5 ms·
Former Columbia House insiders explain the shady math behind “8 CDs for a penny”
- DrScump 11y agoDid the article ever get to why Columbia House failed? I gave up due to the obnoxious ad load (eleven external sites according to Ghostery), and that obnoxious Timescapes moving ad (which reloaded from the beginning with every text scroll, which means every 1-3 paragraphs) slowed it down to the point of being unreadable.
- supercanuck 11y agoPeople started ripping their huge CD Collections (essentially digital masters) and sharing them on Napster and P2P Networks.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoIt failed for the same reason that the music industry failed. People stopped buying CDs, so loss-leading divisions were eliminated.
- mystikal 11y agoThe music industry failed?
- mixmastamyk 11y agoMore or less, when revenues drop 50% ... things change, have a point?
- mystikal 11y agoShrinkage is not failure. I know plenty of pro music biz people.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoI meant "as we know it". There are large parts that did not survive, such as this one, and music videos for example.
- mystikal 11y agoI see what you mean, but I think maybe "disruption" or "upheaval" is a better way to characterize the changes than "failure". Also, music videos are still made and widely watched on YouTube - again disruption rather than failure.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoYep, it was just a sub-optimal word choice, a bit too strong.
- mystikal 11y agoNo worries, I just like to argue :)
- wpietri 11y agoThe article talked a lot about how for many people Columbia House was their main access to buying music. My guess is that they made their money on people who kept subscribing because it was either the easy way or the only way for them to get new music. But between internet-enabled mail order for CDs and the later rise of things like Napster, Columbia House no longer solved a problem for most music fans.
- hakutsuru 11y agoColumbia House was a multi-format business, very sensitive to "hits", which experienced booms when new formats were being adopted. It catered to collectors, not with "quality" per se, but convenience and bargains. (Recognizing the weird/sleazy negative-option element, it was possible to use Columbia House to amass product at a discount while playing by the rules, as explain by others.) The CD boom pushed the company toward $2 Billion annual revenue. Take these numbers as fuzzy. Revenue definitely dropped, but it was still sizable for music, though the music clubs became much less profitable... When Bertelsmann acquired Columbia House to eliminate the competition for BMG, the music clubs were shut down. While I can sympathize with people calling Columbia House a failed business, its music business did not fail.
- jlgaddis 11y agoMy first job out of high school was entering those Columbia House applications into a computer database. The amount of fake applications I, personally, came across was astounding. I can remember, on my first day, coming across a batch of applications that were so obviously all from the same person -- different CD selections (six-digit numbers, if memory serves) and different names but the same mailing address and same handwriting. I went up to ask my supervisor what I should do about them and was told to enter them in regardless. Basically, it did not matter one bit if the apps were fake or fraudulent. My job was to enter them into the computer. It was explicitly NOT my job to decide whether they were legitimate or not. I wondered then how they managed to make any money. Even before I worked there, though, it was common knowledge amongst my friends in high school that you could put whatever information you wanted to on the applications and the CDs would still come in the mail.
- cpeterso 11y agoInteresting! Did your office have a quota or bonus that depended on how many applications were entered? It sounds like some perverse incentive that made sense at corporate HQ but had unintended side effects. :)
- jlgaddis 11y agoISTR we had a minimum number of applications we were supposed to process (averaged out over a period of time), but I can't recall what that number was.
- bryanrasmussen 11y agosurely filtering out the false applications should have been the task of programmers / DB admins once the data was all in the DB.
- jlgaddis 11y agoOne would hope so but the evidence (CDs showing up in the mail) didn't tend to support that assumption. In addition, this was nearly 20 years ago so the technology wasn't as great as it is today. If memory serves, our interface was a DOS-based application with our PCs networked using Netware, if that says anything.
- brandonmenc 11y agoFrom the article: "There is an alternative to [Spotify], in getting outside of it, but only if we have net neutrality. If they really fuck with net neutrality, then I don’t know what independent musicians are going to do. Right now, you can go up on Bandcamp and you can put out your record, and they take their 15 percent cut, and you can make a fair amount of money selling a couple hundred CDs. You can do okay. But if that kind of freedom is taken away, then it’s going to be a really strange game." This is some bizarre logic that has filtered down into the general population - that if ISPs are allowed to prioritize traffic, it inevitably leads to people not being allowed to sell zip files of their band's music. It's a ridiculous conclusion to draw.
- logn 11y agoIt depends how you interpret non-neutrality: 1. Laws written to allow different "lanes" of traffic, with protections that prohibit censorship and don't raise the bar of entry for websites. 2. Providers mostly have free reign to slow/stop any data that crosses their network and charge anyone however they want. Given Facebook's internet.org and similar "zero-rating" schemes, I'm not sure you can dismiss argument 2 so easily.
- chrischen 11y agoSpotify could make the argument that they are willing to provide free unlimited music streaming to impoverished Americans (as an altruistic act of course) by partnering with ISPs (of course Spotify will still serve ads to these users). They would pump their millions of dollars as a large player in the industry into this effort, and music listening becomes de-facto based on the Spotify platform because they've invested in a deal that would bring free music streaming to the masses of impoverished and (musically) underserved Americans. Smaller streaming services such as Bandcamp, with their selfish capitalistic intent on charging for their services directly, cannot compete with the pervasiveness and free-ness of Spotify services. People cannot fathom why they would pay to buy music when Spotify is so generously providing it for free (faster loading, free, and doesn't use up their data allotments!) included in their ISP plan. Far down in the future Spotify realizes they don't have to improve their services anymore. They realize "hey altruistic act we did is actually a great indirect way to pay to make our competitor's services worse, instead of investing in making our services better." By paying to prioritize their traffic at the network level, Spotify realized they can leverage their existing size, money, and power to simply hold down the competition at the ISP level rather than rise up above them in the product level.
- wsc981 11y agoThe whole business was premised on this concept called negative option. Which just sounds so creepy and draconian and weird, but the idea that if you don’t say no, we’re going to send you shit. It’s going to fill your mailbox, and we’re going to keep sending it unless you panic and beat us back. That was how the money was getting generated. Interesting article, but a bit too long. I think in The Netherlands (and perhaps Belgium) there was this 'book club' that shared the same 'negative option' business model.
- malz 11y agoIn the US it is Book of the Month Club (surprisingly still in business). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_of_the_Month_Club https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_of_the_Month_Club
- selimthegrim 11y agoSounds like Blue Apron took notes.
- cafard 11y agoIndeed, I joined Book of the Month Club to get the introductory offer of the two volume OED cheaply, and ended up leaving after paying $50 for stuff that I just didn't want. I still have the OED, but I couldn't tell you what the other books were. I do, however, remain the pain of writing the $50 check, which was a good deal of money for me then.
- hakutsuru 11y agoYes, and the wiki is relevant... Columbia House, BMG and Bookspan were mashed together years ago. While Columbia House could a Dilbertesque nightmare, the Machiavellianism I watched unfold in Garden City was remarkable.
- techdragon 11y agoFor extra examples, see the non advertising components of the revenue models behind the majority of adult entertainment companies charging subscriptions on the Internet.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoYes, good memories. I was a member of Columbia and BMG clubs many times over the years, often with multiple memberships at a time for a decade or so in/after high school. Note: this article does not explain the math at all, it is mostly about paying rent in Manhattan. Despite what the article implies, it was easy to figure out if you can use a calculator and was an awesome deal. Add up the cost for all discs total, then divide by the number of them and voila, you'd end up paying something like $4.XX per CD with shipping. Which was amazing when stores were selling albums for $16 +/- $2. Then you'd cancel as soon as you tired of the mailings. I never knew why they did it but I didn't care. In fact I built my ~500 CD selection that way. Probably 1/2 to 2/3 came from the clubs. Many of the rest bought used. Topical story because I just pulled them out of storage and are ripping them a final time to .flac and then will send them off somewhere. Any tips on a service for that? I had found an interesting startup last year that would take your collection in bulk, rip, and put you in a marketplace to trade with others. But, unfortunately I've already lost the name and can't find it again. edit: did the dvd club also around Y2k, was great also for a round or two before getting the axe. That was about the time a friend got me a DirecTV descrambler card so didn't sweat it.
- wpietri 11y ago> Then you'd cancel as soon as you tired of the mailings. I never knew why they did it but I didn't care. My guess: you were an unusual customer. I suspect the more typical case was somebody who never canceled and was not very disciplined about rejecting the selection of the month. So maybe they broke even or lost money on you. But they'd do well on the typical consumer, so it was fine by them.
- keithpeter 11y agoA couple of quotes from the OA >> “You’re not supposed to be enjoying yourself this much,” even though we were incredibly productive. << Is it possible to have fun, go home at 6pm, and still be productive any more? >> Especially looking at my younger friends in their late 20s, I feel bad for them, because they’re grinding. They’re working their asses off. They’re working so much harder than we did, and they’re barely having time for their own projects. One thing about the fat, Clintonian, CD money years, is that in New York, you could still skim off some of the industry money and be an artist. << Is this just an attack of the Good Old Days syndrome or is it evidence of a trend that will eventually cause the ossification of our cities? PS: UK: Book of the month style 'clubs' had books in 'club edition' bindings to differentiate them. They did that default option is you bought that month's book deal as well. My parents did it for a bit, then stopped it.