3 ms·
I feel like your suggestion is extremely naive and wasteful of both hard drive space, transfer, and ram. Please explain how you can put an entire system togeth
by michaelmrose 11y ago
I feel like your suggestion is extremely naive and wasteful of both hard drive space, transfer, and ram.
Please explain how you can put an entire system together that way in a non stupid way.
- nailer 11y ago> hard drive space, transfer, and ram are all incredibly cheap when compared to human effort in dependency management with dynamic libs. And most Linux packages managers don't elegantly support installation of multiple versions of libs (libfoo and libfoo123 isn't elegant). The way you'd fix that is similar to what the OP is proposing. Of course, there's many other concerns: but it's not entirely unreasonable.
- michaelmrose 11y agoIts entirely possible for an individual app to have its deps included without forcing every app to work the same and I'm far from convinced that is a real benefit. It would be far better to work towards standardization to make producing a package for multiple distros easier.
- brianclements 11y agoThere's always a trade-off. A little extra space (which is cheap) for less developer time accounting for all the distro/library/arch combinations. I think it's a very fair trade since space gets cheaper by the year and time does the opposite. One working example of this type of system is RacherOS[1] which I think could do what I'm proposing. I'm excited to see it mature. People can just package their app in a minimally sized container and be done with it. I think it's what the linux community really wants anyway (modularity and options) but adds the ability to switch without re-installation from scratch. [1]http://rancher.com/rancher-os/ http://rancher.com/rancher-os/