3 ms·
Well that's all very moral, but what Theranos is doing is mostly engineering. So while "hype the fuck out of it, raise big money, and fake it 'till you make it"
by Zigurd 11y ago
Well that's all very moral, but what Theranos is doing is mostly engineering. So while "hype the fuck out of it, raise big money, and fake it 'till you make it" might feel all icky, it's not a unique plan.
Will we be saying the same things about Palantir? Maybe, maybe not. There's not that much difference between Palantir and Theranos. What has Palantir got that others don't? Answer: The ability to raise money at incredible valuations. Both are living off a mythologized ("PayPal has great fraud detection" and "you don't need an incompetent phlebotomist poking holes in your arm") advantage. We'll see if they can turn all that money into a real advantage.
But you can't count on science to spank these people.
- jjoonathan 11y agoThat's what I thought at first, but $400M and 12 years should have been enough to put together a pretty solid uTAS seeing as microfluidic integration wasn't exactly bleeding edge back then either. But they seem to have drunk their own kool-aid and created a working environment so toxic that they sabotaged their own chances to fake it till they made it. They might still get there, but even if they do there's a lesson to be had about expectation management. EDIT: to clarify, I'm not the source of downvotes. Before the recent media explosion I believed exactly as you did.
- Zigurd 11y agoSomehow the ability to spend money scales pretty well relative to the ability to raise it.
- XorNot 11y agoAnyone working in microfluidics would've been skeptical at the time and is probably not surprised now. Microfluidics is amazingly hard to make work properly, and the history of the field is littered with great ideas which proved to be much harder to execute reliably.
- ThomPete 11y agoPalantir is not making binary claims which can be proven right or wrong. Palantir is making tools which can be used and interpreted different ways. They are much more like vitamins.
- Zigurd 11y agoThis is a very important point in favor of Palantir. While there is much to be said for the placebo effect in medicine, Palantir's customers can more readily convince themselves Palantir works. On the other hand, you've either got herpes or you don't.