7 ms·
Chevrolet Volt Extends Its Appeal
- ebbv 11y agoThe battery capacity is increasing by only 7.6% (from 17.1 KWh to 18.4 KWh) but they are claiming an increase electric only mode range of 51% (35 miles to 53 mlles.) I wonder where all the extra range is coming from. My Leaf gets a claimed 80-90 mile range on its 24 KWh battery, so proportionally the 53 miles on 18.4 would make sense, but remember the Volt is carrying around an ICE and all its trappings (it foregoes the drivetrain for the ICE, but it still needs lubrication, cooling, intake, exhaust, etc.) so the volt weighs about 300 lbs more than the Leaf (which is ~10%), and that's going to have an efficiency cost. Also, I should point out the leaf has had a 25% battery capacity increase in the new model, which should result in a direct 25% range increase since the new battery takes up the exact same space and weight as the old one.
- pcl 11y agoAlso, I should point out the leaf has had a 25% battery capacity increase in the new model, which should result in a direct 25% range increase since the new battery takes up the exact same space and weight as the old one. How did they pull that off? Is it a different battery chemistry?
- bonestamp2 11y agoI don't know for sure about the leaf, but if you look at the original Tesla battery it was created by combining a lot of smaller batteries which wastes a lot of space (double cell walls, more external connectors, etc).
- pcl 11y agoOh interesting... so by removing the walls and connectors, they could be net-neutral in mass. Makes sense.
- lumberjack 11y agoThey upgraded the range extender as well. Since it's more powerful it allows for the battery to be depleted further before it needs to definitely kick in which allows for a greater electric only range.
- dwhall 11y agoThe Gen 2 Voltec drivetrain has two motor/generators, two planetary gearsets, an abundance of clutches and the ICE. This allows the system to be used in five distinct drive modes ( http://gm-volt.com/2015/02/20/gen-2-volt-transmission-operating-modes-explained/ http://gm-volt.com/2015/02/20/gen-2-volt-transmission-operat... ). The all-electric range increase is proportionally greater than the battery capacity increase because the new drive system uses two-motor drive mode more often than the first gen drive system.
- Gravityloss 11y agoThis is very fascinating, new mechanical approaches proliferate! Koenigsegg has the total opposite approach in their hybrid Regera supercar: no gearboxes at all. Low speed high torque is delegated to the electric motors, and the internal combustion engine only engages after a certain speed. http://jalopnik.com/how-the-1-500-hp-koenigsegg-regera-hits-248-mph-without-1689181377 http://jalopnik.com/how-the-1-500-hp-koenigsegg-regera-hits-... I think that is a potentially fruitful approach.
- malyk 11y agoMy 2014 volt regularly gets 42 miles on battery only which would change your calculations a bit.
- dmitriy_ko 11y agoWhere and at what speed do you usually drive? I don't get more than 35 miles on battery on my 2015 Volt, but most of my driving is on freeways in off-traffic hours.
- malyk 11y agoLots of short side street trips (groceries, hardware, parks) and a few longer trips (hiking nearby, weekwnd getaways, etc) but I only drive it on the weekends. I take transit to work. Highway driving is brutal on the battery (in a mileage capacity per charge...wind resistance and whatnot).
- darksim905 11y agoDoes it even have a traditional exhaust? The engine makes such little noise when it's even using gas.
- technotarek 11y agoDoes anyone here have experience with / an opinion about the Ford C-Max? We're about to enter the new car market and are pitting the Volt against it and the Prius. (The new 2016 Prius is so ugly, though, that it's starting to fall off our radar.)
- chucky_z 11y agoThe C-Max is a very utilitarian vehicle. It's more Mazda 5 than Volt/Prius. That being said, they sure do have a nice interior for that style of car!
- secabeen 11y agoI've ridden in one, seems fine.
- dwhall 11y agoTL;DR: Driving electric is sublime and among the 3 you listed, only the Volt lets you do it for a significant number of miles. Disclosure: extremely satisfied 2013 Volt owner here. I test drove every form of electric-augmented automobile available for sale in the midwest (some plug-ins are for sale only on the coasts, so don't have trained repairmen near me). The C-Max had a useful form factor. It would fit my family with legroom in the rear, although the energi's trunk space was severely compromised by the extra battery. Loading groceries would block the lower 30% view. The C-Max's engine was noisy, annoyingly so. Also, Ford was caught misrepresenting their MPGs and had to readjust them. I drove a C-Max and a C-Max energi (the plug-in). Between the two, I'd prefer the energi because it runs 100% electric some of the time (but nowhere near what the Volt can do), but the price difference was not justified. www.gm-volt.com is a great resource for prospective and actual owners. From there I learned that buying a used Volt was a good idea and a great deal for these reasons: 1) used Volt prices are outrageously low for a high-quality car, albeit compact. 2) Reading the dash computer's "lifetime mpg" will let you know (with some reverse math) how many of the miles on the odometer come from the combustion engine vs electric. This is important because a Volt with 30K miles may only have 10-12K miles on gas; the rest electric. And since the electric drivetrain has a 8yr/100,000mi warranty, you're covered. 3) There are guys reporting their Volt's battery still taking 90% of their original charge after reaching 100,000 miles. 4) The guys taking ownership of the 2016 Volt are reporting 50-60 miles all-electric range and quite a bit more punch when putting the pedal down. edit: Added TL;DR
- secabeen 11y agoJust as a note prices on used Model S's are lower than you might expect. There's a model S listed for $48k from Tesla today, and there was one at $43k in the last few weeks. Some buyers have mentioned that even lower-priced Tesla's are sold without ever reaching the public list, so if you were in contact with your local Tesla location, they might be able to find one for you for under $40k. http://ev-cpo.com/ http://ev-cpo.com/ is a nice aggregator for the public listings.
- loarabia 11y agoNice site. That seems like a surprisingly fast depreciation rate. I would have thought Teslas would hold their value longer compared to other cars.
- crabasa 11y agoThe increased rate of innovation (measured in months rather years) that is customary in SV has the perverse effect of hurting resale value. Think of how quickly an iPhone depreciates. This is good for bargain hunters but increases the cost of ownership for original owners.
- superuser2 11y agoYou can get a much better car for the price of a Model S. The price premium pays for prestige/coolnesss over stodgy old BMW/Porsche/Lexus, which is dampened signifantly in the used market.
- r00fus 11y agoCan you name one? For ~$55k, it's tempting to go gas-free even on my 75mi roundtrip commute as opposed to my 50mpg (10yo) Prius. Other options are non-viable at that range.
- superuser2 11y agoModel S starts at $69k. That's a lot of car. The model Consumer Reports gave 100/100 to is the P85D, at $105k. That's a ridiculous amount of car. If you're looking at sedans/coupes: BMW M235i or 328d xDrive ($50k), BMW 5-series ($60k) Mercedes E250 diesel ($63k), Audi A6 ($56k), Porsche Boxster ($59k). I wouldn't be sad about my money going to fund cool battery technology and saving the environment. But you could also use it to buy more car. The price premium for Tesla over a similar gas or diesel luxury vehicle is conservatively $20k (since the BMW M and 5-series are closer to the P85D than the base Model S). Figure diesel is at $2.50. The 328d and E250 both get close to 40mpg highway. You'd have to drive more than 300,000 miles to break even on the electric, and that's before you consider the price of electricity.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoKnock $6K off the price, bump the electric range to 100 miles and gasoline range to 400 miles (500 total) and you have the car of the future. Congratulations to GM/Chevrolet for continuing to be innovative in this sector. I just wish Chevrolet would move a little faster with its release cycle; five years is a long time to take for what amounts to an incremental improvement. Unfortunately for them, the new Volt arrives just as fuel prices hit a low of $2/gallon, which when adjusted for inflation is the same as in 1971 (about $0.50). Of course, fuel prices will rise again at some point, but the American car market has a short term mentality; when fuel prices are low, large vehicle sales rise, and vice versa. The Volt will probably continue to do well in the niche market of local urban commuting. The average Volt owners are going 900 miles between fill ups, and the larger battery will probably raise this number.
- IndianAstronaut 11y agoSome electricity companies in Texas offer reduced or free nighttime electricity. Ideal for charging a Volt.
- grhmc 11y agoHow about the $7,500 tax credit?
- rhino369 11y ago50 miles is more than enough for a car with a gasoline backup tank for most use cases. Average car users use below 50 almost every single day. Something like 98-98% of trips are under 50 miles. 95% of people commute less than 40 miles. Adding more weight and room for only a small percent of rides is probably less efficient (economically and ecologically) than just popping into gas for 5% of trips.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoPerhaps that was the results of their analysis, I don't know. I used to have a 27 mile commute in the Phoenix/Scottsdale area, so even the 53-mile range might not have been sufficient. Every extra 10 miles you add to the range will make the vehicle that much more useful for a wider category of drivers (in terms of staying in electric mode and avoiding burning gasoline). At some point perhaps they see it as diminishing returns, except that really when it comes to electric vehicles, the more range the better.
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoIf/when they update the Cadillac equivalent I'm going to miss being able to say that my 20yo truck with the economy engine is faster than a new Caddy. That said, this is a step in the right direction for electric cars. I've always thought an incremental transition from hybrids was the way to go and that's basically what the Volt it.
- csours 11y agoThere is not an upgrade currently planned for the ELR, but the 2017 CT6 does have a PHEV drivetrain option. I find the electric drivetrain much more satisfying even with lower 0-60 numbers, as you have all the torque all the time. I do wish GM also worked on the 0-60 numbers. > The combined system is capable of producing total system power of 250 kW (335 hp) and 586 Nm (432 lb-ft) of torque. [1] Disclosure: I am a GM employee. 1. http://media.cadillac.com/media/cn/en/cadillac/vehicles/ct6_phev/2016.html http://media.cadillac.com/media/cn/en/cadillac/vehicles/ct6_...
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoThat's nice. It was kind of embarrassing for a luxury sedan to have comparable performance numbers to a 90s F-series with a 300 and 4.10s (which also has torque pretty much all the time). Those vehicles are so dissimilar it's kinda funny how close they score on the consumer (0-60, top speed) straight line performance metrics. Numbers obviously don't tell the full story but it's amusing since 0-60 and top speed are the two numbers that people that don't know cars generally care a lot about.
- csours 11y agoHave you driven an electric drivetrain vehicle? (Serious question) I've driven the 2014 ELR (for a week) and test drove a Tesla. The Tesla of course had much better acceleration[1], but even the ELR was satisfying to drive. With an electric drivetrain you don't have to downshift (or wait for a downshift in an automatic transmission). You don't have to wait for a turbo spool. You don't have to wait for any lags at all. Its really amazing, and I think it must be the future of automotive. 1. In my opinion the 2014 ELR was a beautifully styled high-luxury vehicle with mystifyingly poor performance. I don't know what they were even thinking. The 2016 was a bit better, but still suffered from (I assume) beancountering.
- bane 11y agoOne of the great things about the new hybrid drivetrains is that they're basically electric cars, but they convert gasoline to electricity locally using a gas motor and an small generator. This is different than the first few generations where the electric motor assisted a regular old dinosaur burner in day-to-day -- now the gas engines kick in to either extend range or augment the electric motors, but that's it. It's bumped efficiency up a ton and seems to have dropped prices quite a bit as the drivetrains end up with fewer big complicated moving parts. My current car is a 2015 Honda Accord Hybrid..it's described as a CVT, but actually isn't. It's an electric car with a clutch that engages an oversized generator/engine when it needs more kick. In stop and go city driving, this arrangement is actually more efficient than highway driving and I've gotten north of 50mpg pretty regularly. Range on 15 gallons of gas is ~650 miles...the car is bigger than a Prius, looks more like a normal car and drives fantastically (since Honda trickled down Acura tech into the suspension system to account for the increased weight and the electric and gas motors combined make the car pretty fast for a family sedan). The only sad thing is that Honda is skipping 2016 for this car and won't produce it until a complete redesign probably in 2017. All told, $25k for the car off the lot and I was able to get a few grand for my old car meaning I paid only slightly over $20k for this tech. From talking to Volt owners, they have a slightly superior experience in terms of the car having more of a bias towards being electric. But the car is expensive, small and performance isn't great. So I'm not sure who this is marketed towards. A bit more and you're dipping into low-end Teslas.
- dchuk 11y agoHow were you able to snag that for $25k? I'm in the market for a new car and was looking at the accord hybrid but I can't find it below $30k anywhere...
- bane 11y agoI went for the trim without navigation or leather, combined with end of model year urgency and I got several quotes from dealers ahead of time. It still took some negotiating.
- danielnaab 11y agoYears ago, my impression was that the goal of the Volt was to be fully-electric with a range-extending flex-fuel generator that recharges the batteries (rather than a hybrid approach with a separate internal combustion engine to extend range). Is this idea just totally dead for some kind of innate technical challenge? It seems that mechanically, the cost of a generator and one drive train would be preferable, if it were feasible performance-wise.
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoUnless you scale it up (diesel electric locomotive) you loose too much energy going from gen-set to motor. It makes more sense to just send the mechanical energy from the engine straight to the wheels. Generating power requires a close to static engine speed and optimizing for that is very much in conflict for optimizing the typical emissions/fuel economy/power/reliability/price criteria by which cars are assessed. It would also almost certainly be diesel.
- crabasa 11y agoThat idea is alive and well. Just look at the BMW i3: http://m.bmwusa.com/#overview_styleid91_16IB http://m.bmwusa.com/#overview_styleid91_16IB
- ams6110 11y agoHowever the combustion engine in the i3 is insufficient to power the car. It extends range only (up to 150 miles). So it's not a car you can take on a long road trip.
- ams6110 11y agoYou're talking about a series hybrid design? I.e combustion engine powers a generator which in turn powers electric drive motor(s), usually with a battery system to allow for buffering generator output and to capture power from regenerative braking. For long distance highway driving, this is less efficient since you have losses between the generator and the electric motors. It can work well for mostly stop-and-go driving and is used in hybrid buses I believe.
- darksim905 11y agoMother of God, the new Volt looks like it made love to the rest of GM. Looks like shit on the inside. These big businesses need to appeal to younger masses & people who actually care about why they buy a car.
- csours 11y agoAny particular nitpick you have?
- nikolay 11y agoI've heard people like Dave Asprey recommend people not to buy EV, because of the EMF and the health hazards. Any comments?