6 ms·
How many people actually opt out of the scans? I always do, but when I'm waiting to be patted down I always seem to be the only one. Everyone else always seem
by pmoriarty 11y ago
How many people actually opt out of the scans? I always do, but when I'm waiting to be patted down I always seem to be the only one. Everyone else always seems to go for the scan.
Another annoying thing is that invariably they have me wait sitting almost right next to the scanner. I've seen images showing that people behind scanners also get scanned. The best I can hope for is that the radiation dose is somewhat lower than when you're actually in the scanner itself.
- nitid_name 11y agoHow much of a dose do you actually get from the scans? The best numbers I can find seem to point to something in the 0.015 μSv to 0.88 μSv range. At cruising altitude, you get 0.04 μSv per minute from cosmic radiation. I don't think the radiation from these machines should be the biggest concern.
- fluxquanta 11y agoMost people hear radiation and automatically think "Chernobyl 2.0" without looking into the details. I love using the banana equivalent dose as a way to help people understand that not all radiation is created equal.
- pmoriarty 11y agoThe radiation may not be that much, relatively speaking. But it's all focused on your skin. Plus, this kind of radiation exposure hasn't been tested on humans for long. I'd feel better about being scanned had these scanners been in use for 20 years without many adverse effects reported. As it stands, the jury's still out. And I'd personally rather wait a little longer in line and get a pat down than take a chance with my health.
- DanBC 11y agoDo you drive to the airport? EDIT: Driving to the airport will expose you to far more risk than walking through the machine, however you define that risk.
- JshWright 11y agoA significant benefit is derived from driving. No such benefit exists from AIT scanning.
- rbcgerard 11y agoWhat is you confidence level regarding the maintenance and calibration of these machines?
- DanBC 11y agoI have no idea. I do know that driving is far more dangerous how ever you define danger.
- ggoss 11y agoIt also depends on whether the machine in use (different airports use different machines) are millimeter wave or backscatter x-ray. Millimeter wave machines (the majority of installations), if I am not mistaken, do not emit ionizing radiation, whereas the backscatter machines do. You can tell which type of machines are in use at your airport by the informational posters displayed in the queue, the brand and physical appearance of the machines themselves, or by checking online. My policy has always been to ask for a pat-down when they use backscatter (to avoid the unnecessary radiation), and go through the machine if they use millimeter wave. The dose of radiation may be small (relative to normal amounts of cosmic radiation or black lightning or bananas or ...), but they don't really know if the machines are out-of-spec until, well, they do. I'd like to avoid becoming 'that person' who was severely over-radiated right before they decommissioned a malfunctioning machine.
- glasz 11y agoradiation is some sort of valid strawman argument. it's purpose is to get all the stupid sheep concerned who just blindly submit to anything some clown tells them to.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> At cruising altitude, you get 0.04 μSv per minute from cosmic radiation. All the more reason to minimize it every chance you get, wouldn't you say?
- late2part 11y agoAre you safer with or without the radiation? Without, obviously, so why not ignore it? "Just a little higher chance of cancer" is not a comforting observation.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> How many people actually opt out of the scans? I always do, but when I'm waiting to be patted down, I always seem to be the only one. A few times when I've flown out of PDX, there was a substantial line for opt-outs; sadly not every time. I've also heard anecdotes that when DEFCON let out, the airport handling all the return flights ended up just sending everyone through the metal detectors rather than deal with thousands of people all opting out.
- programmarchy 11y agoSeems like all it would take is a few days of mass opt outs and the TSA would come to a screeching halt.
- late2part 11y agoSo true about many things (plea bargains, commercial banks, etc) but who will bell the cat?
- late2part 11y agoThere was a "restore the fourth" day of protest scheduled, maybe during Christmas or Thanksgiving some years ago - TSA's reaction was same thing, they pretended like the body scanners were out of order and pushed everyone through the x-ray scanners.
- dham 11y agoSame here. I always opt out I'm the only one sitting there for 5 minutes. Funny thing is I was thinking about the radiation sitting next to it last time also. I was about 10 feet from it I think at MIA.
- milge 11y agoI do but we're definitely in the minority. My father thinks I'm a paranoid nut because of it. I think he's a sheep.
- pc86 11y ago> I think he's a sheep. Oh please. You're not helping with that attitude.
- hellbanner 11y agoJust keep stepping to the side, away from the line of sight of those machines.
- coldpie 11y agoI've never seen anyone I wasn't traveling with opt out. I'm not concerned about a radiation dose or whatever, I'm more concerned with "fuck the TSA". Anything that makes their jobs shittier makes me happier. It's pure spite.
- 67726e 11y agoI've also never seen anyone else opt-out. Like you said, it's my way of giving the Theater of Security Administration the finger in the only way I know how.
- coldpie 11y agoI was departing MSP once, a few days before the Republican National Convention was going to take place. One of the clowns made smalltalk with me and the RNC came up. She mentioned she wasn't looking forward to dealing with all the traffic through the airport. I said, "Well, you don't have to work here, you know?". She just gave me this withering look, and I walked away with a smile on my face. I sincerely hope I ruined her day. For all the man-hours and money she and those in her position throw down the toilet every day, one ruined day seems like small payback. Fuck the TSA.
- dfc 11y agoYou walked away with a smile on your face because you hoped you had ruined somebody's day? This woman did not throw money and man hours down the toilet every day. She does not have any decision making authority and did not draft the legislation creating TSA. In another comment you accuse them of sexually harassing you and yet you brag that you "make them fondle my balls simply because I can." Quite frankly you sound like a petty, angry, and terrible person.
- coldpie 11y agoWhen confronted by someone working for the TSA, yes, I am. If they're going to waste my time and insist that I throw away fucking water, I'm going to find some way to pay them back.
- ThomPete 11y agoI always opt out because I had a melanoma. I am well aware that its not xrays but my doctor told me to take no chances (I have more than a thousand moles=
- DanBC 11y agoBut you still fly? EDIT: Flying at altitude probably exposes you to more radiation than the machines. A 7 hour flight is roughly the same as a chest x-ray, and that's way more than the machines.
- nothrabannosir 11y agoSorry for downvoting you twice (here and on your other comment), I feel like I owe you an explanation: Dan, if you have something to say, just say it. This rhetorical Q&A works in a conversation; here, it just looks petty. In fact, I think I agree with what you're trying to say ("the flight itself exposes you to a lot more radiation"?), but if you don't actually say it, I can't be sure. And there's nothing to respond to, if I (or someone else) don't. Not that I'm the boss of anyone; by all means, do what you want. Just that I dislike getting downvoted without explanation, so here's to being slightly less of a hypocrite than usual :)
- DanBC 11y agoThat's a useful explanation, so thank you.
- ThomPete 11y agoYes I still fly because I need to and yes I am of course aware of the risk of flying. That doesn't mean I should do more than I need to.
- pfooti 11y agoI opt out of the scans pretty regularly. Of course, I'm in the queue for getting tsa precheck now, so hopefully it won't be for long. For me, it's not a radiation thing. It's more about a kind of semi-philosophical objection to the idea that people should look at naked pictures of me in order to provide the illusion of safety. AIT (advanced imaging technology) seems to be the quintessence of snake oil - we're told we need it and any real research into its efficacy is discouraged (still though, there's indications that metal detectors were probably better at catching threats). [0] [1] [0]: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2015/06/tsa_not_detecti.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2015/06/tsa_not_detec... [1]: https://radsec.org/secure1000-sec14.pdf https://radsec.org/secure1000-sec14.pdf
- saurik 11y agoI am very curious about the mental path you took from having a philosophical objection to intrusive scans for the purpose of security theater, to simply registering with the government ahead of time and asking them to do some background check and keep that on file. (Maybe the latter actually sounds effective to you, and so isn't only "providing the illusion of safety"?) I have considered pre-check (as one reason I opt out is the research that millimeter wave scans might "unzip" DNA and lead to epigenetic modifications), but as I am also philosophically in strong objection to the entire process I can't bring myself to lose the battle before it is even fought by "taking the easy way out" and "paying the Danegeld", giving the TSA a sweaty wad of "don't scan me cash" to join pre-check and essentially "submit" myself to a different and yet in some ways similar kind of invasive search :/. (I, personally, consider the pat downs I constantly get much less invasive.)
- barney54 11y agoFor me, I paid th TSA Danegeld for the ease of travel, especially when traveling with children. The Pre-Check lines are great and makes you forget about how terrible the TSA is. Yes you have to pay and give them information, but they have the information anyway. For me it has been worth it, even though I coughed up the information. Travel is just so much better with Pre-Check.
- 11y ago
- code4life 11y agoI usually travel with my family. I'm afraid if I opt out, they'll make an example out of me, and I'll ruin my family vacation.
- coldpie 11y agoFor what it's worth, as a white male, I've never had a bad experience opting out. At the very worst, they're curt and overly professional. Most of the time they make small chat.
- late2part 11y agoI have had bad experiences twice. I am polite but refuse to answer questions or make small talk. Twice the man moved his hand "upwards until resistance" very fast and into my testicle. I complained and the managers response was "he has to go up until he feels resistance." TSA Complaint made, response was "no substantiating evidence." Shades of a police state.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoOne way to help with that is to arrive earlier than you would expect.
- fweespeech 11y agoTbh, I go for the scan because it doesn't bother me and the radiation dosage is the same as a few minutes of flight time. The scans are less of a problem than the idea that the government can force people to go through them.
- Fizzadar 11y agoEvery time, which my family always find hilarious and inconvenient. Radiation isn't an issue, as the above comment said it's very much a "fuck the TSA" stance.
- adevine 11y agoI used to opt out when the scans were backscatter X-ray. Now, though, at least all the airports I've been to recently use millimeter wave scanners, which is non-ionizing radiation. If you use a cell phone, you shouldn't be concerned about the cancer risk of these machines.
- panarky 11y agoI used to opt out due to radiation and privacy concerns when airports were using the backscatter scanners. After US airports switched to millimeter wave scanners, I no longer opt out. My understanding is that the new scanners emit far less radiation, and no TSA agent operator is viewing naked images. The software presents a stylized body silhouette on a monitor that you and the TSA agent both view when you exit the scanner. If my understanding is correct, then isn't this a reasonable approach?
- nathos 11y agoA "reasonable approach" using technology that doesn't work: http://www.politico.com/story/2015/08/airport-security-price-for-tsa-failed-body-scanners-160-million-121385 http://www.politico.com/story/2015/08/airport-security-price...
- sokoloff 11y agoI opt out every time (at US airports). The only time I've ever seen anyone else opt-out was after leaving a tech conference. I ended up chatting with the guy afterwards and he reported that I was also the only random person he'd ever seen waiting in the opt-out line. He was wearing a deliciously nerdy "Affordable Cleric Act" T-shirt.
- Grue3 11y agoI can't imagine why one would prefer to be physically touched by a stranger than be scanned by a no-contact device. It's almost certain that people who like to be touched by random people are in the minority. The "cancer risks" are laughable pseudoscience.