2 ms·
The problem with that bit from the Economist is that it no data were presented to back it up. When it comes to these topics, there's pretty sloppy journalism al
by paulddraper 11y ago
The problem with that bit from the Economist is that it no data were presented to back it up. When it comes to these topics, there's pretty sloppy journalism all around, including the original NY Times article.
The Atlantic article just quotes the IZA article, which is about wealth transfer in Sweden, not income. Wealth is heavily affected by spending habits; income less so. And t Telegraph and NY Times articles don't offer anything concrete on the subject.
The Pew source does address the subject. The key part is:
> Approximately half of parental income advantages are passed on to children. The IGE [intergenerational elasticity], when averaged across all levels of parental income, is estimated at 0.52 for men and 0.47 for women.
(That means that if someone earns $40k above average, their children can be expected to earn $20k above average.)
In comparison, IGE in UK is 0.5, France is 0.41, and Denmark is 0.15. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c7/Intergenerational_mobility_graph-1.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c7/Intergen...
IGE studies are somewhat scarce, but that's no excuse for the original NY Times making a bunch of unsubstantiated implications.