3 ms·
At televised sporting events, a prankster, usually drunk, will sometimes run onto the field to make a spectacle. Yet, the broadcast always cuts away, so as not
by gojomo 17y ago
At televised sporting events, a prankster, usually drunk, will sometimes run onto the field to make a spectacle. Yet, the broadcast always cuts away, so as not to encourage the behavior even more in the future.
Perhaps we could consider a similar policy on submissions and upvotes about site-defacements? The hack will already get plenty of attention from the normal visitors of the affected site, and coverage in other 'gotcha' outlets. Maybe we should dampen, rather than multiply, the coverage.
(A post-incident report with details of the vulnerability and valid countermeasures would be interesting. And if the normally-trusted site was at any point subverting visitors with malware, that too would warrant a warning submission. But racing to report and upvote each graffiti incident almost seems to be cheering it on.)
- jfornear 17y agoI think there could be some cheering going on given the love-hate relationship between TechCrunch and the HN crowd, but I don't think anyone wishes them ill.
- ankeshk 17y agoIdealistic. But not practical. Sporting events have just one broadcaster. One person who controls what you see. Online, everyone is a broadcaster. That changes the game. Not everyone will agree to such a policy. And you just need one player to disagree to make it impractical. Case in point: 9/11 attacks were shown on TV repeatedly - because there was more than 1 player who could do the broadcasting.
- gojomo 17y agoI don't think incidents could (or should) be completely hidden, as in the sporting example. But they could be less promoted. We don't all have to magnify the events. Each news site (and voter) can decide where they want to play on the information continuum. Should News.YC be more gotcha-tabloid-if-it-bleeds-it-leads, or less?
- haydenchambers 17y agoso just to make sure this is clear... on a site titled "Hacker news" you don't want hacking to be in the news?
- wendroid 17y agoBut the viewers want them to cut to the streaker