7 ms·
Career opportunities
- crabasa 11y agoMeta comment, but it's amazing to me how frequently articles about the cost/value of higher education hit the front page of HN. I wonder what the fascination is?
- toufique 11y agoHigher education is starting to feel very hackable. Cost is substantially increasing. Benefit is stagnating or decreasing. Cost of substitutes is exponentially decreasing. It's ripe for disruption, hence my fascination.
- ap22213 11y agoHigher education has been ripe for disruption since the 90s, but that disruption hasn't happened. A lot of the ideas that are currently being floated around in the online space are pretty well-worn. In fact, I've seen very little progress in this space, compared to other industries. Not much has changed aside from self-driven 'autodidact learning'. And, that's kind of mind-boggling considering the supply and demand curves. There's huge inelastic demand for higher education and very limited supply (capacity). The toughest nut to crack is the accreditation and pedigree issue. If you can figure out how to get most (or even some) hiring managers (or grant-funding bodies, or even moms and dads) to give more weight to credentials that aren't the traditional diplomas, you'll be in a good spot.
- berntb 11y agoMany of the people I've seen doing really well at university already learned about the subjects they study. A few studied in another country but couldn't get the courses transferred. Another did a year of math studies before university at a local university, then went on to study engineering at an "Ivy league". And so on. Just spending 10 hours a week studying a subject for a year before someone start studying it at university should be a giant market. No need for diplomas.
- toufique 11y agoI think higher "education" is certainly being disrupted, but higher "accreditation" isn't yet. You're right on point.
- pitt1980 11y agobeing a student is a near universal experience, so its an industry that nearly everyone has some degree of experience with also there is at least some degree of connection being the education industry and being perceived as intelligent, so a lot of people's self identity is connected to their relationship with the education industry for a lot of people their education is one of the 2 or 3 largest purchases they'll ever make in their lifetimes ------------------------- combined, it becomes a thing in which a large number of people come to hold opinions about, probably far more than the typical HN topic
- drewrv 11y ago> Anyone who argues that the key to “economic opportunity,” aka a decent job, is to have a college degree is in effect arguing that it’s OK for a large majority of Americans not to have a decent job. I agree if we're talking about a four year degree, but a trade school is a great option for someone "not suited" towards academics.
- kfk 11y agoSo the past week and half I have been on holidays back in Italy (I live in Germany). At least here, in the South, your status still greatly depends on 1) if you managed to raise a family (single 40 years old ultra rich Corporate managers don't get much credit); 2) if you have a good network of friends (and people here don't look down at blue collars). My father was a blue collar worker and he gets a lot of respect for doing well 1 and 2. While this is not ideal (I think 1 and 2 are part of the reasons many Italian lack the ambition Americans have), it's a very good way to live a very decent life as an individual. At a macro level I believe pushing on 1 and 2 will kill your economy, on a micro level (aka if I was a shrink), I would strongly advise them. P.s. of course, 1 and 2 work well in a world where you have USA, where people do kill themselves to deliver loads of innovation to the whole planet (see: internet, space exploration, etc.). P.p.s. of course USA works well because it attracted talent across the world to deliver loads of innovation (see: immigrants)
- lint_roller 11y agoCompletely agree. The "wealthiest" person alive today is some happy accountant in middle America with a great salary, good health, and happy family. Stable and well compensated work with plenty of leisure time and zero want for basic necessities. And on top of all that, you have these crazily ambitious weirdos absolutely killing themselves to deliver to you all these cool toys and convenient services just to capture outsized economic surplus. Pretty sweet deal if you ask me.
- puranjay 11y agoThere are people who actually enjoy working 12 hour days. My brother is like that. Not working makes him miserable. If he's not bashing his head against some difficult problem, he isn't happy.
- kfk 11y agoHey, just wanted to say I feel incredibly lucky our species has developed such diverse individuals! I think we need the Elon Musk and your brother types, as much as we need the more relaxed family oriented ones. I think it's a shame if our society develops a stigma either for one or the other type.
- sandworm101 11y agoIf someone leaves highschool "not suited" for academics then their highschool has failed them. No student should feel they are in any way 'not the type' for higher education. No 16/17/18 year-old should be so pigeon-holed. How many of these kids are making these decisions based on third-hand accounts of what higher education actually entails, without even sitting in on a post-highschool lecture? How many are told not to bother simply because they don't look/act/sound the part? Given the state of highschool education, the lack of basic literacy, nearly everyone would do well to attend some sort of 'academic' post-secondary education. Reading books, listening to lectures and writing about what you have learned teaches the basic communication skills useful in every field.
- Camillo 11y agoMany people are just not very smart.
- Paul_S 11y agoAt least in Europe there is and has been for years a chronic shortage of tradesman (alleviated by migration). You will not earn as much as a doctor but the jobs are there for those who want them. I think the complaints stem from the fact that there are simply not that many labourer jobs (and that's a good thing).
- siscia 11y ago> "Yet anyone with working class relatives knows that some are simply not suited for higher education under any circumstances for a variety of reasons." I consider myself extremely cynical and pragmatic, but I still have to found somebody who wouldn't be able to do what I did in my university, arguably one of the most challenging in my area. Grated, a lot of people that I know wouldn't get what the professor is telling them in the classroom, but in my opinion this is a problem with how education is provided not with my folks being "simply not suited for higher education" In my opinion if the only way to teach is to show prof of theorems with make them feels real, either we don't really know what we are trying to teach or we don't know how to teach.
- pitt1980 11y ago"Tre, who was in a math support class of mine last year, had phenomenal retention of any concrete fact he learned. Total inability to grasp abstract concepts. Couldn’t estimate. Couldn’t isolate x. Couldn’t figure out what the slope of a line was. I’d ask him things like “if you rolled a ball down this line, which one would go faster?” and he’d struggle for minutes just to figure out what I meant. If it wasn’t real, it didn’t exist. He got pretty good at percentages without actually understanding them—but 20% was divide by 5, 25% was divide by 4, 10% was divide by 10. He was motivated. Great kid, fantastic athlete, failing algebra for the fourth time kept him off the his strongest sports team his senior year and broke his heart. But he took up a second sport and made the state finals. He seemed a bit slow in conversation, but nothing that would mark him as really low intellect. He held a job, worked hard, was a popular kid. There was no way he would be passing the test, and when I communicated this to the AVP, she said, “He was not classified correctly, for various reasons”—one of the reasons probably being that Tre is black. She mentioned his tested IQ that his parents included in his file, and it was well south of 90, but still much higher than 70. Mohammed was in another of my math classes last year. Unlike Tre, does not communicate his mental disability immediately. He talks quickly, cracks decent jokes, likes people around, while Tre was happier off in a corner listening to music. It took me a while to realize that Mohammed, who is neither black nor Hispanic, wasn’t retaining any information at all. Once I did realize this, I looked more closely at his IEP and saw he was a special day students with an IQ in the mid-80s. Also an excellent athlete, but very different from Tre. No fact grasp at all. He couldn’t remember what you told him five minutes ago, much less yesterday. But he could solve a simple algebraic equation with a calculator. He’d have to relearn it almost every day, but he had the ability to abstract that Tre lacks. He very badly wanted to move on to the next math class in the sequence, against the recommendation of his special ed adviser, and nagged me constantly to support him in this quest. I was willing to help him try, but his sport kept him out of the classroom a couple days a week for nearly a month, and everything I’d managed to do to keep him not rolling backwards was undone. So I passed him and talked him into an easier course." https://educationrealist.wordpress.com/2013/10/31/noahpinion-on-iq-or-maybe-just-no-knowledge/ https://educationrealist.wordpress.com/2013/10/31/noahpinion...
- xiaoma 11y agoI and most of my friends had a dislike for the general regimentation and bullshit of university life. It definitely gets better as you meet more and more like-minded people and there are some great aspects, but the system is pretty ridiculous. In school, people generally have to do the same thing everyone else does, they have precise deadlines and get nothing for forging their own paths. In life, having no unique experiences or skills is a path to ruin, one can never be certain how long a window of opportunity will be open and finding one's own path can lead to great satisfaction and well-being. From an educational perspective, school is even worse. Many with literature degrees can't write, business majors rarely build successful businesses, foreign language majors often don't end up fluent in the language they study for years on end, and even top sales reps or engineers often lack a related degree. Spending all that time is only really worth it if a) it's required for a license, b) you need access to equipment you couldn't otherwise get, e.g. for the sciences, c) you just aren't capable of learning well on your own, or d) you go to an elite institution where you can learn from the best in the world. 90% of the value is just the credential to deal with narrow-minded people and institutions who use it as a filter.
- draw_down 11y agoThis isn't about how you and your friends were too smart and unique for university life. This is about people getting jobs.
- xiaoma 11y agoThere's no need to be rude. I believe the article was about the rising costs to society that come from expecting everyone to get their post-secondary education through formal schooling to get a job. The truth is, a university really isn't a good fit for a lot of people. It's painful both in terms of the many years it can take and the massive financial burden. One of my closest childhood friends has been buried in student debt for years and is still taking part time classes while working a full-time job (which often forces poor performance in the classes). But debt deferral doesn't last long if you stop taking classes. Talk about poor alignment of incentives! Both the initial decision to seek a degree and the expectation of one from so many downright elitist gatekeepers ended up creating a vicious cycle of increasing debt for a good person who has a great work ethic but poor study habits. Statistics make it clear that this is far from uncommon. Perhaps some social circles are insulated from the reality but facts are facts. At most public universities, only 19 percent of full-time students earn a bachelor’s degree in four years. http://completecollege.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/4-Year-Myth.pdf http://completecollege.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/4-Year... The system is broken and getting worse.
- krisdol 11y agoSo, many more students are attending college, median salaries for college educated folks haven't budged, tuition is more heavily subsidized, and yet college is many times more expensive. Hate to challenge hn libertarians but something doesn't add up here. Where's the money going in that equation? Are school administrators just vacuuming up all the extra money? Are professors mostly less than high school educated? There are more students in college because high school education does limit your job opportunities, and wages for non-educated jobs have not only not risen, but have fallen since the 1970s. Tuition may be more subsidized in the number of dollars touched by the state, but education budgets often haven't risen to meet demand and the only subsidies anyone's getting these days is loans. Grants and scholarships from the state have shrunk and shrunk and shrunk. A college education is more likely to lead to pulling you out of poverty than a lack of one.
- toyg 11y ago> Are school administrators just vacuuming up all the extra money? Yes. There have been quite a few stories showing how admin in education is booming. Also, growth in numbers requires growth in facilities, which are a big money sink for most education institutions; you could argue a lot of this extra money is actually going to the building sector (and again, admin required for all these projects) as well as the constant churn that is IT upgrades. > Grants and scholarships from the state have shrunk and shrunk and shrunk. The more the State pumps into loans (driven by student numbers, and carrying a considerable management overhead), the less it has for direct subsidies. In a situation where overall revenue from taxation is fixed or falling in real terms, that makes sense and it does not contradict TFA. > A college education is more likely to lead to pulling you out of poverty than a lack of one.* I agree there, but it depends on what "pulling out of poverty" means. A degree might help you get a job, but current trends mean that you might still end up being poor -- just a working one. Rather than enforcing class status through education tiers, a progressive agenda should concentrate on restoring dignity to regular jobs. Sadly this is seen as class warfare, whereas platitudes about getting everyone and his dog into 4 years of subsidised drinking go down fine with all sectors of the electorate.