on a test weeks or months later, even if you quit while applying for jobs.