5 ms·
Let's put your idea to the test. There's allegedly around 200,000 patents that can cover smartphones. Everything from how they look to how they can connect to p
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Let's put your idea to the test. There's allegedly around 200,000 patents that can cover smartphones. Everything from how they look to how they can connect to putting voice over a data line. Try to design a standards-compliant smartphone that runs common apps with understandable interface that doesn't infringe on patents. You will have to read and consult hundreds of thousands of claims regularly as you make every detail.
Realistically, you'll just (a) not get into that market at all or (b) ignore the patents then fight with or pay whoever comes after you. Apple vs Samsung is a nice example of where (b) can go but most choose (a).
- incepted 11y ago> Let's put your idea to the test. My idea has already been put to the test and proven correct: the US is the most innovative country in the software area. And has been for decades. The scenario you are proposing is unrealistic because that's not how the system works. Otherwise, we would never have had the iPhone, Android nor the BlackBerry. Now try to understand why the system works despite your understanding of it.
- gnaritas 11y ago> My idea has already been put to the test and proven correct: the US is the most innovative country in the software area. And has been for decades. That doesn't prove your idea correct; it's likely the case we're innovative despite patents, not because of them, because developers largely ignore them and just code whatever they want anyway. > The scenario you are proposing is unrealistic because that's not how the system works. The system doesn't work, that's rather the point; the entire software industry, which you're going on about, largely ignores them, or collects them as weapons of defense against other companies.
- incepted 11y ago> That doesn't prove your idea correct; it's likely the case we're innovative despite patents No. My claim is simply: "The US is the most innovative country in the world in terms of software, and has been for the past decades". This is a fact. Your claim is: "This has happened DESPITE patents". There is little to no evidence for your claim and the burden of proof is on you. > The system doesn't work, that's rather the point It it didn't work, the US would not be the most innovative software country in the world. It is, therefore your claim is wrong. The system works. Could it work better? Sure. Propose a solution and show some evidence that your solution will be better than the current situation. Then we can talk.
- gnaritas 11y ago> It it didn't work, the US would not be the most innovative software country in the world. False, you're claiming we're this innovative because of patents; the burden of proof is upon you to link our success to patents. In the software industry in particular, your claim is just absurd and programmers know it. > It is, therefore your claim is wrong. The system works. Incorrect, our lead in innovation does not logically lead to the conclusion that our patent system works well. That you think it does indicates a failure of logic on your part. Innovation happens with or without patents, patents by their very nature slow it down by preventing others from innovating. Patents have never increased innovation, that isn't their purpose; their purpose is to prevent innovation from disappearing into trade secrets and add it to the collective human knowledge. They do this by hampering innovation in favor of the original innovator in exchange for disclosure of the innovation. > Your claim is: "This has happened DESPITE patents". There is little to no evidence for your claim and the burden of proof is on you. There's mountains of evidence, it's found in how companies now use patents, as legal weapons to defend themselves from other companies and their hoards of patents. That's not what the system was designed to do. And now patent trolls, the existence of which are quite literal prove the system is broken. Lets be clear, because someone else's argument fails isn't proof that yours is correct; your arguments have to stand on their own and so far you're not making your own case at all. If you want to defend patents, then defend them, you're not just right because someone else is wrong nor is our lead in innovation proof that patents work. Logic doesn't work that way. And take note, you're talking to multiple people here.
- incepted 11y ago> False, you're claiming we're this innovative because of patents I never made that claim. All I said is that the US is the most innovative country in terms of software. That's my claim and it's fact. People who say that the system is broken need to first reconcile their claim with my statement of fact. And they're doing a terrible job at providing proof of their claims besides saying "the system is broken". > That's not what the system was designed to do. And now patent trolls, the existence of which are quite literal prove the system is broken. That's absurd exaggeration. The system is not broken, it has flaws. Fix the flaw that enabled patent trolls and the system will get even better than it is today. > you're not just right because someone else is wrong nor is our lead in innovation proof that patents work. Logic doesn't work that way. Totally agree. Good thing I did none of that.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoMost of the patents files for software are by big companies. Most innovations come from startups, academics, and volunteers in FOSS. Most of it was protected by copyright law with money recouped in licensing and acquisitions. Now try to understand why innovation existed outside patent motivations. Then look up what big companies do with all those patents. Only then will you see the real effect of the patent system.
- jb613 11y ago> Most innovations come from startups, academics, and volunteers in FOSS. Not sure you can lump 3 very different types of entities into one group. I agree with your 1st type (startups) but what about #2 (academics) and #3 (FOSS volunteers) - what are some examples that "most innovations" come from them?
- rayiner 11y agoUniversities are big filers of patents, so that leaves startups and FOSS. The latter do a lot of innovative application, but not much invention. If you look at something like a smart phone. The UI was developed at a big company, using ideas originally developed at big corporate R&D labs. The CPU and wireless chips were all designed at big companies. The LCD and touch screen technology is all developed at big companies. The only big FOSS part (the Linux core of Android), is a clone of something (UNIX), invented in a big corporate R&D lab.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoEven with your counters, it seems innovation would continue via academic grant money and R&D by big companies for differentiation.
- pcwalton 11y agoFOSS has its fair share of research. You just don't hear about it as often as you hear about the more engineering-focused FOSS projects, for the same reasons you don't hear about the research projects big companies do as much as their flagship engineering projects. (How many people have heard of Midori compared to Windows? I'd wager it's the same ratio, speaking in orders of magnitude, as the number of people who have heard of the Glasgow Haskell Compiler vs. GCC, both of which are FOSS. I could name many other examples just in the PL domain.) Now you might say that a lot of those open source research projects are funded by big companies, so they don't count. But most development on popular open source projects is funded by big or medium-size companies. Research isn't any different in this regard. I think it's no accident that most of your examples are hardware, not software. The problem there is that open source hardware is difficult to make work, not that open source research is difficult to make work. The other main example you gave is Unix, but FOSS didn't exist in 1973--of course it wasn't open source by the modern definition. Its research successor, Plan 9, was open source. Disclaimer: I work on one of those open source research projects.
- mattlutze 11y ago> The scenario you are proposing is unrealistic because that's not how the system works. Otherwise, we would never have had the iPhone, Android nor the BlackBerry. Those companies built their phones then spent tens/hundreds of millions of dollars in lawsuits fighting each other's basic patents and infringements thereof. That would appear to be option b in the parent's scenario. Big companies can afford to take that risk. Small companies end up having to sell to bigger companies or close down when core tech is threatened by patent challenges.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoWell-said. That's exactly what I'm arguing. The patent suits, the cost, and the results work against innovation. This is provable by looking at patent-holders' behavior then what resulted from it. The combo of market forces, legal threats, and silo-ing led the industry to be an oligopoly among a handful of companies with two, large OS's. Apple's patents and position led them to make insane profits close to $100 billion. Yet, their innovation isn't significantly greater than the more open alternative. The money goes goes into their pocket, mostly, plus some R&D and lots of lawsuits. The true result of the U.S. patent system: making owners money.
- monochromatic 11y agoThat's not putting his idea to the test.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIf he's right about innovation part, most of the innovation in the mobile space should come from patent-loving groups instead of companies selling phones, companies selling apps, academics, or FOSS volunteers. Currently, most innovation is from non-patent side. If he's right about motivation, we should see all kinds of innovation in the mobile space with goal of licensing or selling resulting patents. That group is such a small percentage of overall activity in that sector so as to be nearly non-existent. So, we have motivation for innovation (i.e. sell stuff) plus tons of innovators without people relying on patents or filing lots of them. The patent system isn't helping here. However, suits like Apple vs Samsung, Oracle vs Google, and so on show patent holders do use it to try to eliminate competition and ensure stagnation for profits. So, we have no provable need for patent system for innovation, proof that innovation happens anyway, and proof patents are used to remove competition in a way that harms consumers. Whether fully or not, his model of patent system = innovation boost is tested enough to reject it for mobile software. Similar arguments apply to software in general.