7 ms·
No matter how this story ends (whether they eventually ends up with having a fully functioning product or not) this should be a cautionary tale to anyone wantin
by ThomPete 11y ago
No matter how this story ends (whether they eventually ends up with having a fully functioning product or not) this should be a cautionary tale to anyone wanting to actually change the world in healthcare.
Science speaks for itself and does not care how much you raised at what valuation. It requires a rigorous approach to testings and facts and data or it will be merciless if you aren't living up to your own claims.
So hopefully next time someone has a great disruptive idea in healthcare, they will spend a little more time getting the science and tech right before they start worrying about becoming a unicorn.
- krmboya 11y ago"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be fooled" - Richard Feynman
- trhway 11y agohow about reality distortion fields?
- Zigurd 11y agoWell that's all very moral, but what Theranos is doing is mostly engineering. So while "hype the fuck out of it, raise big money, and fake it 'till you make it" might feel all icky, it's not a unique plan. Will we be saying the same things about Palantir? Maybe, maybe not. There's not that much difference between Palantir and Theranos. What has Palantir got that others don't? Answer: The ability to raise money at incredible valuations. Both are living off a mythologized ("PayPal has great fraud detection" and "you don't need an incompetent phlebotomist poking holes in your arm") advantage. We'll see if they can turn all that money into a real advantage. But you can't count on science to spank these people.
- jjoonathan 11y agoThat's what I thought at first, but $400M and 12 years should have been enough to put together a pretty solid uTAS seeing as microfluidic integration wasn't exactly bleeding edge back then either. But they seem to have drunk their own kool-aid and created a working environment so toxic that they sabotaged their own chances to fake it till they made it. They might still get there, but even if they do there's a lesson to be had about expectation management. EDIT: to clarify, I'm not the source of downvotes. Before the recent media explosion I believed exactly as you did.
- Zigurd 11y agoSomehow the ability to spend money scales pretty well relative to the ability to raise it.
- XorNot 11y agoAnyone working in microfluidics would've been skeptical at the time and is probably not surprised now. Microfluidics is amazingly hard to make work properly, and the history of the field is littered with great ideas which proved to be much harder to execute reliably.
- ThomPete 11y agoPalantir is not making binary claims which can be proven right or wrong. Palantir is making tools which can be used and interpreted different ways. They are much more like vitamins.
- Zigurd 11y agoThis is a very important point in favor of Palantir. While there is much to be said for the placebo effect in medicine, Palantir's customers can more readily convince themselves Palantir works. On the other hand, you've either got herpes or you don't.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- late2part 11y agoAgreed! And confidence in theories is needed to persevere to get true evidence. But if the evidence disproves the theory - adapt. To ignore this is hubris.
- harryh 11y agoShould Bill Gates have spent a little more time actually writing an operating system before selling one to IBM? Fake it 'till you make it is often an important part of success.
- leftnode 11y agoI think the point is you can't fake it till you make it in medical science, and if you can, the outcomes usually aren't great.
- dinkumthinkum 11y agoBut he did license them an OS that like worked, not a promissory note that may be like near Star Trek technology.
- ryandrake 11y agoScience and results don't care about secrecy and PR either. As far as I can tell, the only purpose of this company is to provide the media with a steady stream of glamour shots of the CEO so they can fawn over her and promote the never ending "pretty Stanford dropout founds a company and is like Steve Jobs" narrative.
- beagle3 11y agoIt is a common, romantic view of how science works - but it is only compatible with reality on a 30-50 year timescale, and probably only because of survivor bias. The science of Dan Shchetman, J. Robin Warren, Barbara McClintock and many others spoke for itself, and for a long time "science" essentially didn't listen. I put "science" in quotes because "science" doesn't speak or listen - scientists do - and the scientists shunned those luminaries (eventually to recognize them with one of the highest honours - the Nobel Prize). Warren had to use himself as a test subject for others to notice. Shechtman was a cast out for years (and then it turned out that he wasn't the first to notice 5-fold symmetry - he was just the only one for a long time to insist it's real; the other "scientists" who noticed it cared too much about their status, rather than the science). McClintock was shunned by her peers and essentially lost her job -- though evidence for how badly she was treated by "science" for her radical ideas (now mainstream and assumed true) is being whitewashed. I keep wondering how much progress we have lost because "scientists" (unlike "science") does care how much you've raised, how much you've published, and who your friends are. > anyone wanting to actually change the world in healthcare ... Science speaks for itself The belief that modern healthcare is nothing but the application of science is also romantic and misguided. In the US, healthcare is a business and not even a free-market one. It is informed by science, most definitely. But e.g. no doctor will recommend the single most effective treatment for type 2 diabetes early in the disease[0] (calorie restriction whether directly, by direct fasting or intermittent fasting). In fact, it turns out that the American Diabetic Association recommendations are the everything but science, and possibly the worst you could do. [0] - http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/may/12/type-2-diabetes-diet-cure http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/may/12/type-2-d..., see http://www.ncl.ac.uk/magres/research/diabetes/reversal.htm http://www.ncl.ac.uk/magres/research/diabetes/reversal.htm for references
- pdonis 11y agoI agree that good science often doesn't get recognized because it happens to rub some established scientists the wrong way. However, the issue with Theranos is the opposite: it is getting recognized, even though we don't know whether it's good science or not, because there isn't any visibility into what they do and how they do it. The scientists you mention all published their work for the world to see; they didn't hide behind "trade secrets". > The belief that modern healthcare is nothing but the application of science is also romantic and misguided. I agree with this too; but again I don't see how it applies to Theranos, because they are explicitly claming that what they are doing is science. So they should be judged by scientific standards, even if the rest of the health care industry can't live up to those standards.