5 ms·
Let's see it vs a SPARC with same clockrate and/or SMP for same no of cores. Still not apples to apples but closer. Maybe some Ultrasparc 3's or something. Thr
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Let's see it vs a SPARC with same clockrate and/or SMP for same no of cores. Still not apples to apples but closer. Maybe some Ultrasparc 3's or something.
Throw in some Alphas for good measure. Then put critical routunes in PALcode. See what happens. ;)
- pmiller2 11y agoI'd be willing to bet that even if you tilt the contest in the most favorable way toward the Sparc-20, the Pi would come out on top on a cost/performance basis.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoWhoa whoa, we're talking performance not cost. Want to compare cost and performance? Use a Leon4 Quad-Core SOC on same process node so both are embedded. Otherwise, we're comparing RISC embedded on advanced node to SPARC servers on old nodes.
- pmiller2 11y ago> comparing RISC embedded on advanced node to SPARC servers on old nodes. Correct. That's the point of the article, to see how things have changed in the past 20 years.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIt sort of does that. I'd compare the early Acorn's to ARM's on Raspberry PI's. That would tell me how ARM has changed over 20 years. Optionally comparisons to older RISC and CISC architectures, esp i386.
- coderjames 11y agoI wondered about that too. In some of those benchmarks, the Pi was only 4x faster or so. But the 700 MHz Pi clock is about 12x faster than the 60 MHz SPARC. So in a same clock rate test (e.g. a theoretical 700 MHz SuperSparc), it seems like the SPARC should be faster. I have an SMP SparcStation 20 in the closet (either 2- or 4-way, can't remember). I should dig it out and run those benchmarks myself.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoA lot goes into processor performance besides clocks. Pipelines, caches, memory bandwith, timing of individual instructions... even the compiler version on same compiler. So, go ahead and give the junker a spin to see how it compares. Might surprise you.
- eschaton 11y agoIf you can, I'd love to see those benchmarks not just on SunOS 4.1 or Solaris, but on something like NetBSD 7.0 using a recent GCC or clang. It might make for a good comparison since the hardware is close to what the benchmark was originally run on. And if you're in the Bay Area and looking for a home for that system… I looked into getting one as I was writing, and while Weird Stuff and MemoryX have OK prices on CPU boards and memory, I was seeing prices of about $300 for a working SS20!
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's same range as eBay. Many of the old, RISC machines hold their value well. The SunBlade workstations still go for around $1000 if loaded. The AlphaServers are holding out well across the board: http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_odkw=Sunblade+workstation&_osacat=0&_from=R40&_trksid=p2045573.m570.l1313.TR0.TRC0.H0.Xalphaserver.TRS0&_nkw=alphaserver&_sacat=0 http://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_odkw=Sunblade+workstation&_o...
- pkaye 11y agoLets also compare them for power, noise and size.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoEspecially the Leon3 and Leon4 embedded ones. Throw in cost of processor license: up to $15 mil with royalties for ARM ISA vs $99 for SPARC ISA with implememtation a fraction of ARM's.
- pkaye 11y agoWhy would you have to license a processor? Just get an off- the-shelf board with each processor.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou have to license it to make the SOC. They only get those cheap in huge volumes. So, what people are actually saying is a huge-volume, low-margin ARM has better price-per-unit than a low-volume, premium-market alternative. No kidding lol. Even similar markets, the low licensing are why MIPS and PPC chips continue to sell at low prices even with lower volume. And SPARC has no such licensing if you do the core yourself given it's a mostly-open ISA. So, the comparison is apples to oranges in many ways. It would have to be on same process node, same clock, feature power management, high volume, and embedded board. Who knows what that comparison would be. This one is meaningless because, outside Leon's, SPARC development focuses on servers with high performance for threaded and mainframe loads with inflated prices. Case in point: https://blogs.oracle.com/rajadurai/entry/sparc_m7_chip_32_cores https://blogs.oracle.com/rajadurai/entry/sparc_m7_chip_32_co... http://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/08/29/fujitsu_sparc64_x_plus_processor/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/08/29/fujitsu_sparc64_x_pl...
- Theodores 11y agoIMHO 'the newer Suns' (as in the pizza box things that are now 2 decades old) always felt slow compared to other boxes I was using at the time. The OpenLook window manager was also a bit naff compared to what else was going. I preferred Silicon Graphics hardware back then, the user interface was as cool and responsive as it gets rather than the juddery OpenLook effort the Sun machines had. I stayed working with SGI machines when the PC's started to get really fast - Ghz clock speeds rather than the few hundred Mhz that RISC machines did back then. I felt RISC should have the higher clock speed, but it wasn't to be and SGI and other workstations died a death shortly thereafter. During those end times I spke to some SGI engineer who tried to persuade me that it really wasn't about clock speed, which was true on SGI as there was a lot you could do in the many hardware boards a typical SGI machine came with. For most actual real work the graphics pipeline would be maxed out with the CPUs (of which there could be many) doing very little. So my Raspberry Pi vs... would be Raspberry Pi vs SGI Onyx 'Infinite Reality' desk-side super-computer from some time in the mid 1990's. These usually cost real money and were tricked out - I had one with 256Mb of RAM and 64Mb of graphics RAM. Nobody had that much memory back then!!! Yet would anyone want the 256Mb PI when there is the 512 Mb version?
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"I preferred Silicon Graphics hardware back then, the user interface was as cool and responsive as it gets rather than the juddery OpenLook effort the Sun machines had." Bro, Silicon Graphics was the shit! I was studying games, AI, and supercomputing back then. Their Octane workstations with dual 200MHz MIPS plus innovative graphics were totally smoking nearly GHz Intel rigs. The NUMAlinks on Origin were giving 100+GB of RAM, dozens of CPU's, and GB/s bandwidth at microsecond latencies. They threw a room full of Onyx2 NUMA's together to blow our minds with [the graphics of] Final Fantasy. They later put FPGA's ("RASC") on NUMAlink in Altix machines to show what FPGA's could really do as accelerators if PCI bottleneck wasn't there. Anything those people did was mind-blowing for a time. Their legacy lives on in XFS, the NUMA extensions to Linux, that mainstream graphics adopted similar interconnect strategy, and that Intel's about to one-up their FPGA scheme with Altera acquisition. Not a bad list. I want them to spin off an older NUMAlink chip as a commodity for building x86 NUMA's. I still want me a MPP system with single-system image and hundreds of GB RAM on the cheap. It's 2015 but my 1990's dream still hasn't come true. Getting closer. "InfiniteReality" You mean this bad boy? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z45nbzMLk98 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z45nbzMLk98 Btw, here's the two architectures they used if you were interested in technical aspects. It's so out of date that a FOSS GPU should be able to copy it with low patent risk. Improving it would make a nice MS or PhD for academics. https://www.cs.cmu.edu/afs/cs.cmu.edu/academic/class/15869-f11/www/readings/kilgard97_realizinggl.pdf https://www.cs.cmu.edu/afs/cs.cmu.edu/academic/class/15869-f... "Yet would anyone want the 256Mb PI when there is the 512 Mb version?" Based on what I've read, anyone trying to give them muscle should go for 512MB as the 256MB is giving many commenters hell. Just too little memory. However, people doing things that aren't memory intensively, esp embedded, might be fine with a fraction of Pi's resources. Remember that even 8-bit CPU's still sell around $10 billion a year at prices under a few bucks each. That's a lot of applications and units. Meanwhile, anyone wanting an SGI-style experience today will need a combo of high-end CPU's, GPU's, and FPGA's. Pico Computing's desktops seem to fit the bill. I'm saving up for one. :) http://picocomputing.com/products/picocube/picomini/ http://picocomputing.com/products/picocube/picomini/ http://picocomputing.com/products/hpc-systems/sc6-4u/ http://picocomputing.com/products/hpc-systems/sc6-4u/