3 ms·
>> ... such a talk can easily succeed in >> convincing the audience that there is >> a dry, ridiculous, but famous conjecture >> coming out of nothing; cr
by ColinWright 11y ago
>> ... such a talk can easily succeed in
>> convincing the audience that there is
>> a dry, ridiculous, but famous conjecture
>> coming out of nothing; crazy number
>> theorists have wasted their life to
>> contribute to the list of partial
>> results, which cannot even be claimed
>> to be a long list.
>> Hopefully I have failed in that way.
> Ummm, I guess that even among techies on HN,
> there are only a small fraction who could
> understand this.
^^^^
> So the author failed with me. Any one want
> to do an ELI5?
It's not clear what you mean by "this". You might mean this small section that you quoted, or you might mean the entire article to which this is an opening preamble.
If it's the first of these, then here's a free translation:
A talk like this can convince an audience that the
conjecture is just a wild, crazy thing, produced by
wild crazy people, and it comes from nowhere, without
motivation, without provenance. If so, you'd have to
believe that number theorists are wasting their lives
chasing bizarre and pointless things, and really, not
many of them either.
I hope that this article *fails* to make you think
that. I hope this article shows you that the BSD
conjecture is a part of a larger, meaningful context.
On the other hand, if your "this" refers to the article itself, then it's a rather larger task to help access it. I attended a talk a while ago that gave an excellent, high-level overview of this conjecture and the work being done on it, and I can see the structure of the arguments here.
But it's not intended to be read like a novel by people other than experts in the area. If you're not an expert - and very few people are - it's an article you need to wrestle with, work on, and dive into.
It's math, it's not a graphic novel, and math is not a spectator sport. It's requires participation and effort.
So, is it the article itself for which you need an ELI5? If so, seriously, good luck. This is material at the very limits of modern math.
- chrispeel 11y agoThank your for the comments. Yes, it's the article which I would need help understanding. I don't plan to put in enough work to understand it well; the explanation from jordigh and others here was good enough. I do like the self-deprecating nature of the "dry, ridiculous" statement from the authors, and the valiant efforts of others to explain it!